skip to main content

House Plants Garden Clinic Container Gardening

Why did my Money Tree spontaneously die?!?

allyssa macallister

2 years ago

This money tree has been great and super low maintenance since I got it ~8 months ago. But this week, seemingly out of nowhere, it decided to drop dead and I can't figure out why or if it's at all salvageable. I'm a little annoyed because it appears to have been over-watered, even though it has lived in one of those self-watering pots (where you pour the water into a reservoir in the bottom) so this shouldn't have happened.
A few days ago, it started looking droopy, the leaves began to turn yellow and fall off, and the trunk started to feel soft. I repotted it today, mostly so I could investigate the problem. The roots actually looked pretty good. They're small, but none were mushy or dried out. The soil, however, was soaking wet.
But then, after repotting, I carelessly grabbed the pot without thinking and the whole plant tumbled out of the soil onto the floor. One of the branches bent at the trunk and would have snapped off if it had been dry. Instead it kind of mushed off and took a little piece of the trunk with it. Where it detached, the trunk seems to have rotted - it was black and stringy/mushy inside. So I peeled back some of the wet "bark" at the base and it was totally fine - a nice tan-is solid wooden trunk.
How does this happen? The upper part of the trunk shows signs of rot, but the roots and base look fine. Is there anything I can do to salvage the tree? I can't tell if the two remaining branches are dead or not. They have always been slightly grey but continued to produce new leaves. But with the upper trunk rotted, I'd expect these branches won't be far behind....
Any advice or links to resources would be helpful!
Photos attached:
1) Money Tree on Monday when it started looking droopy (please excuse my attempt to blur out my mess)
2) Money Tree today (after repot)
3) Three distinct colors of the trunk
4) Roots - healthy, right?
5) Where branch broke off
6) Remaining branches - are they still alive?
Thank you!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (2)

tapla (mid-Michigan, USDA z5b-6a)
2 years ago
How does this happen? Ultimately, potted plants die because the grower has provided one or more cultural conditions that are beyond what the plant is genetically programmed to tolerate. In this case, soil conditions contributed to growth of a fungal pathogen which first infected the roots and moved systemically through the plant's vasculature to infect stem tissues and destroy the plant's ability to move water/nutrients efficiently. Chronic over-watering and/or a very high level of dissolved solids (salts) is/are almost undoubtedly at the root of the issue (no pun). The upper part of the trunk shows signs of rot, but the roots and base look fine. My assessment is not the same as yours. My intent isn't to make you feel diminished, but if I'm to be honest, the root system was virtually nonfunctional when the plant toppled from lack of enough roots to anchor the plant in the pot. Healthy root system:

Is there anything I can do to salvage the tree? To say yes would be false encouragement. The plant is beyond salvation, and any attempt to propagate it will end in disappointment. I can't tell if the two remaining branches are dead or not. ......... But with the upper trunk rotted, I'd expect these branches won't be far behind.... I agree with that assessment.
I'd skip the self-watering arrangement. Plants grown in these containers are disadvantaged due to the difficulty of maintaining a suitable air:moisture ratio in the medium; and, All salts from tapwater and fertilizer solutions remain in the grow medium. As they accrue, they begin to limit water/nutrient uptake, so your plant can die of thirst in a sea of plenty.

This link to an Overview of Good Growing Practices will help you avoid the major issues we all face at some point on our journey to a green thumb. If you work toward gaining an understanding of the information it contains, it will make a conspicuous improvement in your ability to keep your plants in a high state of vitality (health). That means they will also LOOK like they're healthy, which makes you feel like you're a better provider, and you likely grow things to satisfy that 'nurturing bone' almost all of us have.

Ask questions and don't be bashful about asking them.

Al
ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
2 years ago
spontaneously die?

==>>>

it really didnt die spontaneously ... it was a long process.. and may have been going on when you got it 8 months ago .... just now hitting critical mass ...

at least that is how i would justify it to myself that i am not a killer ... lol ...

regardless.. dont torture yourself ... out of sight.. out of mind.. and get another if you need that precise plant in your life ... and if not.. learn how to kill something else.. lol ..

some suggest.. you arent a real gardener.. and that included houseplants.. until you have killed every plant 3 times.. by which time .... you are either broke.. or know how not to kill them ... lol

