Looking for an HE Powder Detergent - Hamstrung by Indecision
Vasiliki Demmas
5 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (32)
Related Discussions
Gain HE powder detergent opinions?
Comments (28)I know several people who use Gain products and are happy with it. I tried it but I couldn't take the smell. Performance-wise, it worked just fine. I can't stand scented laundry detergents. I switched to Tide Free/Sensitive skin several years ago and haven't been disappointed. No need for the myriad of additives I had to use with other brands. I don't find that it's any less effective than the "original" Tide. I don't believe that perfume and dye contribute to cleaning. They still have enzymes in it so I doubt there's a significant difference other than pulling the stink and color out of it. I used to itch really badly from Tide so I didn't touch it for decades but after the compaction I tried it and it worked fine, no itch, but again, I couldn't stand the smell. When my clothes are washed I don't want them to stink - stench is when you're supposed to wash clothes. So I went to the Free?Sensitive and been happy. That's now changed to Free & Gentle but I haven't tried that version as yet but I suspect the name change was a marketing idea rather than a formula change, at least any significant change. I also have Era Free but haven't tried it yet. I'm sure I'll be pleased with it, and if it doesn't handle the toughest jobs, no problem. 150 oz jug only cost about $6 or $7 so I can use it for lighter duty if needed. I have so much laundry detergent built up that I won't be buying for a long time. Yes Tide is P&G's flagship brand. However, each of them have their own niche it aims toward. Tide of course is the big dog, do everything. Gain is for smell. It's formulated to hold smell longer. Cheer's market is toward bright whites and anti-fade. Dreft and Ivory Snow are targeted for babies and super-sensitive. Era was for stains but became the redhead stepkid until lately when they've decided to start marketing it a little more aggressively and gain back some lost market share. I used to use Era years back but then they upped the price so much I said nope. Now it's a bargain brand again. Personally, I think there were people who wanted to kill off the brand and that's why they dropped advertising and support for it until recently. Seems to be quite a coincidence that about the time of a CEO change came that they started pushing it more. Purely speculation, but makes sense to me. I'm trying to remember, maybe someone here will know for sure. Did Woolite used to be a P&G brand? I was thinking it was years back. I know it's not P&G now. I can't really find anything definitive on it either. I suppose I could contact Reckitt Benckiser but thought maybe someone here would know....See MoreAre all liquid HE detergents bad for front loaders?
Comments (0)So after hours of perusing this forum, I'm more confused than ever. Is there a current consensus on whether liquid detergents are to blame for buildup of slimy scum on the outer drum? Or is it only liquid when used with cold washes? Will regular use of a "sanitize" high temp load or a load with Oxy eliminate that build up? (I use the sanitize at least once a week with sheets and towels, so I suspect/hope I don't have that nasty buildup.) I've had a FL for about 2 years with absolutely no problems with odors. I've just decided I'd like to switch to a more eco-friendly laundry regime and want to find an alternative to TideHE---though other than the fact that it's a huge brand name petrochemical, I generally think TideHE works great for us. I'd love to find these results in a natural brand, preferably a powder because it would have less packaging and less fillers. So for powders, I had narrowed my choices to Persil and Charlies. I love the way powdered Persil smells, and I absolutely *want* to love it. Reminds me of my childhood detergent. I can see my mom folding our childhood laundry when I smell it. But it didn't seem to clean anything in my wash. Most of my kids jeans and tee shirts smelled and looked like they were still dirty after washing with Persil. So that's out. I know lots of people love Charlie's... my mom included. She just gave me a bag of it to try. But it doesn't seem to clean my clothes as well as the tide, and I tend to like a tiny bit of a scent to my clothes when they're done. I'm going to continue trying it, but I just don't yet feel like a convert. So I keep coming back to the liquid detergent options. I'm considering Method's HE Liquid and Seventh Generation Liquid HE. Both seem to have some sort of plant based softener, so I'm wondering if that's potentially going to gunk up the machine worse than something like a TideHE liquid. Or is that a non-issue if I'm using a sanitize mode once in a while and not over-dosing. Thanks, Kmama...See MoreWhat is your favorite HE detergent and why?
