skip to main content

Design Dilemma Kitchens

Opportunity for Change...Help Me Choose a New Hood PLEASE HELP ME

4 years ago

So the 42" stainless steel hood I have sitting in my garage cannot be used in my kitchen (long story and late notice by kitchen designer. I know how the opportunity to make a change. You can see the space I have and the colors I have chosen. The space between the windows is 69". The cooktop is 36".

When I started the planning process, I definitely wanted a wood hood but the cost of the one that matched my cabinets was way too expensive. So I switched to stainless steel. Since I now have to shop for a new hood (and quickly order one), I am looking at all options including buying a hood kit and insert.

Here is the space I have:

And here is a closer shot of my island cabinet color:

Please give me your insights:

Should I stick with 42" or go to 36"?
If I switch to my first choice (wood), what shape do you like with my finishes?
What type of finish would you use? Shiplap? Drywall? Barn wood? Etc?

I need to decide with 24 hours so your quick feedback would be appreciated.

Featured Answer

Kristin S

4 years ago

Stick with 42". If wood was your first choice, go with that. I would not do barnwood, as it seems like it would compete with the island. Personally, I'd probably do painted wood to match the perimeter counters, possibly with an accent band to match the island, if you want.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (61)

pittsburrito
4 years ago
Any hood will work. It's the ductwork that will run into the plumbing -- not the hood. So please tell us where the plumbing is exactly, so we can help strategize a ductwork path around it.
PRO
Patricia Colwell Consulting
4 years ago
IMO the kitchen does not suit any wood hood a much better choice is stainless and get a different one or at least show us where the plumbing is .
Related Discussions
Please help me choose a landscaping block!
Q
Comments (47)
Joanne, I think you are absolutely on track by getting all of the elements together to see what looks best. I took AGES to pick the paint color in my guest bedroom. The reason I was so cautious that time was I picked the color for the back bedroom just by looking at paint chips against the wall, in natural daylight and at night with the electric lights. The color didn't end up being ANYTHING like I expected when painted all over the walls. And it didn't go with the other pieces in the room like I thought it would. Plus looked different because I had to paint the trim too, (the PO's son had painted the trim in that room hyperlink blue!). With the guest room, the wall color looked great. Then, I had the floor sanded and refinished, and the floor color ended up being totally different than it had been before, throwing the look of the walls off again, as they looked different contrasted against the different floor color. I'd get something approximating what you think the new roof color will be, and yes, try to find something approximating the mulch color. Will you be using the same type of mulch as you have now? If you're going to make a big investment in this block, don't feel guilty about really taking your time. Also don't feel guilty about looking some more. In that guest bedroom story above, I looked at paint swatches from five different companies. The brick that I hate in my backyard patio just came from the one company my landscape designer worked with. I was overwhelmed by the brick issue so I let her make all the decisions for me, something that was a mistake because she wasn't really going all out to find the best options. Mine was a small job so I'm sure it wasn't worth the trouble to her to spend time searching for the perfect patio block for me. She just basically said take it or leave it and I had already invested time and money in her so I didn't want to throw a wrench in the machine, but now I am stuck with something I don't like, that cost 4K so I am pretty much stuck with it forever. I will not be able to justify tearing that out when I have so many other big ticket items in my house that need attention. If this is a once in a lifetime do-over for your yard, you have a right to take as much time as you need!!
...See More
Help me choose new range - gas vs induction
Q
Comments (26)
