I see a very dark redder color in your stone, on the wall in your entry. I would try to match that for the color of your door.

Maybe the blue in the frisbee on the ground.

Agreeing with cat_ky. Consider using the darkest red-brown in the stone, leave the window areas as they are. The contrast should add some oomph.

I would totally go with a satin finish of Miller Paint "Day Spa"

I totally see there deep green.

Also, the door is on a different plane than the brick so I would definitely not try matching the brick

Some colors variation from your stone

Charcoal Blue is appealing to me.

I would leave the side lights white and paint the door charcoal blue.

I really love the charcoal blue in Celery's suggestion. That blue with a grey undertone compliments the stonework.

I've been using the SW ColorSnap and really like the darker green/grey hues for the door. Something like this.

A lot of agreement on the charcoal blue, but my roof is a sandstone and I don't love the blue with it. Thanks everyone for the suggestions. I think I'm going to go with Ripe Olive or Andiron from SW, I'll post how it turns out.

I would leave the side lights white, btw, Tim. Also, I think that the singed red color will look dated for this application

Why leave the sidelights? Is there a reason or is typically done this way? Just to accent the door more? Thanks!

Look dated for me with no painted sidelights.

The warm browns and rusts in your stone are trending again, at least for interiors. I love the green-y hues above. I also like the light blue that you currently have, except paint the sidelights too. You have a very pretty house!

I like the Ripe Olive; Andiron would be very dark in this shaded space. And sidelights always look better when they match the door. Could we see a pic of the whole front of your house please?

Black

Love the Ripe Olive!