I'd be tempted to take off all the shutters, since they're way too small for your wide windows. Second choice black, although the current white isn't bad. Frond door I'd go with a cheery color that contrasts with the brick, especially to come out from under the new roof -- a bright medium blue, say.

That's what happens when it's not painted properly. It's a different story when brick is painted with the proper prep and product. With that said, the look you have right now is a look people work really hard to achieve. The flaking paint on brick might just be serendipity. Check out the Romabio IG feed and you'll see what I mean. You could leave it as is and the more that flakes off, may be the better. https://www.instagram.com/romabiopaints/

Is the trim around the windows paintable? I ask bc you’ve got a lot of things going on between the front door color, the siding and the brick. The trim around the windows further distracts.

Why oh why do people insist on taking pictures with the house shaded, then request opinions on color? Take the picture when the sun is at your back and the front of the house is in natural light. And yes to a nice, soft sage green. It’s lovely in a wooded setting, and if the house tends to get mold, it will be much less obvious. Lovely house!