Cholebud, I've never been a fan of any green but I do like the way both of your photos look. I'm going to home depot today to get some color swatches. I'll look into the green sage colors as well as some blues and grays like the roof wizard suggested. Whatever color we finally choose, I'll definitely pair it with white trim. I love that crisp clean look and it's perfect for a small cottage. Wish me luck and feel free to send more colors if you come up with anything!! :)

How about cream with a navy trim

I’d reverse the color scheme. Light trim and eaves. Add some trim to the bottom windows. And if you aren’t afraid of color, I’d pop the front door with maybe something in the coral/pink to orange range.

What do you mean by “pop?” I like the existing color of the house, but would definitely lose the turquoise accents. That isn’t the kind of “pop” that I would like. I suggest that the “pop” come in the form of landscaping design. Colorful foliage, planter boxes (perhaps in turquoise), beautiful trees, etc. Bring in a landscape designer. That is where you will get the best bang for your buck. And “pop!”