x-post : floor tile problem?

14 years ago

I posted this in the flooring forum but haven't received any responses so thought I'd try here.

Hi. I don't post here much (usually over in kitchens) but I need some advice. I'm having rectified porcelain tile (7 x 14, running bond) installed in my mudroom and I noticed today that a few of the tiles are as much as 3/16" of an inch higher than others. The tile is being installed on a new concrete slab. The slab surface isn't very smooth and no skim coat or self leveller was used before the tile was installed. About 2/3" of the tiles are in place and it's not grouted.

My question: Should the slab have been evened out with a skim coat first or is it normal to just use mastic to try to even it as you go? And what kind of height differences are considered acceptable? I definitely want the couple of really bad tiles removed and replaced, but do you think I should have the whole floor taken up and start over (it's only 120 sq ft)? Thanks for any advice you can give.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (8)

bill_vincent
14 years ago
Okay-- a couple of things. First, I'm hoping it's only a case of semantics, and your intallers aren't really using mastic (which comes already mixed in a bucket), but are actually using thinset (which must be mixed either with water or an additive). Secondly, no matter how they do it-- flattening out the floor prior to installing the tile, or flattening it out by adding more thinset AS they set the tile-- Either way, the floor must be flat. And not for nothing, but I wouldn't accept 3/16" lippage from NORMAL tile, much less rectified porcelain!! I'd let them know that if they intend to get paid, they need to do something about the lippage, first, and it should be done before they go any further-- get what's done so far to the point of being acceptable, and THEN proceed however they wish to, so long as they get the floor flat, no quesitons asked.
remodelfla
14 years ago
I was going to relay info that Bill had provided to me awhile back about the installation of rectified porcelain but you heard it directly from the source! And to restate... he told me (as you) that the slab must be totally even for a quality installation. We were going to DIY it but since I'm saving so much money super shopping appliances and other things; I think we'll have to spend on the installation since we only plan on doing this once and the plan is to stay in this house till we're very very old and cranky!
Related Discussions
Is there a wrong thinset for ceramic floor tiles? (x-post)
Q
Comments (5)
Thanks for your responses. :) It's a gypcrete floor underlayment. When you say not to mix the two together, do you mean not to mix together dry and then with water in same batch? Sorry, I didn't intend to say that, if that was what it sounded like I was asking. By "mix and match", I meant would it be alright to do one section of floor with one mortar. And then when I run out of that one, can I finish off the floor with the other mortar? I mainly had my doubts about using the Marble/Granite mortar for my glazed ceramic tile, but the Custom Products website said that it was fine for ceramic tiles, and particularly good for ones larger than 12 x 12". The tiles we're laying are 16 x 16". Out of curiosity, what does "medium bed" mean? Have a good evening and thanks again.
...See More
X-post need help choosing 1898 victorian bath floor
Q
Comments (18)
golddust, I've heard of that too, I'm not sure if one can do that with these really old toilets, or if they would still work well with less water. Maybe worthy will weigh in? If there's a way to keep it, I'd love to. It's really neat in the old Cadillac vs. Honda idea that Kasha Kat mentioned earlier. I know the Honda is much more efficient, but those old caddys are just so cool! Fuzzywuzzer (love the name)- I hadn't much thought of painting the floor because we aren't going to be taking the tile off of the walls right away (and maybe never) and I don't like the look of painted floor with tile. Somehow it makes the floor look cheap to me. I know this makes no sense, I love a painted floor everywhere else and in fact plan to paint the floor in our den, but for some unknowable reason, I don't like it in a bath. After we do the kitchen, and get a real look at the floor, we'll see what direction we need to go in. If the floor is in good shape, then I think we'll finish it and make the walls beadboard wainscoting. If it's not, then we'll probably tie it to match the tiled walls. I'm hoping for the Octagon and dot style, but maybe hex with random daisy design. I've been posting our kitchen renovation in this forum, more to push me to save photos of the process, I know I'll forget. I've been keeping "polish" somewhere in the title. It's a great house that just needs a nice polish. Katie,as much as I love the O & D it's not worth a toilet! I'll be adding a coat of white paint to most woodwork in my house because I don't have the time to strip it right now, that's an activity that is definitely back burner when there's so much else to do. I love the purple- I bet your bath is amazing, will you post photos? I put in a reply on your earlier thread asking about color choices, did you make any others? I'm still hemming and hawing over them. I'm going now for just some plain white for the woodwork- Thanks for the input! Ginnie
...See More
X-post: Vote please! Flooring indecision...
Q
Comments (10)
Just for another point of view from someone who has laminate in their kitchen - The kitchen in my old Cape had Armstrong vinyl flooring when I bought it it 1986, put in by the PO. I removed it when I re-did the kitchen. Under the vinyl was the original old growth Douglas Fir, which I had sanded and sealed. With three dogs (in two 'sets' over the years) their nails and exhuberance damaged that beautiful floor. I did some research and put in a high quality laminate in April 2008. Pic below. Despite my dogs having access to the outside through doggie doors in the basement, and running up the stairs to the kitchen at times clean and dry, or wet and muddy or piled with snow, the floor still looks beautiful. They also have a shared water bowl on the floor that may get dumped at times, or splashed on the floor. It'll sound like the Post Office motto of neither rain nor snow...but it has not come unglued, picked up any odors, and no matter what has been dropped on it over the years, there is not a single stain. I've really put this floor through its paces, and while I'd rather have the real wood that is in every other room except the basement bathroom (tile), if there comes a day that I don't have dogs (heaven forbid) I'll put a hardwood floor in. What you see where the oval rug is, my pantry, has real oak, and many people, including some carpenters, have had to touch the adjoining kitchen laminate floor to see that it isn't real hardwood. It'a ALLOC Domestic with silent system. It's a very close match to the oak hardwood in the pantry. Here is a link that might be useful: ALLOC Domestic
...See More
X-Post Sequence: Tile vs Cabinets
Q
Comments (6)
You can do it either way; it's a personal preference thing (as long as you make sure your cabinet people knows which way you're doing it and whether they need to prepare anything special). We are doing the floor ourselves and have a cabinetmaker. He gave us the choice---basically, if we do it first it's easier to lay the floor but there is the risk of damage to it when the cabinets are installed, though obviously we'll cover it. If we do it last, there is more cutting involved and the cabinets either need to be on a platform the same thickness as the floor or the boxes need to be built slightly higher to compensate for the thickness of the floor. We opted to do it first because we're tiling under appliances that will later be surrounded by cabinets, so it seemed far simpler to do it that way. But unless one or the other of your contractors feels strongly about it, it's up to you. I don't think it makes much difference in replacing the floor later, though. I've seen people leave cabinets with flooring under them in place and just cut out and replace the center floor. Either way your cabinets will be at floor height---it's just that if they don't have flooring under them, they'll have plywood or something comparable.
...See More
cheri127
Original Author
14 years ago
Thanks so much for the comments. My mistake, Bill, it is thinset. Also, I tried to measure the lippage and it may be more like an eighth but I still don't like it. There aren't too many tiles that are too high so I think it would be pretty easy to fix. However, this may all be meaningless because I'm beginning to think the color is all wrong. Sheeeeeesh! If we do decide to rip them all out, I'll make sure the floor is made smooth before we proceed again.