The comments about ten-power settings got me musing on the subject and about Amy's initial question about logarithmic power controls. Here's where that lead me. Nobody really has logarithmic power controls, but there can be power settings spaced to sort of approximate a logarithmic curve -- a number of settings at the low end with only a couple of additional points needed to define the steep side of the curve for really high heat. In theory, that can be done with a ten-step power curve and some folks do find 10 power settings fine for what and how they cook. Others do not. Is anybody else here old enough to remember the GE stoves and cooktops from 50's and 60's with ten mechanical pushbuttons for heat settings? Those pushbuttons were literally "digital" controls, meaning that you punched them with one of your digits. GE sold a lot of them for a couple of decades, so some people found them adequate. Some did not. For the current digital electronic ten-step controls, others here besides loonlakecamp have reported satisfaction with a ten step set-up. Others, like me, would find them inconvenient for my cooking with, say, my pressure cookers. With only ten heat level steps, I would have to be constantly switching settings to maintain the correct pressure. Power setting "1" might be too low, setting "2" might be too high. Switch to 1 for a while until the pressure drops a little too low, switch to 2 for a while until it gets a little too high, then back to 1, etc., etc. With in-between settings, I avoid that annoyance. You don't use pressure cookers? Then maybe having in-between steps won't matter to you. This is just one example of how cooking styles can differ and how more settings can matter to one cook and not to another. Much fuss is sometimes made about the supposedly infinite adjustablity of gas burners. As a practical matter, though, we mostly try to get the burner to the same relatively few settings. Searing is pretty much searing, isn't it? If you deep fat fry, how often would you care if if the oil were at 352° instead of 350°? But maybe somebody is working with sugar syrups where, say, it might matter if a syrup is at 325° and not 360° and then maybe it matters if the induction burner only has ten settings. That said, the subject of induction power settings and controls can be more complicated than just the number of settings. The need for finding "in-between" steps for induction cooking can reflect two different aspects of ways that manufacturers design induction burner controls. One consideration is the power cycling that all induction burners use for settings of less than full power. A technical term for this is "pulse width modulation. or "PWM." It is the same kind of thing a microwave does for low heat levels---momentary pulses of power that average out at a particular heat level. With most PICs as well as some brands of induction cooktops and ranges, the PWM is pretty crude. I've seen this somewhere described as firing up the burner for a second or two of omigosh hot and then switching totally off for three or four seconds. While these pulses average out at a certain heat level the timing can be problematic for, say, the srambled eggs that Amy mentioned at the outset. Combine that kind of "low frequency" PWM with the crude power controls found on many PICs, and you could have a reason that Amy would find herself wanting steps in-between power level "1" and "2" for scambling eggs. Some full size induction ranges and cooktops work this way. I noticed a lot of pulsing at the low heat settings on the Maytag induction range I saw demoed several years ago when I was stove shopping. From past threads on PWM, I gather than Whirlpool's induction ranges and cooktops (which include Maytag and Kitchenaid brands) have used crude PWM. For searching out past threads here on this subject try a search strings like "induction + pulsing + gardenweb" and "induction + cycling + gardenweb." A few of the expensive PICs (Cooktek, Garland, Vollrath) and many full size ranges and cooktops use much higher frequency PWM. Instead switching on and off for a second or more at time, the power switches on and off many times per second. The higher frequency of switching yields much finer power control that more closely approximates a steady heat level. The other design aspect that can lead to wanting "in-between" settings is in how the engineers program the electronic controllers to space the power settings on the appliance you are using --- that's the kind of logarithmic curve I thnk Amy may been thinking about when she posed her question in the original post. . For manufacturers, the least costly controls use simple linear spacing. Setting "1" would use the PWM to average 10% power, setting "2" would be 20%, etc. Even with a high quality PWM, though, 9 or 10 linear settings may be too crude, A thing most induction users discover pretty quickly is that they do most of their cooking in the low to medium range settings. The highest setting can be used for boiling. One or two medium high settings takes care of high heat applications like searing. There seem to be three strategies for induction manufacturers to address the crudeness. One is to add half-steps between the numbered power settings. The other is to program the stove's controllers to put more steps in the low to medium range and fewer in the high ranges. The third strategey combines the first two. Without using the particular induction stove or cooktop, it can be hard to find out whether the particular unit was designed to use one or the other or some combination of them. In