I want to rip out ceiling and change design of this addition
I am adding a 900 sq foot addition to a midcentury modern home. I am trying to honor the lines of the existing home home. Because there is intense sun in my state, the addition faces South west, and there is a 17’ run of floor to ceiling windows in hallway, I added pockets for motorized blinds. We had to change the framing from the original plan to accommodate this, which meant adding support masonry columns and changing the design. I was not okay with the supports, as I wanted a long run of uninteruppted glass and block, but the architect seemed okay with it. I have since found out that we could have added a beam instead, but nobody’s told me this was an option!
I came home Thursday night to the drywall backing being in. I was very disappointed. On the plan it looks like the columns are 1’4” x 8 to 16”. They vary in size but are around 26x26”. There are 8” drywall returns at the windows!! Nowhere in my original house are there 8” returns. They are 4” maximum. To enter the hallway, you have to walk through two 26x26” columns, effectively creating another hallway. Not only that, but if you look at the house plan, the new hallway entrance is even more not in line with the entry hallway on the other side of the house. I hate it!
The architect, who worked with the original architect of the house thinks it’s fine. I begged and pleaded for options to change it. Why did he never tell me we could use a beam and alleviate it all of this? Why did no one discuss 8” drywall returns? I cannot see 8” returns on the plan. I asked the contractor if he could have turned the 2x4” to the side to take off 2” and he said yes.
The contractor said we could pull out the framing in the hallway and that side of the bedroom and redo it, so it’s consistent with the origI always plan. It would mean no recessed blinds. When I spoke with the shade store, the solar shades are not that large anyway, but mine will also be motorized. It would also mean the window in the bedroom will not match up with the hallway as we staggered it to match the new version. (Maybe someday I can replace it with a larger window). The cost will be significant to redo the framing.
What would you do? I want to tear it out.
Thank you.
As built plan:
Original plan:
Columns to enter hallway from house:
Looking toward bedroom. Architect suggests making staggered columns on left into one big massive column.
Comments (16)
rockybird
5 years agoRelated Discussions
I just ripped out my kitchen backsplash!
Comments (13)Ashe 42, I love charcoal slate and these tiles are great. They are rectangular with variation in size of the rectangles, so sort of a more linear look than a lot of traditional square slate tiles. The tile is from Earthstone Gallery in Reno, NV but I don't actually know the brand (ordered them directly from the showroom based on the display). I now have 24 square feet of gently used tile, but it wasn't inexpensive - upward of $20/sq ft as I recall. Argh. Linelle, thanks for the words of support - greatly appreciated! Unfortunately there is some tangential family connection and it is a small community. I don't think they're bad people, it's just not a business model that lends itself to good customer service (we have to fight with them to get itemized cost lists, like for plumbing fixtures, and then consistently find errors - all of which labels us "bad clients"). This crew does good work, so I'm a lot better off than other stories I've heard in that I feel the house will hold up! All the subs live in fear of this builder and their designers, who will cut them off at the drop of a hat if they talk to their clients out of turn, etc. But that is the business model - controlling the clients to get them to agree to what is profitable, and controlling the subs to get them to do what they want, is the bottom line for the relatively low price/sq ft in a more assembly line "semi-custom home" approach. I do feel ambivalent about having made this choice, and honestly had no idea what I was getting into; nonetheless, it was our choice. The good news is that I really like the foreman and many of the subs, so the people who are actually doing the work are great (vs the owners, managers and avaricious designers)....See MoreWant to change out a portion of my backsplash, need opinions!!
