The second plan is a nice bathroom. If you're only used to one sink do you think you'll use two at the same time? Do you need more closet space? If this is your forever home then do whatever suits you best.

Am I missing the shower space in the first plan?

We haven't drawn up plans for the shower in the first plan--but it would essentially go where the shower is in the second plan, only inside the existing floor plan (so the space between the existing vanity and the closet depicted in the attached bedroom on the left). We would close up the door to the hallway and put the shower there.

We definitely need a second sink! And we also need more closet space, though we could create some by improving the function of the current reach in closet (wouldn't be nearly as much space as the walk in would create however).

I dont really understand the options here. i think it would be helpful to see current layout and proposed layout including bedroom/closet. measurements would help. i think the details matter here. i’d prefer to have walk in closet but i don’t understand the point of 2 sinks and have always had 1950s and prior bathrooms - so small! it probably depends on size of current closet and how bug the walk in will be though.

I am going to try to hand draw the current bedroom and will post later!

I prefer a wall of pax wardrobes with a nice size bath to a walk in with tight bath when both good size walk in and good size bath is mot an option. I love my pax and my spacious bathroom.

Ok forgive the messy drawings. This pic is with a larger bathroom, bedroom closet staying as it is now (reach in).

Here are plans for the smaller bath leaving room for a walk in closet.

Your proposed bathroom looks lovely! I would rather have storage and counter space than 2 sinks, but clearly that's a personal preference.

On your first sketch, where is the door to the bedroom?

Your proposed "walk-in" closet is less than 40" wide. Allowing 24" for hanging clothes on one side does not leave you enough room to walk. If you remove the existing reach-in closet and replace it with PAX storage, you could have much more efficient storage, including drawers and shelves.

This is the storage potential of wall of ikea with doors. I love the calm the doors offer so even in a walk in closet I need hidden storage for open storage always makes me feel claustrophobic.

Hi, AnnKH--the bedroom door in the first sketch (larger bathroom) is right next to the shower (the little wedge to the left).

The larger closet would be 72" deep. Maybe may handwriting wasn't clear? It is currently 29" deep. I was thinking we could have storage on the two short sides, and the (long) far side. The close long side would have space for hanging jewelry, belts, ties, etc., to leave room for an "aisle" for walking in. We will have roughly 40+" clearance for the aisle (minimum recommended is 36").

Also I think even with the smaller bathroom option, we will have a large enough vanity that there will be room for storage underneath, including drawers in addition to cabinets (and maybe even a linen stack on the vanity between the sinks). We also have a linen closet just outside the bathroom (shown in the second drawing), so we won't lose the linen closet with either design. Just one option has the linen closet inside the bathroom, and the other has it remaining outside the bathroom (where it currently is located).

What is the clearance between toilet and sink in the smaller bath idea? It looks cramped but it may not be quite to scale. I think if you truly plan on both using sinks at same time frequently the larger bath would be nicer as there is more room for maneuvering 2 people without being on top of the toilet. This is almost never the case in my life though (hence my confusion at the double sink obsession) so I'd prioritize the larger closet. 6 ft seems adequate - as you planed or long hanging row and 1 ft deep shelving/hanging hook space. I like having laundry in walk in closet (our "step in" closet is miniature, but a big improvement from laundry basket in our room) and being able to see all my clothing at once.

I think there will be ~2 ft of clearance between the vanity and the toilet, maybe a few extra inches. We also have the option to turn the toilet sideways if we want, without moving the stack, which would create more room. Might be nice as I don't want to look at myself in the mirror while I'm sitting on the toilet (though I've been assured that won't be an issue!).

Another option would be to have a trough sink with two faucets, so we could both use the sink at the same time but the right side faucet doesn't need to be directly in front of the toilet. We could flush the trough sink towards the left side, and have a linen stack up against the wall/facing the toilet, instead of a second sink. DH isn't a huge fan of trough sinks, so not sure he would go for that...

I think you need to remove the closet in the bathroom.

You could do a tall cabinet 30 to 36 inches wide by 15, maybe 18 inches deep to give you more room in front of the toilet.

Then your vanity could be longer also.

Is the closet opening up to the other bedroom necessary. Seems like door interference. Could that room use Pac systems?

If you want two sinks, I would go with the closet you have.