it Will fade with time...

you could use something from the stone (the mid tone) for the railing, posts and garage door to add a little contrast.

Reduce green with black/dark shutters

Its just a big change. You'll get used to it. A big improvement would be to remove the faux louvered shutters. If you miss them, then add some larger solid style ones that would cover the windows if you could close them. You might check to see what complimentary colors for your Sheraton Sage are, and change the shutters to a new color. Adding some more of those red plants in pots under the porch railing will be helpful in moving the eye to your entrance.

Agree with Celery. The color is fine, but shutters should be darker.

@Jilly so funny I thought the same but was pleasantly surprised. It looks very nice. Celery’s mockup is a good suggestion.

If the shutters were properly sized they would be wider and make a bolder statement.

Here they are in a brown to complement the stone

Here they are in black to contrast the house.

I like Celery's example with the black shutters but properly sized.

HAHA yea I was half-expecting to see what Jinx posted.

Yours look fine. The truth? I think it looks BETTER than what you had before, there's a vibrancy to it yet it's not overwhelming. You would be wise to repeat the brown in the brick somewhere -- perhaps paint the front door a rich brown tone that coordinates with the tone of the brick, or dark brown shutters. If it were me, I'd leave the shutters the same and paint the front door dark brown.

I agree with the others. This looks so much better than before!

The shutters would definitely look great in black.

It's a really nice color! I was wondering about a dark green for the shutters but also changing the white on the columns, rail, trim, at least the garage and door trim (and the drainpipes) to an off white/ cream - closer to your stone. ETA: and the front door in the dark green. Like this palette:

Based on the feed back…I was looking at the different ideas,taking off the shutters, or making them wider ,painting them off white/cream or dark brown or black,painting the garage door off white/cream , painting the house door and/or the railing and posts brown.Also adding more red flowers.

I am leaning towards painting the shutters black or dark brown, i did strongly consider making the garage off white as well, to match the trim but i will need to look around my neighbourhood to see if any of the houses are painted that way ….otherwise i will hear from the HOA .

I will also add some red plants or flowers around the porch.

Thank you for the ideas , and also for helping me realize that it’s not an entirely horrible color (like the lime green house posted above, by ’Jinx’ …😁) - I just need to get used to it.