Comments (54)ellendi and A2gemini - both of your designs you created with the Grazia Rixi tiles are stunning! I need do some google searching tonight and this weekend for simple backsplash ideas. That's what I want - simple and classic. I can embellish with the nick nacks and change those out as they get old and boring. ellendi, I love yours that it doesn't have any accents, just the brick tile. I am drawn to that shape, as it's the similar to the subway I have now. I am leaning more toward that at this point than the square as I feel it fits my kitchen and overall decorating style better. A2gemini - I am drawn to yours because it does have the accent tiles that bring the colors of the granite subtly into the backsplash. After some thinking, I am afraid that if I just use the accent tiles that I posted yesterday (ellendi, I agree, nix the ORB pencil liner) and not anything else that draws the granite colors in it will look, what word am I looking for, too contrast-y? Too sharp and not subdued? If I use the brick shape only, is it even possible to incorporate accent tiles? Gosh, I do sound like such a newb and high maintenance. But please don't give up on me yet! What about if I did a row of bricks, then a matching pencil liner, and then more bricks all the way up? What is the consensus of the the artistic folks reading my plight think would look best with my granite? Which, by the way I have fallen in love with again now that I have found the Rixi tiles...I had been cursing it for the past month or so as it, IMO, has been so hard to find something compatible! Also, there are two areas that do no have cabinets above them. Just to keep things simple (especially to the DH as I know he would never go for a 'no' backsplash idea in those areas) I intend to replace the existing footprint the same way. Do I end those two areas with the matching small end piece or go for the more grand and elaborate end cap? (forgive me, I don't know the technical names...) And, just to complicate matters, one of those areas has a cabinet door that will open up touch the area, so perhaps I do need to just do a flush end cap......See MoreAnyone want to stop me before I rip? (a backsplash question)
Comments (22)First...to Jterrilynn....an apology for repeatedly misspelling your name. KK, I did not tape up the tile. They are so heavy and so expensive! I am really afraid one will break. I ordered extras, but not with the extra course under the windows in mind. So, I did a mock-up using paper and it looks darn good when I squint my eyes to get a sense of what it will look like. Circuspeanut, thanks so much for that picture! That says it all! At first I thought, "yeah, but her counter matches the window trim." Then I realized mine does, too. doh (Are you a her, btw?) Thanks for cheering us on, davidro! Blfenton, I plan to take this all one step at a time. I won't paint the window trim unless I really need to. I still think the uppers could benefit from paint and the truth is I always wanted a painted kitchen but my builder didn't offer it. I just ordered the espresso (almost three years ago now!) and figured I could paint later if I wanted to. The tile is two colors which, in combination, look like a third color somewhere in the middle. So I will probably use one of the two actual colors, so there will be some variation from the visual blending of the two. (Did that make any sense at all?!) Anyway, I need the tile on the wall before I get too crazy picking colors. The tile will run under the cabs on the L side of the kitchen. The opposite (fridge) wall will just be paint. The tile will end at the lower edge of the hood. I will remove the apron from both windows. Like you, I want the easy clean-up. Thanks for all your input!...See MoreHow can I secure this porch floor/addition ceiling w/o tearing dow
Comments (9)Ok, so apparently big bust for getting any real or helpful insight or suggestions on here, so I’ll start off by saying thanks for that! Next, yes, my company does renovation of kitchens and bathrooms, thanks for noticing, good catch there, I don’t know how I would have done this without you! We also specialize in custom tile design and installation, although i’m not sure what any of that has to do with the soundability of a pre-existing structure of my personal house or how that thought process, pointing out the obvious or sarcastic and ugly comments are helpful in any way?? Obviously I’ve already had a professional out here, otherwise I wouldn’t be asking for any other HELPFUL suggestions, tips, design inspiration for maybe a similar situation or layout. Here’s a tip for all reading, if you read a question and don’t have a legit idea, answer, or anything that may be helpful or of use, you don’t have to answer! you can just keep trolling, I mean scrolling! smh thanks again, you’ve been great! So helpful...See Morerockybird
5 years agolast modified: 5 years agorockybird
5 years agolast modified: 5 years agorockybird
5 years agorockybird
5 years agolc
5 years agorockybird
5 years agolast modified: 5 years ago
Mrs. S