SHOP PRODUCTS
Houzz Logo Print
ilovemytrees

Did Dh and I screw up our brand new picket fence? Please advise.

ilovemytrees
6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago

Hi.

Dh and I put up an adorable small cedar wood picket fence. We were
going to paint it white, but we loved the natural look of the cedar so
we were just going to keep it as it is. We went and bought Thompson's
water sealer in clear and applied it to the entire fence last night. We
thought that was what you had to do to keep the fence from turning grey.

Well, we found out online after the fact (of course) that cedar
fences will still turn grey, even though the Home Depot guy assured me,
after I pressed him on that issue. it was the only issue I cared about,
and he said this will prevent it from turning grey.

Now we know it will turn grey unless we do maintenance on it every 6
months etc and that is not something Dh and I want to assign ourselves
to. So we decided to go back to the original idea of painting the fence
white.

Only now we read online someone saying that Thompson's water sealer
is the worst thing you can put on a fence before painting, and that we
will have to sand all of it off! That makes no sense to me. Aren't you
supposed to protect the wood first, before you paint it? We live in NY
and have harsh winters, I don't know how long the wood would hold up
without some protection. We did use pressure treated wood, fwiw.

Thompson's has said that of course people can paint after using their
sealer, that if people put too much on then they would have to remove
the excess, but if it's applied correctly (which we did) then by all
means paint, using an oil based paint.

I wish we could have left our fence natural, but if we can't, I don't
want our paint coming off because of the sealer. I guess it has to do
with the cedar's oil coming out. Can anyone advise? Dh and I have never
worked with wood before, so we are complete novices. I'd be grateful for
any tips or advice. Thanks.

Comments (11)