The chances of finding matching tile is slim. Can you exchange the vanity for one that isn’t raised?

You might not need an exact match if it's going under your vanity. you can prob find something similar at the Tile Shop or a big box store.

Just get a vanity that goes to the floor and forget about tiling under it.

Is that tumbled travertine or marble?

I think it is travertine. Definitely not marble.

I had this problem in my previous house. I put a border around that area with coordinating tiles and then filled it with a tile that almost matched and was underneath so you couldn’t see it.

that's a ceramic tile not travertine. just a basic tile that probably isn't made any longer. (obviously. it was done in 1995)

either redo the tile, or get a vanity that goes to the floor. You will never be able to match that tile and that exact grout color.

how far up is the new vanity? a few inches or more than a foot? if only a few inches, find something close to the tile and be done.

Can we see the vanity? Is it the exact width as the old one?

I would try this, hopefully it can work. Carefully remove some tiles. Find a coordinate colorway, predominately white with 1-2 of the original darker colors, in the same size. Maybe you can create this border with a new contrast color tile 'border'.

That is a great idea!! Thank you!

chances of popping those tiles off the floor or the tub in one piece are slim to none. and once you attempt it, you're committed. because if they break (and they will) now you have another missing tile in a more conspicuous spot to deal with. Those tiles were set in old school mortar. knock on them w/your knuckles. do they sound hollow or dense? if the latter, you'll never get them up in one piece.

and let's be real about this, if you're going through all the trouble of taking up those extra tiles, buying new accent tiles to replace the ones removed, paying for all of that, then just take up the whole floor and start over! But it's moot because you'll never salvage those other tiles.

I agree the chances of the tiles breaking are really high. In that case, you could take the pieces and make a mosaics with them, at least the floor below the vanity will be the same color given that you can get the same color for the mortar.

I have other ideas for below the vanity but I can't say if they work without seeing the vanity first.

Thank you everyone! We ended finding a ceramic tile that matches enough to go under the new vanity. Thanks again for all the ideas!

Whoo hoo. Saved $$$