ken
Related Discussions
Why did my Meyer lemon tree die?
Q
Comments (19)
Like I said in my previous post, I don't know why outdoors would be different. I know about WLD from previous experience, and from knowing a lot of people who grow citrus commercially and have been growing them for dozens of years. Leaf activity, eg photosynthesis, reduces the colder it gets. So if it is cold outside, roots won't function, leaves won't function...it is essentially dormant. Perhaps this is why WLD does not occur outdoors. As stated, I don't have the reasons, I just know from experience the roots do not function below 55.4F. Whether or not you choose to believe this is your choice. A link to any site would not be suitable, to prove for or against, but if you want to know more, do a google search for winter leaf drop with citrus and read peoples experiences. From there, whatever you choose to believe is entirely your prerogative. Best way to know for yourself is to experiment, Buy a citrus, sit it in a cold south facing room (below 12.5C but above 5C) and see what happens. I keep all of mine indoors from September onwards when it starts getting cold, and I have a lot of foliage growth and blooms. I have quite a bit of fruit on the go too. I have only had to deal with one scale problem, an isolated incident that was managed after one oil application.
...See More
why did my grapefruit tree die?
Q
Comments (1)
There is no way for us to tell you why your tree died. Perhaps someone knowledgeable might be able to come up with some hints by visiting and inspecting the site and attempting something of a tree 'autopsy' on the premises. There are several diseases of citrus which are systemic to the tree and might not be symptomatic to the foliage. RoundUp typically need to be sprayed on the foliage in order to do damage, but can harm young woody plants if applied to the trunk. Mature trees should be fine.
...See More
Why did my Lion's Head Japanese Maple Die
Q
Comments (10)
If this was its first winter, then I suspect the culprit is cold damage. You are located in an area where Japanese maples are of borderline winter hardiness, you experienced what is the equivalent of a zone 4 winter this past season and Shishigashira is not considered to be as cold tolerant as some other JM's. Most authorities only list it to zone 6. I also have some concern about the planter box. In the last photo, it looks like the planter is resting on heavy duty landscape fabric and not in direct contact with the underlying soil. Is this why the tree was planted high? Not enough depth for the rootball? And no winter mulch? This definitely could have been a contributing factor. Need more details on the planter itself before suggesting whether replanting another tree makes sense.
...See More
Why did my variegated lemon tree die!
Q
Comments (48)
Monica I bought a half pound box of Nagami kumquats at Kroger grocery. They were small and they had seeds. I did a years worth of research and decided to order a 10 pound box of Meiwa kumquats from Florida kumquat growers Inc. They were delicious and I planted 300+ Meiwa seeds. I also bought Poncirus Trifoliata seeds since my research showed that kumquats from seeds were a no go. Out of 300 seeds I had 2 plants left and one thrown into the compost heap as low quality. My 2 died and I rescued the compost victim. 1 years later it was clear that I could not graft to PT. I planted seeds and ended up with 4 sweetlee tangerine trees for rootstock. They grew very nicely and are the pride of my citrus fleet. My Meiwa died and that was the end of my citrus career. A friend moved and gave me her 2 Meyer lemon trees. They did well so I built a greenhouse and kept the tangerine trees and the 2 Meyer lemon trees. 2 of my tangerine trees tripled in size over winter into spring and the Meyers doubled in size. A friends gave me a grafted Meiwa kumquat and 2 seed grown Fukushu kumquat trees while another friend sent me The New Zealand lemonade tree, all mentioned above While doing all this I bought a fig tree and it took off and I have rooted over 30 cuttings that all produced figs. I can produce easily 500 to 2000 figs a year going into next season. The Hardy Chicago fig has been a real winner for me. This past year I harvested more figs than 5 apple trees of 20 feet. More than 17 full size peach trees 1 plum tree, 2 paw paw trees, 2 cherry trees, 7 blue berry bushes, almost as much as my black berries. At current I have a total of 6 citrus trees gifted to me and 3 tangerine trees from seed. All 9 are doing well#3 above is in ground #4 above is in ground I believe I know enough to get set up to produce most if not all of the citrus fruit we would eat in a year and do it cost effectively. I am there with the figs. Gardening is a labor of love. I will repeat that growing citrus trees take a real commitment to do well and is ONLY easy when the trees are not having problems. I will also say if you are growing for foliage then grow from seed from fruit. If you are growing for fruit start a bunch of trees from seed and learn on them for 2 years before buying a grafted tree. You get more fruit sooner if you blow 2 years growing from seed first as you go over the learning curve. I can say now I really enjoy my trees
...See More

Related Stories

SPRING GARDENING 7 Spectacular and Practical Spring-Flowering Trees

Put on a beauteous show in the garden with a landscape tree awash in flowers — just do your homework first

MOST POPULAR The Most Incredible Kids' Tree House You'll Ever See?

By Sarah Greenman

Duck your head to enter this unforgettable Dallas wonderwork, lovingly crafted with imaginative delights

BUDGET DECORATING 14 Ways to Make More Money at a Yard Sale — and Have Fun Too

By Laura Gaskill

Maximize profits and have a ball selling your old stuff, with these tips to help you plan, advertise and style your yard sale effectively

HOUZZ CALL Did You Design Your House Around Your Pet?

By Gwendolyn Purdom

Doggy doors are just the beginning. We want to know what other pet-centric features have driven your home design

HOUZZ CALL Where Did You Stay During Your Remodel?

By Erin Carlyle

Did you live through the noise and dust during your project, rent a place or camp in your backyard? Tell us your story

MOST POPULAR Springtime Gardening: Begin by Listening to Trees

By David Haskell

A biologist and author shows how open senses and lively curiosity can guide our work in the landscape and garden

HOLIDAYS Houzz Call: Show Us Your Christmas Tree!

By Annie Thornton

We’d love to see how you make your tree your own. Please show us your best photo and tell us about your traditions

EDIBLE GARDENS How to Grow 10 Favorite Fruit Trees at Home

By Marianne Lipanovich

Plant a mini orchard in fall, winter or early spring to enjoy fresh-off-the-tree fruit the following year

ARBOR DAY 10 Trees Landscape Designers Love

By Annie Thornton

In honor of Arbor Day, consider adding a beautiful and beneficial tree species favored by designers around the country

LIFE Houzz Call: What Did Your Dad Teach You About Making a Home?

By Erin Carlyle

Fathers share skills and wisdom with their kids. What did you learn from yours?

Sponsored

More Discussions

Firefly Petunia in Containers Outside

4

Yellow leaves: to remove or not?

5

Combine 5-1-1 And Gritty Mix?

3

Up-potting small Sango Kaku

5

Weighing down the plant as rootball won't hold

1