That looks like a cookie to me!

What else would it be? A Pookie? (grin)

Too many vowels for pieookie!

Admittedly, I have not baked a cookie that big, and I'm wondering, how did the Princess make sure the center was baked and the edges were not overbooked? That's what's been holding me back!

Edited to add: Will you please post the recipe, and what size pie pan? Thanks!

My daughter baked that sort of thing when she was a teen. Forget what they called them , but it was a "thing" girls did as a gift for their boy friend. Think they called them monster cookies.
Tell her she "done good"!

Oh, yeah, I remember those, but just big cookie on a baking sheet. We sent them to boys away at camp, but really for our own fun, not theirs. :) Just an excuse to play around while baking and giggle. The boys didn't mind. They ate them. :) And the popcorn we used for packing filler. :) Teen boys will eat anything. :)

Your Princess's pie cookie is much fancier. :) And she kept the good stuff for herself. :) Good going!

"How big can a cookie be before it's not a cookie?"

I ask instead, " How big can a cute cookie be before you can't call her a cute cookie anymore?"

dcarch

That would be but an appetizer for the cookie monster!

*Sesame Street humor*

cookie!

Annie, I love Princesses's determination and her desire to try new recipes - she'll be a member here before long, posting her own amazing meals and desserts!

LOL sooz, "pookie"! And bragu - cookie monster appetizer! Love both those comments!

I used to make 'big' cookies too, like plllog I did mine on a baking sheet - and nowhere near as fancy as the Princess's big cookie, nor were they 'deep pie dish' cookies : ) I don't have kids, and made them first for my Dad, then my friends, and yes, once I made one for us... we're all big kids at times!

Love it!

How big can a cookie be ?..........how about 102' in diameter!! Record breaking cookie.

Great cookie...pretty girl! I recall a chocolate chip cookie dough from Martha Stewart that could be used for cookies, pie or tart.

Me want big cookie!

Thanks, Annie, and thank the Princess for me, too! There's a Pookie in my future!!!

LOL! Pookie sounds great. I say it’s a cookie until it doesn’t fit in the oven. I’d probably eat that whole thing right now if it was in front of me!

I made a big cookie in my iron skillet, recipe from Cook's Illustrated. Good, not to replace my regular coolies, but nice for a change

So, how much per dozen ... thinking of placing an order ...

“I’ll just have one cookie for dessert!”

I don't recall any issues with getting our giant cookies baked, but it occurs to me that heat sinks would work. A chocolate chip cookie should mend itself if you pull the sink out right when it comes out of the oven.

FOAS, that's a great diet idea. "But I just had ONE cookie....." (grin)

Bragu, I'm sure she'd make you a special deal, LOL. What the heck would you do with a dozen of those monsters, though. She cut hers into pie shaped wedges, 12 wedges and said it was still a pretty good sized "cookie" slice.

Hmm.....a pookie....

She's sure growing up, I look at that picture and can't believe how time has gone. Some of the members here remember when she was born, now she's 15, taking driver's education, in high school. (sigh) She's still in my kitchen, though, so it's all good...

Annie

six ice cream sandwiches ...

But FOAS, I can never eat just one..

When I was seven or eight, I used to bake cookies for my mother's tea parties, and I made them very small and dainty and then served them on a silver platter to the women at the parties. If a woman took more than two cookies at a time, I gave her a look - can't remember what the look was, but sometimes they would put one back.

As a teen boy, I was a much pickier eater than I am now, but then I would also go on hunger strikes when I was a teenager. I did notice that the college boys who lived next door to me in Venice would eat anything, or so it seemed, and so I used to give them a lot of my leftovers, for which they seemed very grateful.

The large cookies does seem to resemble a pie, and so pookie is probably a good name for it. It's not on my current diet either :(.

LOL! Lars, you're the exception that proves the rule!

I'm working my way up to a Pookie. Meanwhile, I discovered this sweet little website that has recipes for making a giant single serving cookie! I made the oatmeal raisin cookie this morning (after letting the dough chill in the fridge overnight). It was tasty and delicious! The dough for one cookie started out about 3 inches in diameter (looked like a tall hockey puck maybe), and it baked up like this in the photo!

Gemma's Website page with giant single serving cookies!

LOL, bragu, that would make an ice cream sandwich for sure. Or six of them.

Lars, I think teenaged or young adult boys/men do sometimes eat anything, just as long as they don't have to cook it themselves. You're an exceptional cook, though, so they were probably very, very happy to eat your cooking!

Sooz, now that's my kind of cookie. The idea of a single cookie is actually a very good one, although I do keep frozen dough in the freezer for dessert emergencies. A single serving, though, would give a lot more choices!

The big "pookie" didn't seem to have any issues with cooking through to the middle, in fact, the Princess said she'd like it a bit "gooey-er". Next time she'll bake for less time, and she thought it would be a great snack to take to share after cheer practice, not as tricky to juggle as a couple of dozen cookies can be. She'd just have to bake it in a disposable or metal pan...

Annie

*needs to remember to trademark the word 'pookie'*

need those residuals in retirement

^_^

dkB

Dave, remember me when you get those residuals. The Princess will have college loans...

BTW, I saved seeds from both Ajvarski and Sugar Rush Peach, if you want some just send me an email, I have lots!

Annie

Cookie is a state of mind.