I'm no expert but I think you're right, you probably want to keep the garage door matched closely to the brick around it so you don't highlight the garage. I think the bright white on the front door looks nice but maybe to make to stand out more a different color would be fun, but yeah, not red, lol! Ok, I'm no help but hopefully my comment will bump it up.

Thank you Beth such fantastic suggestions. I have really struggled as we wanted to keep structure of the house - both bc was well made and had character (like brick and stone) and also because I despise creating waste so did not want to knock down whole house BUT when we started this I would have never guessed what a challenge it would be to pick things that worked with both brick, hardie plank siding added and stone work. The door was one of final pieces and I am so relieved it is all coming together to still reflect character to house but not look like we made a mistake by renovating instead of tearing down.

Is there a siding color you like more than the others? I think I'd choose my siding color first and then a shingle color to match. Black and gray shingles will go with everything.

If it was my house this is what I would do. I would remove the shutters, paint the siding, trim and pergola in a dark gray to make the stone stand out. I would also paint the window frames in black and install a wood front door to match the garage door. In your photo we can't see a sconce nor house numbers so I would install nice black large ones. I don't know what the chimney is made of, looks perhaps like bricks so I would paint that in a colour to match the stone. The landscaping can also be improved for more curb appeal.