Your new colors are almost the same as existing.

Here is some option to go with muted green

All of the house sage green

Thank you so much for your help! Unfortunately we are trying to go away from greens as we have had green for 10 years. Would love a gray that will work well with the brick. It is so hard finding one.

Don't have any color names quick to hand, but I would consider painting the garage doors to match the siding, when you pick your paint -- it's hard enough to see where the front door is without having those drawing the eye so strongly!

I think the Colonnade will look fine. Agree with @Celery. Visualization, Rendering images (as always) that it's not very different from current color. Also agree that you should paint garage doors to match siding. Then remove shrubs hiding the walk to the front door and make the entry the focal point, not the garage.

Thank you for your help! Agree that garage doors distract. We are removing the 3 tall shrubs by the front of home & replacing front door package also.

I also think Colonnade Gray could be nice. Both Colonnade Gray and Repose Gray were suggested to us by a SW color consultant. We're leaning toward Repose Gray since I wanted something fairly light. Repose also seems to work better with our roof color.

This was one photo I found online with Repose Gray and brick. It's another option with your house, and maybe even better with your roof color.

Thank you for your insight! We also looked at Repose. We really want a gray or greige but know it can’t be too cool because of the brick. I was really hopeful that Houzz may have some answers for a good gray. We were wondering if we should go darker vs. lighter. Revere pewter is also pretty but seems to be a chameleon- looks tan in some areas, gray in other depending on lighting.

Revere pewter also can look green, in some light, so if you are trying to get away from greens, this is probably not a good choice. Colonade gray is a bit darker than repose gray.

Have you used Colonnade gray? Wondering if it is dark enough to work with our brick?

Go darker

you have a lot going on w/diff textures.

what's the wood above the largest garage? is that staying? doesn't seem to go w/anything

what about the brick? Could you do Romabio on it? if you do, you could literally pick any color.

Another poster on here had a similar house. they limed the brick (Romabio Masonry can be tinted any color) and did the other colors

Isn't this an awesome after photo? notice the wood posts, copper awnings, new lighting, (I would have done carriage hardware on these garage doors, and replaced the faux victorian door, but the color is nice)

That red brick is restricting your color choices. White dove would be very similar to the trim color you ahve.

I would go darker.

dark charcoals, navy, soft black, all look great w/red brick and the wood garage doors

Urbane bronze on the trim, and a gray siding would get you this one. but the windows are also a dark bronze. trim yours dark if you want this look

red brick w/what looks like Swiss Coffee and maybe SW Anonymous? Dorian Gray?

I like how the gables are darker than the rest of the house. this one is a greenish gray trim, and a lighter griege base color

What is this? Really out of place, like a couple strips of siding fell off.

These are all fantastic ideas! Thank you all so much! Those are wood shake shingles that have been repaired. 😂 The front of our home is mostly wood shake shingles. So sorry this photo was taken during repair stage. You can also see from the photo that we have already put up numerous paint swatches/samples to test - the area to left of brick has China White, Colonnade, & Revere Pewter. Also paint samples on either side of large garage door.

Here are better photos of our home.

I like this idea for your home, along w/the fresh new shakes

I put your doors on this house so you could see. You could paint your posts or wrap them in cedar and stain them the same color of your garage doors.

do the front door any color you like

If you want to try this out first, get a sample of the Classico Limewash in the white. try it on some bricks. it washes off in the first 72 hours if you don't like it

more of a cape cod look w/blue/gray siding color

The white rendition is gorgeous! I so wish we could do that! Our painters are ready now though so sadly changing the brick is out for now.

I looked at SW Mindful Gray today & am wondering if it could be nice with white trim, white garage doors with black hardware. Maybe do shutters in SW Iron Ore? Our new front door could be stained a lighter wood color for contrast? Not as beautiful as a white home but I am stuck with the brick for now.