my own somewhat limited experience, it seems that the GE induction appliances and Electrolux's Frigidaire/Kenmore ranges seemed to use a modified-half step approach with some concentration of steps but also using half steps for finer control. The Electrolux-branded models use a slightly different approach with quarter-steps at the lower power ends and fewer steps at the high end. Miele cooktops seem to use a similar kind of mix with the option of switching on more steps. I'm not sure how BSH (which includes Bosch) handles this except that their induction appliances manuals show that half-steps are available. The Samsung freeestanding induction ranges seemed to follow the GE model (19 half steps). The reports about Samsung's ten-step "Chef Collection" model seem to conflict, some seeming to say that stepping is linear, some hinting that the settings may be skewed to the lower end. There is a yet another strategy which is the near infinite stepping of of potentiometer-like controls. These control systems seem to be very expensive so, AFAIK, they are used only for the commercial Garland/Manitowiac PICS and maybe the new Miele induction range have this. I say "maybe" for the Miele because there is nothing about it in the product literature and the display shows only whole-number settings, but a couple of posters here -- livinginseattle is the name I recall -- have reported finding that the knobs can be turned to provide fine gradations of "in-between" settings. Some folks would find that ideal. Then the question becomes: how much are you willing to spend for the "ideal" (and are there other design compromises that have to accept in order to get that ideal function for the burners?)
...See More
PLEASE help me choose countertop color asap!
Q
Comments (43)
What a gorgeous kitchen! I'm jealous of all that beautiful wood. The character of the wooden beams and wooden base cabinets bring such warmth and personality, it almost feels like the outdoors are coming in. I had looked under your name in the finished kitchens blog to see if you were there, really appreciate you sharing the photo. Your backsplash is so pretty, just the right amount of bling and lightness. Where did you find it? I'd like to do he same thing, with subway glass tile everywhere except right behind the stove, do arabesque there. If I had a kitchen like this, I'd want to cook a lot too. =) Love hearing that cleanup is easy with a stain resistant grout, that's a great tip, I'll be sure to ask for that too, Was it an epoxy grout?
...See More
Help me choose porch posts, please!
Q
Comments (6)
Definitely keeping shutters! I'll be coming back for suggestions on color. As the siding is going up, it seems to be a stronger green than the sample I had (the sample was more of a subtle greenish gray) but I still like it; just making me rethink the color scheme. Now that the siding is off of the porch area, I can see that there is a solid 8" tall run of (plain) trim along the top that was covered by the aluminum. We will be reproducing that. There was also trim around the garage door that was covered. We are going to actually make that a bit wider than the original; and the contractor has talked me into replacing the garage door -- so I'll have to choose a style for that, too. But I still need help with this decision on the posts!!! I am sure that I don't want round. I can choose square fluted, plain or recessed panel; and a variety of bases and capitals. I think fluted are too ornate for this house; recessed panel might add some interest. The basic decision I need help with though is whether to go with one 8" or 10" post at the corner, or two 6" or 8" posts (either one on each side of the corner or side by side in front). Perhaps I should start a new thread: Help! I need help with choosing posts, shutters and garage door! Maybe even a new front door!
...See More
User
4 years ago
last modified: 4 years ago
You have to define the problem before a solution can be found. When the problem is the contractor, and he’s responsible for making sure that the ductwork or the plumbing was located correctly according to the design, then he gets to pay to fix it. Keep the hood. Fix the issue.
PRO
Design Interior South
4 years ago
I would do stainless with brass trim to tie into your gold hardware. It will play into the warm tone of your tile and island.
User
4 years ago
last modified: 4 years ago
If the moderate priced wood hoods from the cabinet maker wasn’t affordable, do you really think that those over the top custom metal ones that cost twice as much are going to even be an option? And then need liners and remote blowers to make the pretty work?
PRO
Flo Mangan
4 years ago
Wentz - not sure of budget but with your kitchen style looking nice and modern, I would do one like this.
Anna (6B/7A in MD)
4 years ago
No suggestions on hood, but I wanted to say that I love your backsplash tile.
PRO
Filipe Custom Woodwork
4 years ago
I agree with