Comments (53)My FL (Frigidaire GLTF2940ES) is being delivered in about 2 weeks. Was going to buy one in a couple of years but my horrible 14yo Admiral TL went kerflooey rather dramatically about a week ago and moved the schedule up a tad! I've been reading and reading and reading and I still have several questions regarding detergents. So I'm seeing two "green" detergents discussed here, Bi-O-Kleen and Seventh Generation. Any others recommended? I have chemical sensitivities - let's not even TALK about stuff like Tide Free, ugh! - and admit to a big ole hippie streak as a result. :-) We've been using Seventh Generation products off and on for years, in fact the jug of 7G detergent in my laundry room now is the Free & Clear HE because they didn't have the non-HE in the giant jugs that were on sale, so I'll surely start with that just to use it up but I note reports of "meh" cleaning. Has anyone used BioPac? Their website says their "Ultra" products are HE-OK, and I've had no reaction to their detergent in the past - I know home FLs and commercial ones are different animals, but it worked very well in the laundromat FLs. Is the Bi-O-Kleen Free & Clear as effective as the Premium Plus, which seems to have the most fans? We'll be using mostly cool and warm washes just because we own virtually nothing that should be washed in hot - our sheets and towels are colored and we have purchased very little white clothing for years because of high iron content in the water - although I did see the info about biofilm and will take that under advisement. (I am not at all comfortable with leaving the washer door open lest our adorable but not very bright cat climb in to explore, since she cannot be closed out of the laundry area. We have always kept the top loader closed due to inquisitive cat and never got mold/mildew in that, is this a pretty good indicator that we may be fairly OK with the FL?) Do some natural detergents work better in these lower temperatures than others? Should I stick with liquids for the cooler washes for complete dissolution? How about dealing with vegetable oils - my DH does massage and often gets jojoba or grapeseed oil on his dark blue jersey sheets. Hot water sets the oil and the eventual oil-funk, we ruined I don't know how many sheets while he was in massage school! We've always used a very small dollop of CitraSolv or other degreaser in the TL but that's a no go with the FL, right? Any massage therapists (or fry cooks ;-)) out there combatting grease spots? Do any of the "specialty" detergent companies send out samples, or can they be obtained in very small packages to try out? (I can get BioPac by the ounce at my local health food store, but that's the only one I know of.) Buying these machines in the first place has kicked our budgetary buns, the notion of buying $10+ packages of detergent that may well sit on the shelf gives me the shakes! Most of our friends don't even have their own washing machines, much less fancy-pants FLs, so moochingsharing ;-) with them won't work....See MoreNeed HE detergent recommendation - Free & Clear, Whiter Whites
Comments (14)A Free and Clear detergent still probably has optical whiteners and other additives which may be clinging to your clothes through multiple washes. Your fabric softener is likely building up on your clothes too. I've read it does if you use it on cloth diapers. Fabric softener sheets also leave a residue inside the dryer that can come off onto clothes/diapers. Not sure if liquid does the same thing. I have found I do not need softener sheets when my clothes rinse clean. The only exception would be for synthetic, static-prone fabrics like acrylic. I use Charlie's Soap (detergent) now for all our laundry, including cloth dipes. For sanitation, I use hot washes for diapers and underclothing as well as towels and washcloths/dishrags. I haven't mastered using an oxygen bleach yet, probably because I have a front-loader so the clothes can't soak as easily. On the other hand, I don't feel I need it often--only ocassionally to remove stains. HE machines often get detergent build-up inside the machine on the outside of the drum where you can't see it. This can cause mildew, stink, etc. When I had to have our Kenmore's electronics repaired (same as Duet), the repairman said to only use 1 oz. of detergent and applauded my frequent use of vinegar. If you want to see if you have build-up, do an empty load. To see if your clothes have detergent build-up, which might be causing your dingy whites, do a load without detergent. In either case, if you see a good amount of suds, you have build-up. If you do, then do several washes with vinegar, then plain rinses. Check again, and repeat as needed. For prevention, periodically do a hot load with vinegar. Incidentally, I put the vinegar into the liquid softener dispenser, which empties into the last rinse cycle on my HE machine. Don't put it in with the detergent as they neutralize each other. I've read a lot about washing diapers in HE machines, and most of the info applies to other laundry as well. There are definitely some detergents to avoid. Here are two articles which cover the topic well I think. http://www.sunshinediapers.com/cloth-diaper-university/choosing-a-detergent/ http://www.greenmountaindiapers.com/washing-diapers.htm...See MoreVasiliki Demmas
5 years agoVasiliki Demmas
5 years agoVasiliki Demmas
5 years agoVasiliki Demmas
5 years agoVasiliki Demmas
5 years agoVasiliki Demmas
5 years ago
Related Stories
BATHROOM DESIGNPowder Room Essentials to Keep Guests Happy
Set out these bathroom necessities (hello, hand towels) to make your company comfortable and your parties run smoothly
Full StoryBATHROOM WORKBOOK12 Ways to Get a Luxe Bathroom Look for Less
Your budget bathroom can have a high-end feel with the right tile, stone, vanity and accessories
Full StoryFURNITUREHow to Keep Your Upholstery Looking Good
You wouldn't expect your car to maintain itself. Show your sofa and chairs the same courtesy with this 3-part strategy
Full StoryHOUSEKEEPINGHow to Keep Your White Spaces Looking Great
Brighten up your white walls, floors and furniture with these cleaning and maintenance tips
Full StoryEVENTSLook What Tile Can Do Now: 9 Versatile New Finishes
See exciting new stoneware looks from Italy’s big ceramic tile and bath show
Full StoryBATHROOM MAKEOVERSBathroom of the Week: Artful Sophistication in an 1820 Home
A first-floor bathroom serves as a powder room, laundry room and soaking spot in this Massachusetts Colonial
Full StoryBEDROOMS11 Reasons to Love White Bedding
For easy bedding that makes neutrals sing and accessories pop, look to the white side
Full StoryHOUSEKEEPINGHow to Clean Marble Countertops and Tile
Acidic solutions can damage your marble surfaces. Here’s how to keep marble looking clean and amazing
Full StoryTHE HARDWORKING HOME8 Laundry Room Ideas to Watch For This Year
The Hardworking Home: A look at the most popular laundry photos in 2014 hints that dog beds, drying racks and stackable units will be key
Full StoryHOUSEKEEPINGHow to Clean Grout — Stains and All
If your grout is grossing you out, this deep-cleaning method will help it look new again
Full Story
doreycrouse