Furnace for a lake house

12 years ago

I've been reading through posts and haven't been able to info on heating a part time residence. Help :)

We need to get a new furnace for our lake house. We are there very infrequently in the winter (maybe one weekend every two months). We set the heat to around 45-50 degrees.

We have spoken to a contractor and he suggested that we need a lower efficiency heater b/c of the temperature that we set the thermostat to. He suggested an 80% efficiency. Does that make sense? This is a lower efficiency than what we currently have.

Next question . . . the honest, ethical folks at American Home Shield (AHS) - snicker - are telling us that they can replace our 100,000 BTU furnance with a Payne 100,000 BTU for $300. They want to cash us out because our contractor said that 100,000 BTU is too big for our house and recommended an 80,000 BTU unit. Obviously AHS wants to spend as little as possible, and our contractor said that Payne furnances are not good. Can AHS really buy a 100,000 BTU furnance for $300? Seems like they are trying to rip us off (not surprising based on the amount of complaints that I found online about AHS).

The home is in Wisconsin. The 80,000 BTU 80% efficiency Trane furncance that our contractor recommended will cost about $1200. So, we will have to pay about $900 out of pocket.

Thanks in advance for any advice/help.

Beth

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (5)

tigerdunes
12 years ago
Just to be clear, this is nat gas or LP propane.

What size living area for lake house?

How would you describe the insulation properties of lake house?

Where would new furnace be located? Home could accept high efficient condensing furnace?

I have to admit I am not a fan of and very untrustworthy of third party warranty companies. And I would not have a Payne for a dog house.

IMO
MDean5
Original Author
12 years ago
The furnace is propane. The house is a ranch and is about 1500 sq ft. The home is about 28 years old, we have only been in it for 1 year. I think it is fairly well insulated. Some of the windows have been replaced, but not all. But I don't see daylight coming through any where and I haven't felt drafts.

The furnace is located in the crawlspace (it is a large crawlspace, earthen bottom but has a vapor barrior). The problem with the existing one - other than it is the original and really old - is that the pilot light kept going out. The service folks came out and replaced the burning element and/or the panel around the pilot and cleane it. But the next time we went there, the pilot light would be out again. The contractor thought that there was no air flow so when the furnace fired up, it would light improperly and extinguish itself. Forgive me - I don't totally understand how the furnance works.

I don't know if the home could accept a high efficiency condensing furnace - I am not sure what the requirements are :)

I appreciate any thoughts that you have!

Beth
Related Discussions
Furnace for Old House
Q
Comments (9)
>1. Putting aside price, given the age and bad insulation in my house, would the modulating be the better option to get heat to cold places places like my 3rd floor? That's not really a problem that can be fixed by just changing equipment. >2. If I am better instead with a two stage variable then is the Infinity 96 or Trane VC95 a better option (as similar price)? It's a matter of whether it's worth it to you. Modulating furnaces are much better than 2 stage in terms of comfort. The only way modulating would be worse is price. What is the contractor's justification for avoiding modulating? Usually when contractors steer people away from modulating it means they haven't been keeping up with the latest technology and aren't trained on how to install and service them. >3. If go with a two stage furnace do I need an infinity/trane thermostat or can i simply buy a decent programmable thermostat? No need for the communicating stat if you go 2 stage. In a 2 stage application the only benefits are less wires needed, and diagnostics/more data available at the thermostat. Those benefits are mainly for the contractor, less so for the customer. Make sure though that if you go 2 stage that you get a 2 stage thermostat, not any old programmable. >I looked at the product data sheets of the 59TN6 and the 59MN7. The former is a 2-stage variable speed furnace. The latter is actually a 3-speed variable speed furnace. Carrier advertises it a a modulating furance, but it does not have the variation that other manufacturers offer. Actually the 59MN7 is fully modulating from 40-100% of capacity in 1% increments, when used with the Infinity control (which it always should be). I forget what it does when used without the Infinity control, it may very well become a 3 stage.
...See More
Lake house with boat house on the water. What color fiberglass door?
Q
Comments (1)
Darker, greyer... closer to the stone. Wold be nice to have a panel of lights/windows at the top row for upgrade appearance.
...See More
Furnace heats home during day, but not at night...?
Q
Comments (4)
It sounds like an auto restart fault is tripping on the furnace. Some manufacturers like Carrier have faults pre-programmed that will clear themselves on their own after so much time, usually a couple of hours. Problem is this will make diagnosing the problem much harder. I like to call this situation: Trouble shooting a ghost. So you call service, they sit there for half an hour or so running the furnace check common trouble points. If the furnace runs while they are there? How do you find fault with a furnace that runs? If you're lucky, it acts up when service people are at your house. Otherwise, you're left with guessing. How old is the furnace?
...See More
More on beach/lake house....
Q
Comments (15)
Yeah, anytime a property seems too nice for the price there's usually something not apparent that impacts the value. There's a lot to be said for not having two homes but for now we do and the benefits outweigh the disadvantages. We are thinking quite a bit about selling both and buying one in a warmer climate. It's not really practical for us to rent a place down south in the winter with our two cats. It would also freak me out a bit to leave two homes in MN in the winter where power or furnace could go out, pipes freeze, etc. We've had that happen but we were here to get the problem corrected before it was too late. It is fun to look at real estate listings though prices have been insane so far.
...See More
david_cary
12 years ago
I think 80% is fine for what you are using it for - but I'd want to know how much more a 90 would cost. Your crawlspace should be ok for a condensing furnace. The issue is mainly freezing and that is worse in an attic (from what I understand)
tigerdunes
12 years ago
MDean

Any idea of size and age of existing furnace? Must be pretty old to have a pilot light.

With propane being your heating fuel, I would look into a high eff 95% furnace. This would be a plus if you decided to sell the lake house.

iMO
MDean5
Original Author
12 years ago
It is the original furnance - 26 years old. It is a beast, and I have had to crawl down into the crawl space and light it. yuck! It is 100,000 BTU.

I thought that from what the contractor explained to me, you couldn't set the thermostat for higher efficiency furnance below 50 degrees. Because we leave the house around 45 degrees when we are not there, he said that we needed a lower efficiency. If that is inaccurate, please let me know! I don't want to burn through any more propane than we need too :)

Beth

Furnace for a lake house

Comments (5)

tigerdunes

MDean5
Original Author

Related Discussions

david_cary

tigerdunes

MDean5
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Furnace for a lake house

Comments (5)

tigerdunes

MDean5Original Author

Related Discussions

david_cary

tigerdunes

MDean5Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

MDean5
Original Author

MDean5
Original Author