Design Interior South

Flo Mangan

In my opinion, the stainless will break up all of the wood and will create a beautiful focal point in that area.

I would also go with the larger hood.
PRO
Design Interior South
4 years ago
Yes to the gold trim on the hood @Flo Mangan Posted and that shape would be nice as well. One thing to consider when doing a chimney style is the height of your ceilings. They look better on higher ceilings 10' +. If you have a lower ceiling, not sure by your photo, then I would stick with a style that is less elongated like the ones I posted.
athleticannie
Original Author
4 years ago
This is the hood I have. Due to the height of the unit before it attaches to the chimney, it is too high to install and vent outside the house due to the location of the cut out on the exterior wall. I could use this one if I wanted to recirculate with the charcoal filters.

I also agree that I need to be careful since I have 8 foot ceilings.What do you think of this?
athleticannie
Original Author
4 years ago
Another view.
PRO
Flo Mangan
4 years ago
I would not do filtered return. Useless. You might want to look locally for metal shop that could do custom for you. That way you can get exactly right shape and size. I have done this in a couple homes and the cost was very competitive.
PRO
Flo Mangan
4 years ago
This is only photo I have handy. Different but lower ceiling like yours. Different style but had it made in metal shop. Took them specifications of ventilation system and they came out and measured and it turned out beautiful.
shead
4 years ago
IOW, your hood is too tall and misses the vent hole? If so, how much too tall is it?
shead
4 years ago
Also, it looks like you only have 8 ft ceilings. Many of those designs you posted above will NOT look right in your space because they will look short and squatty. You need either a true chimney hood or you need one that is roughly the same width at the top as at the bottom.
PRO
User
4 years ago
If the duct needs to be adjusted, it’s on the contractor to open the wall and make the adjustment. He had the measured design, and the product measurements and specifications. He’s gotta step up and do what it takes.
PRO
Design Interior South
4 years ago
A chimney style hood is going to be short for an 8' ceiling. That would leave maybe a foot stack which will look stunted. I agree with @Flo Mangan I would go to a metal shop and see about having one custom made. Stick with a style that doesn't have a "neck".
PRO
Flo Mangan
4 years ago
Are you acting as your own GC?
btydrvn
4 years ago
With all the shiny tile in the backsplash ..i would go with a matte finish on the hood ..it is really difficult without seeing more of your space to know whether you should have a show stopper style or a more understated style...for instance is there an open view from the rest of your home ? Should the style of the rest of your home influence your choice?
PRO
Design Interior South
4 years ago
This island looks to me the same tone as yours and the perimeter as well. This would be a great look in your space.
PRO
Flo Mangan
4 years ago
Did the best I could to mock up the hood DSI posted. Maybe it will help you visualize this style hood.
RedRyder
4 years ago
Design Interior South got it right. I’d look into that one. It warms everything up.
PRO
Flo Mangan
4 years ago
Your GC should be helping resolve this. Did you provide h/her with specifications of vent and hood at stud stage or before?
User
4 years ago
last modified: 4 years ago
”Wants help”, but doesn’t provide any of the needed information for anyone TO help. Sheesh.

This is a giant mess up by the contractor. It’s on him to fix. Why you’re even involved in finding a new hood is crazy. You had a hood. You had specs. You had measured plans and elevations. You had a GC. Enough said.

