What makes 'vinyl safe' paint vinyl safe?

13 years ago

I am researching paint systems to use on my vinyl shutters and want to paint them a very dark green (like BM Essex Green). They are faded dark green right now. Most have been on the house for 10+ years, but a few will be new because I'm replacing some existing ones that are inappropriately sized.

Sherwin Williams markets products with "VinylSafe technology" - the description makes it sound like this is a characteristic of the color, not the paint, as it is available in a couple of their lines.

Does anyone know what makes these products "vinyl safe"? I read elsewhere (old posts on this forum) that it is the omission of black pigments. If that is the case, wouldn't any full spectrum paint (i.e. Ellen Kennon) be considered "vinyl safe"? Or does the "vinyl safe" characteristic come from an additive that is mixed into the paint?

My plan is to clean the shutters well with TSP, sand a little (patch screw holes), prime with XIM Plastic & Vinyl Primer and let that dry really well, and then apply topcoats.

I'm trying to figure out:

A) which type of paint will be best for the top coats (brand, type, finish, etc.)

b) if this XIM primer is the best product for this application or if there is something else out there that I should consider

B) how to get the very dark green color I am looking for without causing warping or peeling because the paint will be darker than the original color. Is this possible?

Any help would be much appreciated. Thank you!

Here is a link that might be useful: Sherwin Williams Vinyl Safe Colors

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (5)

PRO
Lori A. Sawaya
13 years ago
In theory, yes.

Technically, no.

Difference is SW has done the appropriate testing and established color standards for their color vinyl safe formulas.

Interior you can monkey around quite a bit with colorants before you compromise the integrity of the product. Still, it is possible to go too far. Which is one of the reasons I am so dead-set against the notion that formulas can be cut by percentages, etc. But that's another discussion.

Exterior - that is no place to mess around. Bad crap can happen if you try to get cute with color.

Significant testing is done for light-fastness and UV stuff and a bunch more things I don't understand. I just know it's all important and following the rules to the letter with exterior color specs will keep you outta trouble.

So, yeah, SW took out the black. Which means the color is not going to absorb energy like it would if it had black colorant - but that's not all they figured out and calculated and made allowances for.

There's more to it than that. Whatever they say are vinyl safe colors and how they say they have to be mixed is the way it has to be. No wiggle room on this one.
latimore
Original Author
13 years ago
Thanks, funcolors. Are you aware of any other manufacturers who have vinyl safe lines or is SW the only option?
Related Discussions
Old Fashion Milk Paint Safe Paint -- great color!
Q
Comments (10)
awm, it's because of those quirks that it can not be on my list of go-to paint resources. Full spectrum throws enough painters for a loop, can you EVEN imagine if I handed them powder and told them to go mix it. Oh. My. Goodness. All the paints mentioned, FS, F&B, Aura, Milk have a *visual hand* that is unique; a visual nuance of depth. They offer a multi-dimensional texture that comes from magical pairings and blendings of paint bases and colorants which delivers that notion of texture first to the sensation of vision and eventually touch. Regular paint samples people hold in their hands and tilt and turn to look at them at different angles and eventually run their hand across them. The uber brand's samples garner a touch almost instantly after the first glance. I find that interesting. Anyone who says all paints are equal and a regular paint can deliver the same kind of visual experience as the uber boutique paints have some kind of visual deficit -- their intuitive notions of what color is suppose to look and feel like -- even before you actually touch it-- is messed up. I'm not trying to be provactive or a smart azz. I seriously believe that there are varying levels of visual ability with specific degrees of color intuitiveness. Some people are more attuned to the wavelengths of color and some are less sensitive. Color vision takes place in your brain automatically, without awareness -- your eye/brain team sees and computes color effortlessly. Color is a natural, intrinsic response. So, I guess the question is: is it fair to expect every response to be identical? Very similiar to a great extent? Sure. But all identically intuitive and completely, totally equal? I personally think not. Which is why the buffet of paint choices we have available to us is the greatest thing ever -- ever! We are so lucky. There's a paint out there for everyone and it's so much darn fun! when someone finds their fit like awm and milk paints.
...See More
What's a safe trim paint color in BM?
Q
Comments (5)
The colors sound nice. I think they are what BM calls "warm colors", on the Canadian fan deck, warm colors are indicated by a little picture of a sun on the color chip. The cool colors are indicated by a snowflake. When I was choosing a trim color the designer told me to make sure the white trim color was "warm" white because my wall color was "warm". Where I live BM Cloud White , I think it is OC130 is very, very popular. The designers use it for everything; ceilings, trim work and doors and built in furniture. Apparently it goes with everything. Hope that helps. Good luck with your choice.
...See More
Vinyl plank flooring in basement? safe for kids??
Q
Comments (4)
My son and husband have severe allergies so carpet is not an option but thanks for the suggestion. I really would like to go with the vinyl plank flooring and have began my brand research but was hopeful someone had already been done this road and could offer some advice on safest/healthiest options.
...See More
working with what I have..white vinyl windows, beige vinyl siding
Q
Comments (16)
Thanks, Celery! I was just working on that. Here is it is SW double latte. I'm wanting more cohesion, though. It just seems like two separate top/bottom houses with the light/dark and not getting tied together. Does that make sense? The only thing I can think of is painting the window trim in the darker color...but that just looks so dated. Soooo tricky, it seems.
...See More
PRO
Lori A. Sawaya
13 years ago
SW is the only one I am currently aware of - others could be out there.

Might not be labeled "vinyl safe" but the product might exist that does the same things -- just that marketing department is calling it something else. Like UV wonder coater or something.

If you don't want to go with, SW just start inquiring with "real" pro paint shops.
Faron79
13 years ago
If you've got that XIM primer, you've won that battle.
It's a good one!
Just make sure everything's cleaned and dried b4 priming/painting.

Hmmmm...I'm wondering HOW a deep green like that can be made without black?!?!? I don't see how it's possible. Brown can be used, BUT...it gets ugly in a hurry!

To ME..."Vinyl safe" mainly means not getting too Black with your color. The blacker something is, the hotter it can get, which can warp some plastics.

>>> With that primer, you're golden to use ANY good Exterior Latex in at least a Satin sheen.
>>> UV protection comes mainly from the paints' binder-resin. Better paints withstand the Suns'-blasting better.
>>> The paint/primer system ITSELF is the UV protection!
>>> COLOR mainly affects the HEAT build-up/possible warping.
>>> FADING will always be worst on the S & W no matter WHAT you do though.

Faron
latimore
Original Author
13 years ago
I made the happy discovery when I took the first shutter down that they were originally black, and had been painted before. So I understand, and the paint guy confirmed, that I'm not limited in my color choices. I decided to go with the XIM primer and SW Resilience paint. Thanks so much for taking the time to help me - now off to start the project!

What makes 'vinyl safe' paint vinyl safe?

Comments (5)

Lori A. Sawaya

latimore
Original Author

Related Discussions

Lori A. Sawaya

Faron79

latimore
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

What makes 'vinyl safe' paint vinyl safe?

Comments (5)

Lori A. Sawaya

latimoreOriginal Author

Related Discussions

Lori A. Sawaya

Faron79

latimoreOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

latimore
Original Author

latimore
Original Author