I have a turquoise back-painted glass backsplash (and floor), but that's quite a commitment. I don't have specific tile suggestions, as I didn't really look at tile for myself. But I have seen so many really nice tiles on here. You could do teal, or you could do a mix of colors. You could also bring teal in with textiles or with wall paint (if you do a more plain backsplash). I like the tile you posted.

http://s1277.photobucket.com/user/treeshouse/library/Kitchen?sort=6&page=1

Painted ours. Used Cabinet Coat and hsve held up really well for at leas 7-8 years

These are all from Tilebar

The flower is blue but is hard to see in this pic

We have this one in white. It's 3d and is really neat.

Also 3d

Textured

Ooh, I love this

Oh, these tile examples are gorgeous. I love that last one too!

What do people think about the floors? They are red oak (I think) and about due to be refinished. I was just going to keep them the same (no stain). But would a darker color look good? Or clash with the maple cabinets?

Keep them light. Dark is impossible to keep clean and are dated, even now. Your unstained floors are classic and never out of style.

Hi Sarah, we have the same exact cabinet (colors) as you, and finding the right countertop and backsplash proved very challenging. I ditto the first individual who responded on keeping everything light and neutral. You'd be amazed!

"Updating"?? What's your goal to find something that will stand the test of time or something that you will tire of and get to "update" again and again and again? Your cabinets are beautiful. Leave them be. The back splash over all look is neutral even if the tile is no longer the "IT" product. Be happy it's not a loud floral!! You could swap it out for on trend subway but in the end over all you would have the same look, big picture. This idea that kitchens are throw pillows and should be updated every five years is INSANE. Yours looks in good repair. I don't see the NEED to do anything.

I agree that it looks fine, but if she's tired of it after 15 years (NOT 5), and the granite is damaged, she should change it if she wants. As to leaving her cabinets be, she says "I can't justify replacing them (or even painting/staining them)." Sounds to me like she's already planning to leave them be.

Totally get needing a change! Update the counters first, then the backsplash. I think the aqua/teal color would be fun, and I love the fun patterns.

Two things to consider:

You will get tired of the pattern eventually, so be prepared to replace at least the backsplash again before the rest.

Make sure you choose creamy, warm colors for tiles and counter that compliment your cabinets and don't pull the yellow. You have a lovely space - can't wait to see how it comes out!

^true about the patterns. Definitely something to keep in mind.

Thanks. @mnmamx3, so you think pure white counters (along with backsplash tiles that have a white base) would not work well? I was thinking it might keep things from looking kind of blah and dreary.

I know the backsplash pattern won't be in trend forever...but we plan to be in the house another 5-7 years, so hoping I will at least still like it during that time!

Perfect timing. I've been trying to figure out what to do with our little kitchen. We live in a cottage in a retirement community so I can't do a lot, but I can do tile and these ideas are beautiful.

Sarah, I'm no expert, I've just seen tonal clashes in other projects before. I love the plan but remember the colors in your living room have far less woodtone to contend with. Pure white is relative. There are so many variances in even the whitest white that can give it a slight undertone that can clash with your cabinets or floor. Also keep in mind you lighting can affect how it looks. You can buy lighting in various options to even out coolness or warmth.

Go get counter samples (as big as they will let you check out) and bring them home to your house. You will figure out pretty quickly what does and does not work with your wood.

Hi Sarah,

What lightbulbs are you currently using?

Yes, getting samples is essential.

Sarah I think you should get whatever countertop YOU want. Do you want all white or even like all white?I love your maple cabinets and think you could do a lot of counters with them whether quartz or granite that are still light in color. Here are a few examples of Quartz:

The first is Cambria Kelvingrove with an aqua color glass subway tile. It has more tan and brown tones.

The second is Cambria Skar Brae which has a greyish tan color but still has a lot of the white.

Here is Skar Brae on a slab

This is from MSI website: Calacutta Laza

or Calacutta Verona:

For Granites you have all kinds of choices.

What do you want your accent colors to be, especially in your backsplash? Some of those above are gorgeous. Have fun and play around with different combinations. Your choices are many and yes your light bulbs will make a huge difference in how your kitchen colors appear.

Hi Sarah. Both your living room and kitchen look lovely on their own. But if you're looking to freshen up your kitchen, I'd suggest to have it mirror your living room. Although you're not wanting to, I'd say to paint your cabinets white or off white to balance the fireplace. It would help to bounce light around the room, too. And I always feel you should put in your home things that make you happy-those encaustic tiles you showed are pretty, but if you're worried about being too trendy or specific for resale in several years, perhaps a marble backsplash with a neutral countertop. You can add your own personality and colors thru accents that won't mean major renovations--perhaps you can put together a few tiles, frame them and hang it behind the stove. Or white wall cabinets with a teal island base with matching countertops. Or all cabinets white with your barstools having the color or pattern. Your floors are beautiful - unless they need refinishing I'd leave them. Either way, if you're looking to sell in a few years, I'd keep in classically neutral with your personality in your accents. Best of luck -you have a great base to work with!

There are some beautiful Moroccan tile look rugs and runners. I would satisfy my Moroccan tile lust with one of those and go more subtle on the backsplash.

You don't have a lot of space between your counters and the bottom of your cabinets. Strong patterns need space to breathe, I think a strong patterned backsplash has the potential to look cramped and busy in your kitchen.