Even if you were the GC, the solution is the same. Open up the wall and fix the gosh darn problem that lies behind the wall, that you still haven’t drawn out and shown us. Tile should never have been installed without hooking up the hood and field verifying the venting. That’s an educational moment for someone.
athleticannie
Original Author
4 years ago
live_wire_oak I didn't ask for help about getting the contractor to tear everything out and start again. As a reminder, this is what I asked:
1. Should I stick with 42" or go to 36"?
2. If I switch to my first choice (wood), what shape do you like with my finishes?
3. What type of finish would you use? Shiplap? Drywall? Barn wood? Etc?
Design Interior South, do you know the manufacturer of the hood you suggested?
PRO
Design Interior South
4 years ago
last modified: 4 years ago
Which hood? One of the ones in my first post or the one in the photo of the kitchen? If it is the one of the photo of the kitchen the only information given is the "Raw Urth Designs fabricated the range hood". Here is their web site http://rawurth.com/product_group/metal-range-hood/. If it is one of the hoods in the first post I put up I would have to do a little digging. Just let me know.
athleticannie
Original Author
4 years ago
I like the last one you posted. I am looking at their site right now. My guess is since they consider themselves to be a boutique designer, it will be out of my budget.
PRO
Design Interior South
4 years ago
I would find a local fabricator and show them the photo and get a price on them recreating it for you. I do think that this will be the main feature of your kitchen based on the photos you have shown us. I also think because the windows that will be on each side of it are not symmetrical you need to do something bold and special to draw attention away from that fact and draw the eye to a phenomenal hood/focal point. I hope that since your contractor messed up on this they are helping you with a reimbursement as well as giving you their cost for their vendors pricing for the item.
athleticannie thanked Design Interior South
athleticannie
Original Author
4 years ago
I also saw these two:
PRO
User
4 years ago
1/10th of that hood cost would be better spent on moving the plumbing obstacle, to keep the hood you have. Not a new 12K custom hood.
lisabrodsky123
4 years ago
Love those 2 hoods you just posted! Can you share the manufacturer?
Yes Raw Urth hoods are absolutely stunning ... but you will pay a pretty penny. Got a quote yesterday for a 60” wide by 30” tall ... $7300 + $1000 shipping (includes the inside vent though)....wowza!
athleticannie thanked lisabrodsky123
athleticannie
Original Author
4 years ago
last modified: 4 years ago
I really like this one:
shead
4 years ago
I'm willing to bet that's a 9 ft ceiling, though. I'm not sure how great it would look with 12" chopped off the top.
athleticannie thanked shead
athleticannie
Original Author
4 years ago
lisabrodsky123...they are the same hood (RangeCraft Miami). I am exhausted from making these decisions.
athleticannie
Original Author
4 years ago
shead, all the pictures I posted are the same hood. I think the 2nd picture is for a 8' ceiling.
athleticannie
Original Author
4 years ago
Design Interior South, what type of business do I look for? A metal fabricator? A welder?
PRO
Design Interior South
4 years ago
Yes a metal shop/ fabricator. I would also consider wood that is wrapped with the metal banding as possibly a less expensive alternative.
PRO
Design Interior South
4 years ago
You could do a wood hood and take it into a metal fabricator and have metal strapping and rivets added and stain it to match
36"W Omega Series Canopy Range Hood, Maple · More Info

Castlewood Epicurean Chimney Hood, Maple, 36", No Ventilator/Liner · More Info

Castlewood Curved Gourmet Chimney Range Hood, Maple, 36" · More Info

38" 1065 CFM Hand Hammered Copper Wall Mounted Euro Range Hood · More Info
shead
4 years ago
I came across this photo and realized that this is what your hood would look like with the style you like and ceiling height you have:

Cheyenne Elegance · More Info
athleticannie
Original Author
4 years ago
The only good thing about the coronavirus is that it has given me a bit more time to choose a range hood.

I am still waiting for pricing on the hood above but want some input on these three stainless steel hoods. I tried to do the best job I could with mockups.

