Interestingly, blue has cycled back into popularity, so your door doesn't look dated, but maybe a slightly different shade of blue would look more up to date - not sure. Or a sophisticated gray - young buyers would love it. I would remove the storm door - which DOES date the house. Put a fresh coat of paint on the shutters, use the replacement roof as a bargaining tool with the buyers. Let them mention it, agree to replace, and allow them to choose the color. Put a nice seating arrangement on the porch and some planters. I would put some money into renovating the landscaping. I would consider getting rid of the some of the large shrubs in front of the house. The plant on the right side of the sidewalk looks terrible right now. Unless it looks super wonderful when it leafs out, maybe that's not what you want there. Drive around to some builder's model homes and look at their landscaping for ideas. The cupula over the garage is darling. Maybe you could put copper siding on it? Prettier mailbox and street numbers? Prettier light fixture? Stagers tell us that potential buyers spend a few minutes at your door as the real estat agent is opening the box to get to your keys.

Could you post a close up pic of the bricks? If it were my house, I would think about painting the columns, shutters, and window surrounds all the same color that goes well with the roof and brick colors. Then I would do the door in something really bright - some shade of orange if it goes with the brick, maybe red, maybe turquoise.

Remove the shutters they actually detract form the windows the house is such a mish mash of styles i would keep the front door a simple one painted the same as the house that entry has so much going on no need for anything else.IMO the front porch is all wrong for the house and I would remove it and replace the doors with a large window to make it look like it was never a porch.Sorry but the architect that designed this house should get another job.

May we see your actual house without the mock up additions you've made, plus a close-up of the brick work for color reference? Are the colors you're suggesting part of the HOA's options? You might want to track down exactly what they want color-wise. Yes, they probably think the vestigial shutters are high style and unify the look of the community, so I doubt you can simply remove them. Start with the HOA and then bring your limited selections here for a final decision. Agree with removing the arched window inserts in the garage doors. I don't see the need for carriage hardware. Instead, spend the money to upgrade and beef up all the exterior lighting. Lights should all be 1/3 of the front door's height.