The other issue with strong or large patterns is the repeat. You need to make sure that the repeat will fit nicely under your cabinets. If not, the tile setter will have to make too many cuts and the pattern will be ruined.

d-gw: great points about the pattern. Sarah - keep in mind there are lots of cool SHAPES of tiles that can give you the interest you are looking for without concerns about pattern headaches. I personally chose a handmade minty tile but in a fun pattern and a very plain grey countertop. I do love the look of patterns but I just replaced my backsplash to get rid of the accent tiles I had and wanted to choose something I could tweak with different hardware or accessories.

Obviously, you'd have to find a spot for a smaller microwave. Perhaps a shelf in the island?

I apologize for the terrible photoshop skills. It's from the Houzz sketch function.

So, I have a question regarding replacing an OTR MW with a hood (not under cabinet hood). How do you create enough space for the hood? Assuming that the current cabinet is 30" (like the MW and range), how do squeeze a hood in there? Or how do you rearrange the upper cabinets to make space for the hood?

Interesting. I never thought about replacing the microwave with a hood (I never use those cabinets anyway). Could be good. Although I think I really want to keep a microwave, so I'd have to figure out where I could put one (counter, in the island somewhere, etc.).

Sarah and nosoccermom - Sarah, we have/had almost the same kitchen (cabinet color, OTR microwave, the 'lone' cabinet to the far right of the pix). We took out our microwave, and had a difficult time finding a beautiful wall hood that would fit into our space (30" wide, with a 6" duct) to avoid major overhaul of that area.

We ended with an under cabinet hood, and hubby built/is building a cover for it to give the illusion of a wall hood. :)

MANY DIYers have posted on how to make this happen. Might want to check them out.

https://www.homedepot.com/p/Fasade-18-in-x-24-in-Traditional-1-PVC-Decorative-Backsplash-Panel-in-Matte-White-B50-01/206110615 It comes in a variety of colors. I would hesitate to put a lot of blue or teal item in the kitchen, unless it is amongst a variety of other small colors, to a certain extent. I hope you can find something that is less busy for the counter surface, maybe with only a small amount of pattern in it, and than find something like this product to finish the look for your kitchen? Matte White is just one of the many colors. I can see 4 or more tones, in this product that would look nice, and it does mimic the divided light of the windows in your den I noticed. The price varies with the hue selected.. From your photos I guess you have the walls painted a greige that goes gray or tan depending on the light or time of day? Very very pretty living/kitchen area !!!!!

I was ready to rip out my MW and upper cabinet until I realized that a wall hood might be a problem. I haven't found an easy answer (i.e. trying to rearrange uppers).

and if you don't have under cabinet lighting, please be sure to add some BEFORE changing countertop and backsplash.

nosoccermom, there are some decent looking under cabinet hoods. Have you looked at that those? I used one to replace my OTR microwave in my last house. Then we reconfigured the wall oven cabinet by lowering the existing oven and added an open cabinet for the microwave. Excuse the bright red, it was the early 2000s. I can't believe I redid this kitchen over 15 years ago!

It was tricky to find an under cabinet hood that worked with my preexisting clearances.

nonsoccermom - We had a set of cabinets above the range, and built our 'sudo' wall hood cover around it. We took out the cabinet doors, and hid the cabinets under wood cover, where the original/now duct is. We built that part of the hood so that it's removable should we ever need to get to the hood/duct to repair.

Interesting thought; and, yes, an under cabinet hood would work. But I don't want to hijack the thread.

It's been a year since I posted, but I did want to include an update! We decided to paint the cabinets, refinish the floors (they really needed it), add some molding/legs to the island, and replace the counters and backsplash. I went pretty traditional with white and greys and am still looking for an opportunity to put some accents of color. But I'm very happy with how it turned out! It was a somewhat dark morning when I took the photos, but in real life it's very bright and cheerful!

Wow! Great transformation! What paint color you used? Did you paint yourself? Share please more info and thank you for update. great kitchen!

Thanks! Here are some of the details. We did not paint ourselves, had a local cabinet painting company do it. The perimeter cabinet paint color is SW Snowbound, island paint color is SW Peppercorn. The island counter is Silestone Lyra and the perimeter counter is Steel Grey leathered granite. Backsplash tile is Home Depot Jeffrey Court Weathered Grey. Floors were stained with a mix of dark walnut and special walnut stain.

Thank you, Sarah! One more question about wall color, please

We left the original wall color, BM Pale Oak!

thank you, like color combination.

Oh yay! I’m so glad you updated with pictures! I absolutely love your choices. Looks very cohesive with your family room. The floors look wonderful! I’m sure you feel happy with everything. For some, it’s hard to put paint on wood. But this is a perfect example of how lovely it can be! Congrats!!

This is the perfect counter-post to every time we tell someone not to paint their cabinets. It looks great.

It turned out beautifully!

It looks great! You did a good job. If mine I would add some touches of teal. Maybe one or 2 things on your countertop in teal. Something that would be useful not just pretty,and maybe a rug.

Beautiful - you did a great job!!

Your kitchen looks fabulous. I am still going back and forth with the paint or not to paint our maple kitchen cabinets and your pictures are quite the inspiration!

I was definitely hesitant to paint the maple cabinets. But honestly the paint looks factory applied (they did the doors offsite in their shop, so I guess it is pretty much factory applied) and so durable.

would you mind sharing the approx. cost (and your general location) of the cabinet painting)? Thanks.

Nice job. :)

Beautiful job Sarah. So many people are hesitant to paint wood cabinets, but you could have never achieved what you did without painting them. It looks wonderful

Thanks so much for sharing the cost!

The total cost was about $12k and we are in North Carolina. Keep in mind this includes things beyond the kitchen update (like refinishing all of hardwoods on first floor and hiring movers to move the furniture to the garage, etc.).