Please rank them.
PRO
Flo Mangan
4 years ago
C. It repeats shape of your drawers and is still sleek.
btydrvn
4 years ago
These hoods look a little underwhelming to me...this is a broad swath of a distinctive tile...and i would prefer a little more interesting style hood....but if you are more into understatement ...these hoods are more minimal and would all leave the tile as the most distinctive feature
btydrvn
4 years ago
B...the one you crossed out?..would be my choice of these 3
pittsburrito
4 years ago
last modified: 4 years ago
I recommend B as well, as it's funnel shape offers the best possibility for efluent capture & containment of the three options shown. (i.e. the most effective hood)
athleticannie
Original Author
4 years ago
Any other thoughts?
btydrvn
4 years ago
My thought from the beginning has been ....any opinion is just a stab in the dark .....as we have not seen any more of you adjoining spaces
btydrvn
4 years ago
If there are no other finished spaces....consider that whatever you choose will at least influence your other choices going forward
Shasta
4 years ago
What kind of cabinet pulls are you using? Are they copper? Is the lighting copper also? I can't quite tell. I would want to consider those elements when selecting a hood. Someone posted a hammered copper hood which might be nice. In all, I I think that with all of the warm tones, the stainless steel hood draws too much attention away from other elements of your beautiful kitchen.
PRO
User
4 years ago
There is nothing “wrong“ with the hood that you have already purchased.
PRO
Design Interior South
4 years ago
Sorry to say , your three options are mediocre at best and I hope the renditions you did are not to scale. I will stick with my same opinion that I shared above. You have an unbalanced window situation and whatever hood you put there needs to be a show stopper to draw attention away from that fact. I am also not loving the lightness and reflection properties of a straight stainless steel hood used there against your lovely cream tile. Hood is cool tile is warm. A hood is generally one of the features a kitchen is built around. You seem to be working backwards and because your budget has been exhausted elsewhere are just "making due" with this important choice. Perhaps you can hold off on the hood and use the one you have with modifications and save up for one that will be ideal for your space.

Related Stories

Ideabook 911: Help Me Finish My Foyer

By Becky Harris

LATEST NEWS FOR PROFESSIONALS How to Help Clients Dealing With a Death, Divorce or Other Change

By Gwendolyn Purdom

A general contractor, an interior designer and an organizer detail special process considerations for grieving clients

MOVING Relocating Help: 8 Tips for a Happier Long-Distance Move

By Laura Gaskill

Trash bags, houseplants and a good cry all have their role when it comes to this major life change

ORGANIZING Do It for the Kids! A Few Routines Help a Home Run More Smoothly

By Alison Hodgson

Not a Naturally Organized person? These tips can help you tackle the onslaught of papers, meals, laundry — and even help you find your keys

MOST POPULAR 9 Real Ways You Can Help After a House Fire

By Alison Hodgson

Suggestions from someone who lost her home to fire — and experienced the staggering generosity of community

SELLING YOUR HOUSE The Real Scents That Will Help Sell Your House

Ditch the potpourri and baked cookies. Follow these guidelines on scents to use and avoid to help sell your home

LIFE Decluttering — How to Get the Help You Need

By Alison Hodgson

Don't worry if you can't shed stuff and organize alone; help is at your disposal

COFFEE WITH AN ARCHITECT Mike Brady Lied to Me

By Jody Brown Architecture, pllc

Why "The Brady Bunch" is a terrible guide for the architectural profession

HOUZZ TOURS My Houzz: 38 Years of Renovations Help Artists Live Their Dream

By Esther Hershcovich

Twin art studios. Space for every book and model ship. After four decades of remodeling, this farmhouse has two happy homeowners

BATHROOM DESIGN Bathroom of the Week: Pamper-Me Features and Marble-Like Tile

By James Weske / JW Design, LLC

An Orlando, Florida, couple’s former cramped, dated master bathroom gets an elegant, contemporary update

Sponsored

More Discussions

Looking for ideas and opinion on kitchen countertop

3

How to design this patio with overhang under lean to extension?

14

What did you compromise on and did you regret it - sink edition

26

One large bathroom space vs separate toilet/shower & vanity areas?

9

does anyone have pics of everleigh or Inverness everleigh

0