Stair runner - design advice please

4 months ago

Hello, we have a simple staircase that is currently hardwood. Because our parents occasionally visit and stay upstairs, we have considered installing a bordered natural colored sisal/wool style stair runner with ~3" wood exposed on each side. Our home could be described as modern mid century leaning towards transitional. My question: When I look at other Houzz photos, I've seen some installs where they route and secure the runner under the lip of the stair and others where they transition straight down to the seam. ie, not attached to the lip other than tape (I assume). What are the design considerations when evaluating both?

Thank you in advance.

Featured Answer

elcieg

4 months ago

If you are concerned about your parents, sisal wouldn't be my first choice. Why? It can be slippery. Consider instead wool. You would want a padding under it. Go to a few of you flooring stores and see what they have for remnants. Most carpets come off the bolt at 13' wide. You may find some great $$$$ pieces for a fraction of the cost. On a personal note, I would be looking for a color that does not match the wood. We get to a certain age and we need distinctive differences.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (13)

Val B
4 months ago
When I had my stair runner installed, the carpet company said that attaching the carpet to the underneath of the lip was a more tradition look.
K Lewis thanked Val B
acm
4 months ago
I think it's always secured, but sometimes with staples. It's just a designn preference -- I think the little rods are maybe a bit fancier?

My Work · More Info

Stair Runners · More Info

Also an option: tread pads. We put them in for our large puppy, but turns out the whole family loves them.

Set of 15 Skid-Resistant Carpet Stair Treads Black Ripple, 8"x27" · More Info

Good luck!
K Lewis thanked acm
Related Discussions
Flooring, Stairs, and general design advice DESPERATELY needed
Q
Comments (14)
Judging by how the home looks now. assuming nothing is changing but the floor, i would choose a floor with tones that will draw from both the front door and the dark stairs. Perosnally, i think a walnut would look magnificent. The issue with going grey is that nothing else in the house (stair, front door, etc) have those cool tones so it may be hard to make it work. See attached photos for floors i think would look great.
...See More
Stair runner dilemma
Q
Comments (22)
I think your installer is full of it trying to pass that off as "correct". Chicagoan's mock up clearly shows how it should look. No one would look at that and think 'the runner isn't centered on the lower stairs'. It's obvious the newel post intrudes into the space on those 2 stairs - your brain does not register that as the runner is off center. It's a re-do and I don't think this should be on your dime even if the runner has to be scrapped and re-purchased. If nothing else, your hand rail is on the right and most people will walk up the stairs closer to the rail so the placement of the runner now is dangerous.
...See More
Does this pricing for a stair runner sound correct to you?
Q
Comments (35)
@clt3 I'm with you! I love numbers and have always enjoyed working with them...unless it was Trig! Boy did I have a hate on for Trig. Fast forward a few years after High School. There I was in an industry that needed to evaluate WAVE FORMS! Doh! Yah...it's amazing (tongue firmly in cheek) how much we *should know is being taught in....wait for it...SCHOOL! If only we could go back and smack our teenage-selves around a bit. Knock some sense into ourselves. That would have been SUPER helpful!
...See More
Stair Runner Design
Q
Comments (3)
I am generally on the warpath against gray, but since this will always be the first thing people see, at eye level, a gray runner will hold up really well. This house has a busy design in the entry, and you can see the gray stair runner has a subtle pattern that works
...See More
K Lewis
Original Author
4 months ago
Thank you so much Val B and acm for your suggestions and feedback. I agree that both the stair rods and the tucking of fabric under the lip of the stairs looks like a more traditional style. Appreciate you also sending along the stair treads option as well. While functional, I'm a little worried that it would bit a little more casual than the rest of the house but I'll take a look in person. Thanks again.
PRO
Beth H. :
4 months ago
last modified: 4 months ago
This one has a how two on the sisal

http://elizabethstreetpost.com/our-sisal-stair-runner-before-after/

I love the black bound sisal herringbone:

most of the sisal runners I've seen look lie this

or you could do these anti slip treads
K Lewis thanked Beth H. :
K Lewis
Original Author
4 months ago
Thank you elcieg. i appreciate the advice on sisal. i had heard something similar so while I like the look, I’ll also keep my eye out for a wool blend that has a similar look and feel without a slick finish. I hadn’t considered the color either but you make a great point. i love neutrals so I’ll have to strike a balance with the right contrasting pattern..

Beth, thank you for the photos and the install link. i also like the black bound herringbone. The binding creates a lovely finish. We have contemplated a DIY as well so I’m getting an estimate from a pro to compare.

Thanks everyone for your generous advice. I think I have everything I need. Happy Holidays!
tozmo1
4 months ago
Don't know if your parents have any low vision issues as they age but if they do, be cognizant of that when you select a runner or stair treads.

Advice from the American Academy of Ophthalmology: Stairs. Changes in the floor surface are one of the greatest fears of the visually impaired. Stairs should have a handrail, be well illuminated, and have minimal glare. Put a contrasting strip on the leading edge of each step; without that, the stairs can look like a ramp to a person with low vision.

Stair treads naturally create a leading edge (nosing) as that part of the step is exposed and contrasts with the tread when using a tread that doesn't blend with the stair color. Certain patterned rugs e.g. horizontal or vertical stripes, obliterate the effect of a leading edge and make stairs very dangerous even for those without low vision.

You may also want to consider some kind of wireless motion sensor stair lighting. Lots of options out there.
K Lewis thanked tozmo1
PRO
Diana Bier Interiors, LLC
4 months ago
We installed a sisal-look runner with black edging. Not slippery and has padding. It looks like natural sisal but it is a polypropylene, very soft and you'd never think it's not wool. Holds up great to lots of traffic in our beach house.

The installation is not a waterfall edge as you prefer, but a "Hollywood" or "French cap" installation. The carpeting is wrapped tightly over the tread and then secured to the underside of the nosing.

Rugs · More Info
K Lewis thanked Diana Bier Interiors, LLC
palimpsest
4 months ago
The installation that tucks around the nosing and its secured tightly to it is called a "Hollywood" installation, or tight/tailored installation, and the installation that is attached only at the joint of the riser and back of the tread is called "Waterfall".

A lot of the decisions are really based on the carpet style. I would never install a Persian style runner in tight/tailored manner, or anything with much of a pile, but I would probably install a berber or sisal look that way.

I was posting at the same time as Diana and see I repeated some of her information.
K Lewis thanked palimpsest
PRO
Patricia Colwell Consulting
4 months ago
I don't know how old your apaprents are but my husband is legally blind and when I ddi the stairs going to our walk out basment I did a LVP tread but a darker edge on the front of easch step to make it more visible maybe something like there would work they are non slip .
K Lewis thanked Patricia Colwell Consulting
palimpsest
4 months ago
The only steps my dad ever slipped fell on in my house were the steps Without carpet.

We never slipped and fell on the steps in our house until after we took off the carpet. We are waiting until remodeling is done to put carpet back on, but in the meantime both of us have slipped and fallen on the wood stairs.
K Lewis thanked palimpsest
K Lewis
Original Author
4 months ago
Palimpsest, Diana, Tozmot, Patricia, thank you. i am leaning so much from this discussion and as a result I am armed with more knowledge to aid in my discussion with the carpet consultant this week.
PRO
Diana Bier Interiors, LLC
4 months ago
BTW, here is a link to the wool-look sisal we installed:

https://www.stantoncarpet.com/product/FIJI%20REMIX/SADDLE

Wasn't particularly expensive either.