I've got a different take, but be forewarned, I do NOT have any problem with dated finishes, IF they are in good condition. While I don't care for your wall color, the rest of the bathroom looks very nice in a late 80's - early 90's style. 1. Since your entire house has beautiful oak trim, I definitely would NOT paint the trim and doors. If the vanity wood, doors and drawers are in good shape, I would also not paint them. I'm in the Chicago area and the experience is similar here - painted trim is typically used to hide (cheaper) pine (or now even cheaper MDF), while oak is left stained. Change the vanity hardware; you'll have to be careful about the footprint of new hardware. If it's smaller than the old, it might reveal a ring of different colored wood. You could, if the vanity is not in great shape, paint the vanity only. There's no concrete rule that says every scrap of wood in a home has to be the exact same finish. There is also the option of cabinet refacing, if the vanity is structurally sound but the finish is bad. 2. Change the countertop, sink, faucet and light fixture. I'd use a Corian type surface for the counter. Your daughters would not have to worry about being extra careful with the counter. 3. Since you have no intention of selling at this point, do what YOU like. Pick the counter and floor to complement each other. Then pick wall paint to match; it can easily be changed. 4. Because of the large light, consider installing a dimmer. Pick a style where the dimming and on/off functionality are separated in the same switch (many styles available). That way, you can dim it to medium, leave it there and then just turn it on and off. When you need the brighter light, you'll have it. This post was edited by DreamingoftheUP on Sat, Mar 22, 14 at 10:53

I think I'm the second person to respond who actually has Corian. We put it in every room in our remodel. And after about 1.5 yrs, we still are thrilled with it. Our home is very contemporary and the seamless sink in the kitchen is at home. I also love the feel of running my hand across the counter and I like that it isn't cold. Witch Hazel seems to be extraordinarily popular with some people and I don't recall anyone who put it in who had buyers remorse. Now Quartz is really nice too. It was going to be my first choice until we started looking at solid surface. I had been eyeing a quartz countertop for years waiting for the next time we moved--way back when granite was at its zenith (which our house came with) and quartz was hard to find. Now that granite has declined and quartz is all the rage, I'm glad I did Corian even more. I realize the quartz is nice, but it's not terribly special. Where I live, almost every single house that is new or re-done and put up for sale has white quartz counters. It's in every single episode of HGTV. White Quartz seems to me to be the 2010s version of the 2000s Beige Granite--everywhere. I just like being slightly different than the masses :) The last poster correctly notes that her granite is is "not understated"--definitely never been a term used to describe loud shiny sparkly granite tops. Corian is classically understated. Now for my next house--Lord willing that won't be for a long time--Neolith is my current fascination :)

Fastest and easiest? Hire a great pro. If not that, I'm not sure there's a fast and easy option unless you're super disciplined about decision making. Here's what I did, roughly, and my tile guy and salesperson said I was faster than most, and the bathrooms look good. Not perfect. But we're happy with them. Since you've selected fixtures and vanities you like, prioritize your considerations. What matters most to you? Aesthetics? Function? Maintenance? Budget? Make a list. Ruthlessly eliminate products that don't fit your criteria. Narrow color and material choices to three for tile, three for counters. Go look. Limit time in stores/showrooms to no more than half an hour (okay, maybe an hour if you've got multiple rooms) at a time. Set a timer. Bring home samples. They probably won't be the ones you thought you'd like. Repeat this process up to three times until you get something that looks good. If you can't find anything you like, hire the pro. Remember: There is no One True Choice. Suspecting there is leads to trials and tribulation. Do not take this path. We're doing four new bathrooms in a massive remodel. The way this process worked in the master bath my husband will use went like this. For the countertops, maintenance and function are most important to us. He's a bad splasher and a bad cleaner. Never sees water spots or that blob of shaving cream he spilled. So counters can't etch or stain. Quartz fits the bill and our budget. He wants white. Not my first color choice, but easy enough. Same will work in guest bathroom and laundry room, thus making efficient use of slabs. Pick the most reasonably priced quality product in the store giving me the nice discount. Be thorough with research, but don't over analyze. Set a deadline for your decision. Stick to it. We chose tile at the same time. Budget was important here, as well as maintenance. DH said he wanted something that looked like a "Roman" bathroom. I interpreted this as marble. No. Not going there with his spilling habit, aversion to wiping things down and cleaning in general. So porcelain or ceramic tile. Fewer grout lines=fewer cleaning woes. I told all this to my salesperson and she immediately directed me to an inexpensive fake carrarra-looking ceramic 18"x18" tile. Works for shower walls. We were going to use it for the floor, too, but a last minute substitution floor tile in another bathroom allowed us to use a grey stone-looking porcelain 12"x24" instead. The contrast looks nice. And we sold the extra 18"x18" to a friend. I started out loving Ann Sacks tiles and New Ravenna mosaics the most, but really, I love tile. The colors, the textures, the possibilities! I could look for hours and imagine all sorts of looks. Then, like everyone else, I had to make real life choices I could live with and afford in the midst of selection fatigue. My salesperson at the tile store was a huge help in narrowing contenders. I found her by looking at Yelp reviews, then went to meet her. She listened well and she knew her products. Great combination, and so helpful. Sorry for the dissertation, when you asked for a nugget. Good luck on your selections. Are you going to post them for us to look at?

Hi Roxanne, I recommend using Daltile, which is a cost-effective and durable brand, that has a wide variety of options to choose from. Since your bathroom is small and you are on a budget, I recommend avoiding a busy mosaic that can visually be overwhelming in a small space and can cost more to install sometimes. A larger tile or a slab look would be nice options in the space, as they are less visually busy and can be more affordable to install. Please see the options below. Check out their other options as well! This is the Daltile Sail Gloss Bevel 6x16 tile... This is the Daltile Glazed Porcelain Elemental Statuario surface used on the floor and walls... I hope this helps! Please let us know if you have any other questions!