Elyse, I'm already old and this remodel has me VERY cranky. Seriously, you're the queen of bargains...you deserve to treat yourself to a professional tile installation. I really can't wait to see how your kitchen turns out. Are you in the house yet?
remodelfla
14 years ago
Nope... we wont' move in till we finish it and then we'll rent out my house. I'm very very fortunate that we have the two homes which aside from the financial burden; allows us (me) to use the time to find amazing deals. We've been forced to take time which has allow a very functional layout to emerge out of a small and weird space.
bill_vincent
14 years ago
Also, I tried to measure the lippage and it may be more like an eighth but I still don't like it.

Rule of thumb for lippage with natural stone and rectified porcelain is if you try and slide a credit card from one tile to the next and can't, it's too much.
glenster_jr
14 years ago
I can't help but wonder along which edge of the tile the lippage is occurring, i.e., across the 7" ends or in the middle of the 14" sides? Could it be that the tiles are not very flat, either concave or convex along the long axis? BTW I'm not taking up for the installer. Just curious.
cheri127
Original Author
14 years ago
The lippage is on the long side of the tile. You can't slide your foot over it so you definitely wouldn't be able to slide a credit card. I don't think it's the tiles because I looked through all the scraps and they're very uniform. The floor had bumps in it and I just assumed a skim coat would be applied first to smooth it out. Rule #1-never assume anything! The installer is a really great guy and will make it right. I just have to decide if I want him to just replace the tiles that are too high or replace the whole floor with darker tile.
bill_vincent
14 years ago
I can't help but wonder along which edge of the tile the lippage is occurring, i.e., across the 7" ends or in the middle of the 14" sides? Could it be that the tiles are not very flat, either concave or convex along the long axis?

Doesn't matter. The tiles in the following picture are 12x18 rectified porcelain, and I DID have that problem, where there was a slight curvature to the tile. Even on a tile that big, though, the worst it ever got was a shy 1/16", and in about 1200 feet, with a fussy architect, not one piece had to be replaced, So no, bowed tile isn't an excuse, either.

x-post : floor tile problem?

Comments (8)

bill_vincent

remodelfla

Related Discussions

cheri127
Original Author

remodelfla

bill_vincent

glenster_jr

cheri127
Original Author

bill_vincent

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

x-post : floor tile problem?

Comments (8)

bill_vincent

remodelfla

Related Discussions

cheri127Original Author

remodelfla

bill_vincent

glenster_jr

cheri127Original Author

bill_vincent

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

cheri127
Original Author

cheri127
Original Author