A note: those double doors open out to a balcony.

no you need a minimum of 36” for an aisle between the tub and vanity. Plus you can’t put a free standing tub up against the wall

Plus a 30” wide shower is very tight and if this is a master it will be a huge negative. So is 60” for a double vanity. Where would you store anything?

Thanks, is the 36" inch a code requirement? I didn't find clear guidelines for that online. 60" double vanities seem to be fairly common. I'm comfortable sacrificing a linen closet/storage in this bathroom because there in ample storage throughout the rest of the house.

The space available is too narrow and in general too small to have a double vanity sink, a separate shower and a free stand tub. You would never like to be two in that room at the same time will all the bathroom elements you included that are using the floor space.

Imo, you can include a double sink vanity if:

- you have room for 2 to walk comfortably in the bathroom and

- you have room to put a full length cabinet some where or you have room to put a long vanity that can stored what a separate cabinet would do.

A double sink vanity reduces the space of free counter top. You also have less option for nice size drawers because of the space the sinks and their plumbing is using.

If you don't have the room for a double sink vanity, think really hard at how much you need it. Is it because it is a trend or because you really need it and you need it so much that one cannot wait for the sink before the other is done?

I agree with cpartist, you need space around the tub for ease of cleaning. Personally, I don't think you have room for both a shower and a separate tub.

Can we see the rest of the floor plan? The bedroom, the closet? maybe there is a possibility to move walls.

I updated the layout's dimensions based on cparist feedback and my dad's (who architects commercial spaces, and has remodeled his own home bathrooms) -- this layout is now called Option A.

We also added Option B -- which is a "Shub" (thank you, Common & Vellum: https://www.boardandvellum.com/blog/common-bathroom-floor-plans-rules-of-thumb/). This layout keeps the toilet in its original location, which I've learned can be a cost saving.

As you can tell, I am very much a newbie at this, any critique is welcome. (As long as its not, "you can't have a separate tub and shower in this space :) )

This is great feedback, thank you @suzanne_m. This is the double sink vanity we have right now in our rental, and its fairly comfortable for the two of ours toiletries. 4 of these 6 drawers are usable.

When you say, "full length cabinet" do you mean the drawers shown above -- or something similar to a medicine cabinet/closet? If the latter, we have quite a lot of space in the other 2.5 bathrooms for a family medicine cabinet.

That said -- does the newer layout with the Shub address your concerns re: space for two people to co-exist in this space together?

So now you created a wet room which means every time you use the shower, you not only have to wipe down the shower but also the tub.

How often will you use the tub and is there a tub in another bathroom in the house?

Again 30” is not enough space.

You can’t put 10 lbs in a 5 lb bag

Local code requires minimum 24 inches clearance in front of a toilet, both of these layouts exceed that.

With all due respect -- I'd like to use this thread to discuss "how" we can achieve a complete bathroom with all the requested fixtures, not "if" we should. If, after all feedback, we discover that it truly isn't a possibility, we can go to a layout that has a tub with a shower head.

For this reason, I won't be responding to the prompts regarding how often we'll use the tub, if there are other tubs in the house, etc.

For my use, the vanity you showed would not have sufficient storage but you had the opportunity to try it and found you have enough space, that is great! your argument is based on experience not just 'maybes'.

I have a galley kitchen with a 48" walkway. Both my husband and I can comfortably work in the space but as soon as one opens a drawer, the other has to step on the side to let the person goes. Even worst when it is the fridge, oven or dishwasher door, just turning on the side is not enough, you have to close the door. This is the problem I encounter with 48" space, I can only image how much worst that would be with 28". You are going to hit the edge of the tub, shower or vanity every time one wants to reach the other section of the bathroom if you are not careful.

I mentioned full length cabinet but what I really meant was to say storage for your linens that also includes some shelves for other stuff that does not store well in a drawers or takes too much space.

I feel the same way as cpartist about a wet room. I never tried it but it seems to be that when you use the shower, you have to wipe the tub too. Also, it seems that you have a window problem with that layout. Is moving the window an option?

Is this bathroom accessed only from the master bedroom? Is it a bathroom that you plan on sharing the with other rooms? I would like to see the rest of the floor plan if possible.

Here is an illustration of the rest of the floor (this is not to scale -- I don't have exact measurements at the moment.)

The other bathroom on this floor has a tub, toilet, and a small single sink vanity.

Is this bathroom accessed only from the master bedroom? - Yes

Is it a bathroom that you plan on sharing the with other rooms? - No

If we can't convince you on not having a separate tub, then the Shub layout you proposed is certainly better than the first one.

Personally, I could not live with a bathroom that small and have two people doing their things at the same time but only you can tell if you are good to live with that inconvenient and if the time you are two in there is worth making the floor space available to walk smaller.

If you are still decided on a separate tub and a double sink vanity, here some changes from your layout I suggest. That is assuming that you can work around the window on the vanity wall (and some part of it in the shower. Assuming that you can do this, I also assumed that you can change your french doors to a single door. Making this change would double the hanging space for your clothes and make your bedroom few inches bigger.

You may notice that I moved the tiny bedroom door and your bedroom door too. I think the hallway is best used for the space a swing door required.

I put a pocket door to your bathroom. It is a space saver. I added a cabinet. That is optional. I would really hard time deciding between free space and storage.

I would use the same floor all over (shower, tub and vanity areas). It will make it feel more spacious.

I added a shower curtain that you can pull all the way while you shower. This way you won't have to wipe the tub every time you shower.

I think I would do something like below with the shower curtain and have no glass at all. You can keep your curtain folded between the tub and shower when not in use. It would open up the space. I recommend, especially in this case, a curbless shower.

You could possibly extend your vanity up to the edge of the widow ... even though you will need to find a solution about the mirror over the sink ... but there are ideas on houzz.