Gray with darker gray trim or even black trim would look good. What is your budget? Does it allow for a new garage door? I agree with going with the MCM vibe. The gray would probably need to be a warmer gray so it doesn't fight with the brick. If you're interested in seeing some virtual makeovers to try out different looks check out my website, Creative Visual Concepts.

I generally love black and white as a combo. But in your case you have that lovely slate roof which will always have character and will never be a crisp black like asphalt shingles. I love the suggestion of urban bronze which seems like it would go better with your roof. Gorgeous house. I hope you'll share pictures when you've finished painting.

I like weathered wood. It is a more “neutral” brown IMO and not too dark. We used weathered wood on four rental properties a few years ago and they look great still. None are Tudor style, so I can’t help you with photos. Do you have samples you can hold up next to your house? That’s the best way to see how they will look.

A McMansion, huh? Didn't know people were still pursuing this architectural design with all that had been written about avoiding this style trap. The house is huge and hulking and is mostly roof/attic. McMansion is a slang term that describes a large, often opulent or ostentatious, mass- produced house. The name carries a somewhat critical connotation because McMansions lack architectural uniqueness, class, or style. You keep referring to gray...................nothing in your current palette is gray. If they look gray to you, then there are online color blindness tests you can take to determine if you are seeing colors correctly. What's with the large brick corbels at the base of all the gables? Just another applied detail with no design basis. . Do you think you understand exactly how much roof you have on your home as currently designed??????? And how much that roof is costing you?? McMansions