OK I've changed my mind about how to approach your home. There are lots of details that have been fabricated on this house that I would change, but to get you over the finish line here is what I suggest. I think the key word here is SIMPLIFY. I would consider painting the complete home a soft greige gray color & select dark greige for the simple garage doors. Here are some colors from Sherwin Williams I tried to see what your home would look like if it was a light color & I think that grey/greige color could really update the appearance.

I do like the cerused look myself and its really what I initially had in mind as my stain. Its not a finish everyone offers, is likely to be an upcharge if it is offered, and is going to look best on a rift or quartersawn white oak which isn't cheap wood to start with. I'm happy with how mine turned out and everyone who sees it seems to like it. It's driftwood on maple with an black glaze. Without the black glaze, the pink of the wood showed through and was too much. It's definitely grey, but it has an underlying brown and slightly pink tone so its warm and not GREY. I think it fairly different/unique/unexpected. Would probably have been a bit much for the entire kitchen though, I'd be careful of using grey flooring though, it's such a huge surface can be overwhelming.

I have Brazilian cherry floors throughout the first floor and also have walnut furniture. I have the following colors in various rooms: BM Bunny Gray, BM Moonshine, Behr Clear Moon. Greens, grays and creams are recommended for red-toned furniture/floors. I picked those colors 16 years ago before I knew that, LOL! I would really look at Moonshine, it is a very subtle grayed green color and is gorgeous.

@cda1028... I'm not sure what your issue is, but I've been doing LTR and STRs for a very long time. I have been extremely successful, people pay me to consult on getting their STR business started. I have rented to celebrities, top politicians and my rentals have been used to film movies, TV shows and commercials in. Bottom line...I know what I'm doing. I never said I was not going to address the landscaping nor the inside. I came unto to Houzz as I know it attracts the top professionals in the Design arena. The thread I started was merely about getting the advice from others about EXTERIOR PAINT colors.. I know where my strengths and weaknesses lay. Picking paint colors has always been one of my weaknesses and as my Designer is on maternity leave for the next 6 months, I thought I'd pop on here see if I can get the opinions of some other professionals and even others who are good at this sort of thing. Knowing how to run a business does not make me a Designer. Everyone here has been EXTREMELY helpful. The reason I'm not revealing the exact location is because I know there are many people online who are "unbalanced". Some people feel comfortable putting their locations online, some do not. I fall into the latter category. After reading your very "aggressive" message to me, once again I feel that I've made the correct decision. Best of luck with your rental and no need to feel like I am competition to you... as I am 100% sure you are no competition to me.