Issues with newer build, advice?

3 years ago

We built our house through a builder 2 years ago. Recently we've started noticing quite a few issues with our foundation/slab and possible settling issues. They came after 1 year and patched cracks, etc in our exterior stucco but within 6m they all reappeared. We have screws popping everywhere inside our house now, several areas that now sound like they're hollow under the slab, our garage floor will actually shift up and down when you stand on the corner of one slab, etc. Our warranty covers "structural issues" for 10 years. Are these considered structural?

Featured Answer

User

3 years ago

last modified: 3 years ago

No one here can say with certainty that these are structural issues. They sure don't sound great. You need someone on site who is a structural engineer to do a full inspection and present you with the findings in a report. It will cost a few hundred to a thousand or so depending on your area but its money well spent.

This is why I only buy old houses. If settling occurs after 100 years its expected, and the build quality/materials is/are typicalyl not achievable today. I see houses go up around me that are literally glued together. They are not built to last ten years much less a century or more.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

Izzy Mn
3 years ago
My nephew had some serious water intrusion issues. The builders would barely respond. When they did the did a minimal ineffective "fix". He hired his own private inspector to list problems and possible fixes. It was the only way he got any action... but that included a law suit. Hire your own structural professional to inspect.
PRO
Charles Ross Homes
3 years ago
Your question is really twofold: 1.) Do the symptoms indicate a structural issue that should be remedied? 2.) Will the remediation be covered by the builder's warranty?

I recommend you hire an independent inspector to evaluate the defects. A structural engineer (licensed to practice in your state) will serve you well for this purpose because they can serve as an expert witness in court if it gets to that.

With respect to your builder's warranty obligation, some states have statutory requirements builders need to meet. Here in Virginia, for example, home builders are obligated to warranty the foundation of a new home for five years. A quick call to the office that licenses contractors in your state should provide an answer to what obligations your builder has.

Best wishes for a successful outcome.
Related Discussions
Need Advice Please on how to handle a pool build issue
Q
Comments (1)
Susie, Sorry to hear that you're going through this. One thing you will learn very quickly working with these contractors. No one, absolutely, no one cares about your project more than you do. No one knows the details of your plan more than you do. You are the expert of your pool. I have a similar length pool at 7' deep and I was also concerned about the grade. I thought the pool would be 7' at the end of the pool, but it was 7' in the middle of the deep end which caused the slope to start soon and quickly. Pool is done now and I can barely touch in the middle of the pool (I'm 5'7"). My kids are older, so it's not that big of a deal to me, but there is very little space for younger kids to stand up and play. The one nice thing about the grade is that it slopes back up at the very end of the pool to the point I can get traction to stand on the end wall in the deep end if that makes sense. They probably gave you a grade that was convenient for their bobcat excavator with little regard for your meticulously laid out plans. There is plain physics involved with a 7' depth. 6' would be much more gradual. However, if it's not built to plan and you can easily demonstrate that, I would push back or consider what it would look like at a 6' depth. You may consult with another trusted pool builder, contractor, or even the building department (many are former contractors) for recommendations on how to approach it. Stay involved and ask questions at every phase. There are so many mistakes I caught by just asking questions. There are other mistakes I didn't catch, because I'm not a professional pool builder and didn't think to ask. As they say, all their work looks great from their house. Regards, Mike
...See More
Demolishing an existing house to build a newer and bigger house?
Q
Comments (34)
Thanks again for the valuable inputs. From the research so far, few things are clear: 1. Teardown will cost anywhere between $20K-$30K. 2. I could possibly remodel the house by adding another bedroom and a full bath. I am thinking that may be accomplished by using the screened-in patio space. (A1 area in the attached floorplan). 3. I do plan to stay put in this house for the forseeable future. My business and kids schools are close by (1 middle school and 1 elementary school). 4. Speaking to the village engineers, I know that I could do an expansion of the house by simply adding footers to the existing foundation. Sorry if these questions are slightly off topic and tangential: 1. Since I have to replace the roof anyway, is it possible to lift the ceiling/roof a bit? This will (I think/hope) will increase the amount of light entering the areas of the house, making it a bit more brighter. Currently, I have 8ft ceilings. 2. Currently the house has small windows and not big French doors. If I replace them with French doors or sliding doors, that should help with the daylight also? 3. How feasible is it to remove the pool and utilize some of that space for expanding the living space of the house? I understand this will adversely affect the resale value of the house. Attached is a floorplan.
...See More
Newer Microwave Just Died, Common with Newer Appliances??! Fix?
Q
Comments (30)
I like the look of the OTR, but I will not buy a Samsung again, that is for sure, and probably will not buy another OTR. Mounting them is a pain and requires new holes........every 7-10 years maybe, but after 1.5 years, no. Quality is BAD, it is an inconvenience fixing or replacing, and the whole unit then needs to get hauled somewhere probably into a landfill with the millions of other worn out things. Yes some can be recycled (also takes energy/resources). I know companies are always pushing their extended warranties now..............but things should not break after a year or so.........a company should stand behind their products for normal life and under normal use.
...See More
Need ideas and help: New build "fairytale" roof issues?
Q
Comments (18)
@Mark Bischak .Thank you so much for your very helpful comment. This is the first new idea I've seen in 2 months. Agree about the framing crew... it's one of the first questions we asked when interviewing builders. Thankfully, most builders found this roof plan to be very simple compared to the homes in our area of this size. We didn't do these radiused rooflines in our area of California, but they are thankfully very common here, so they have some experience with the swoop sections. I've heard nightmares from so many folks (no matter the style of home), but in all our years of doing this, we've had (in the end) very good experiences overall. If you find the right people at the start, almost anything can be solved. But you may be right about this one. It's not a standard farmhouse box. But it is mostly one story. In my experience that makes changes in the field a little easier. Always some risk involved. PS You should have seen the eyebrow windows and dormers in the original design. :) .That would have been complicated.
...See More
Bruce in Northern Virginia
3 years ago
If your garage floor shifts up and down from just the weight of a person, you need to hire someone ASAP to figure out what is going on. I can't even picture that happening with a cement slab and only a couple hundred pounds of weight.

Bruce
PRO
Virgil Carter Fine Art
3 years ago
Call a structural engineer for a site visit and report. Ask the engineer to bring a foundation water level to check the foundation levels inside the house to see if there is subsidence.

Does the exterior grading slope away from the house and prevent "ponding" against the foundation? Do you have gutters and downspouts, which have splash blocks to route water away from the foundation?
User
3 years ago
last modified: 3 years ago
Excessive settlement is structural. What supports a slab is structural. Some cracking is structural. A lot of screw pops could be other things like using screws that are too long or green lumber. Take one out and measure it; it's a common mistake.

Issues with newer build, advice?

User

Comments (6)

Izzy Mn

Charles Ross Homes

Related Discussions

Bruce in Northern Virginia

Virgil Carter Fine Art

User

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US