You need some contrast and something lighter, as these samples are too similar to your cabinet color or are too dark. I would go with tones that are in the existing tile.

I think with dark cabinets and counters, you need a lighter floor. Are you planning to keep the countertop also?

I also I think you need more contrast. They are too close to the cabinet color.

The counters are staying. We are replacing much of the flooring because of water damage so the new wood floors will be in most of the main floor. Maybe I need to get some new samples. I was going for the warmer toned wood because that is what I like and it seemed to coordinate with the colors in the cabinets but if it's too dark, I don't want it to look bad. Mainly it just needs to look nice because we are planning on selling in the near future.

You need at least 2 shades lighter than your cabinets.

I think something with a pickled finish would look nice and would pick up the tone of the back splash tiles.

Thanks everyone. I am going to get some lighter samples to look at tomorrow.

opphop, I had to look up pickled wood but it does look good. At first I thought of that old style pickled wood and thought "Yuck!" But it's really nice. Maybe a little risky though for this market.

I think that the lightest floor above is perfect!

grapefruit, I like that one too. I would have never picked it myself!

Fluffy, maybe I mean more like gray washed:

I think that the gray floors are too trendy, and I do not care for that color with your cabinets and countertops.

Yes, I'm afraid they would be too trendy as well. Thank you for posting the picture.