My personal favorite is C ... but that doesn't mean it’s the best choice for your kitchen. :)

We installed one just like C in my dad’s kitchen (except brushed chrome) because I liked the graceful, clean curves of it. His house is more on the rustic side, and I wanted to soften that up a bit.

They are all great choices! Seriously! Modern and beautiful! I love the look of A, but my practical side is wondering why there is an extra bar and would it get in the way - or is it genius and a spot to hang a washcloth to dry? C & D are still modern, but with more of a craftsman feel with the parts that are square.

I like A - but really, it is impossible to advise you without knowing what kind of "look" you like. Could you at least post and inspiration picture of a kitchen you love?

Thanks! It's tough to post what my kitchen will look like, but I do like A as well. The only thing I wonder about with A--if you have an opinion--is whether to get the metal in stainless or chrome. Also, the black part of the faucet you see in "A" is rubber & I'm not sure what that will look like, but I DO really like the image. That faucet is by Grohe. My other choice is C. I might order both then just hold them up in the kitchen & see how they look; worried about restocking fees though!

I'd take C

Option C - would be my pick, if that helps. When I picked out my faucet I was most concerned with getting the best quality faucet that was going to require the least amount of calls to plumbers over time.

Thanks! Option C is by Kohler, a good brand. Option A (I'm sort of tied between these two) is by Grohe, also a good brand. Not sure which brand is "better" between the two??

My in-laws have option A and it's beautiful in person. 10/10 for style over the others imho.

The extra arm is magnetic on theirs and holds the head in place but you can pull it "away" to move the nozzle sideways but not pull down on it.

It's so beautiful I've considered replacing my own faucet with it but it's chrome and all my other appliances are brushed stainless; not sure if that matters to you. (Google shows they have some updated options so if you like the general look there's more than one finish.)

That's what I ended up with Kohler with ceramic discs. It's been working out well. I'm not familiar with Grohe.

Option A is different looking. I guess I just like the lines of Option A, very graceful and solid looking.

Thanks so much Sarah! I just ordered Option A!! Curious--what finish do your in-laws have? I went with the super steel (think that's stainless) so it would match my fridge, but I was really tempted by the chrome as well!

That's exciting! You'll have to update us with pics once it's installed!

My in-laws have the "starlight chrome" finish. They've been very happy with it. It was part of a mini kitchen update (counter tops and sink updated). I was surprised at how replacing just those few items really elevated the space, making it feel a hundred times nicer.

Also, we were told Grohe is a good faucet brand. My own faucet came with the house, American Standard brand, and already has some knicks in the finish after 3 years. Theirs still looks brand new after a couple years of use.

I used Kohler in my kitchen and multiple bathrooms and the faucets have been great. One thing to check on, if it's important to you, is whether the faucet spray mode stays on (it does on Kohler.) My mom swapped out a $500 Grohe because she had to hold the spray button down to keep it on, and that got really annoying. She replaced it with an inexpensive something (Moen? Delta?) that worked better. Your mileage may vary, and maybe Grohe has fixed the issue since then, but I use spray mode all the time and don't want to hold down a button to make it work.

Sarah--one last question (hope it's ok to bug you!) ... Do you happen to know if the "starlight chrome" gets many water spots? Thanks so much!!

Happy to answer! I don't believe theirs gets water spots, at least none that I've ever noticed. They're not the anal type to wipe it constantly if it did (I am) so that leads me to believe it doesn't get spotty. It's always stood out to me as looking really elegant.

Thanks so much Sarah! Apologies for the late response...I was logged out of the website. I'll let you know which faucet we end up getting & thanks again so much for asking your in-laws!:))