They're slightly different.

When colors are this close, it's almost impossible to compare them without notations - because you have no way of knowing what to look for.

Or, exactly HOW to compare them.

Hue Family - They're so close, there's nothing to compare (or see) here.

Value and Chroma - we can compare.

Put your samples in order by Value first:

Cloud White - the lightest

White Dove

Moonlight White - the darkest

Next compare by Chroma in this order:

White Dove - least colorful / most neutral

Cloud White

Moonlight White - most colorful / least neutral

For some this is splitting hairs and any of these three would work (as long as they coordinate with fixed elements/contents of the space.)

While for others, these slight differences will be more pronounced and matter more.

As far as I can tell, any of them will work just fine with BM High Park but I'm still going to sample just to be on the safe side.

They all harmonize nicely with High Park. And, yes, test, test, test.

Thank you! I feel reassured :0)

I believe the contrast is so great they will both look white. In searching for a white today, I came across Peale Green in some photos. This is an incredibly beautiful green, and not too far off what you have picked. I just thought I would mention Peale in the event you hadn't seen it yet. It also depends on the look you want - crisp or a with a touch of calm (gray + cream).

The Peale Green is beautiful, but I'm going to stick with High Park -- it leans just a touch into the bluish-green end of things in my space and isn't too saturated, which is what I need with my counters. My second choice was Cushing Green, but after playing around with sample boards I decided it was too dark for the kitchen -- would be fantastic in a bedroom, though.

I have a samplei,e of cloud white. Got a quart in Benjamin Moore and painted a sample board, and a 2x2 square in tge samplize. The paint is a darker almost peach on the sampleize.

I have samplizes for white heron, chantilly lace, mountain peak white, cotton balls and simply white. They all look pretty much the same with slightly varying degrees of grayness as the light gets low. Not sure sampleize can do white colors with real fidelity.

Comparing sample boards of real paint btw white dove (85.38) and cloud white (87.35)...white dove looks darker and depending on light dingiet. Cloud white is a lighter cleaner tan (which looks a little peachy to me sometimes). Both seem def off whites.

Just put up z sample board of swiss coffee (83.93) using a sample can. Swiss Coffe looks as light a color as white dove (but one is real paunt and one is sample paint) but right now looks a bit greenish. I dont think thats a bad thing with wood.

@Mary S . Thank you! I may have to go to the BM store today. After reading up, I'm thinking of buying White Dove and Cotton Balls. Cotton Balls seems to be a nice brightness, not too white (cool) and won't go dingy. How does your Cotton Balls compare to WD and Cloud? Swiss Coffee is way to creamy yellow I feel.

Cindy

The Cotton Balls is just a sampleize. I had like 5 white sampleizes and they were all just pretty white. I will say the sheet seems to stay white white and not gray in low light like some of thr others. It is very white and bright.

Which is nothing like white dove. Not the same ball park. White dove is quite a bit darker, tanner and is a real off white. If swiss coffee is to much of that ehite dove wont be much different. and you want white white Id try super white, cotton balls, white heron, swiss mt peak, i know 'nough to drive you nuts. Simply white is popular.

How much light does your room get?

Oh, I guess mcgee studio? Used swiss coffee at 75% because it was a little yelliw for them.