Any advice on how to deal with resentment to husband caused by MIL?
User
7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (32)
Related Discussions
MIL - Am I being Childish?
Comments (7)I agree with the other posters. It's hard, but I think from reading your post that you know what the right thing to do here is. Get past these issues so that everyone in the family can have good time together while you can -- someday it will be too late. No matter how irritating the person, it seems like after they are gone, we wonder why we didn't focus on the good parts of the relationship instead of spending all the time only worrying about the bad parts. Emmhip's comments are far from rare. I am learning to focus on enjoying what I DO like about my MIL's (of 23 years) company while I can. We have always had a good relationship, but I let all kinds of little things drive me nuts, and I just made a decision to STOP letting that be. It was easier than I thought (I tried to picture how I would want my future daughter-in-law to say about me!). And I have to tell you, I am much happier, and I am sure she and my husband are, too. What was so precious about those annoyances that I wasted time and energy thinking about them? I'm not sure exactly what it was that upset you so much about the relatives (and "pre-relatives") moving in with her a few years ago. That they did it? That they didn't tell you? That they weren't married? It doesn't matter that we can't tell. What is important is that YOU figure out what it was that bothered you. If it is that they did it at all, think about what an earlier poster said: it is their lives, and they have the right to make their own choices even if you think they are foolish ones (and even if you are 100% right). If it is that no one told you -- well, you need to ask yourself WHY they didn't want to tell you. What happens when they tell you something you don't want to hear? The "right" length for a visit depends on so many things -- how often the visits come, whether you visit back, whether she has other things to do when she visits, how well she entertains herself, etc. But although we can all sympathize with a long MIL visit, try to think about how you would feel to be limited to only 2-3 days a year to see your own child, or to feel unwelcome, unwanted, and judged in his home. My MIL was here for a long time after one of the recent hurricanes knocked out her power. In a way, the extended visit was sort of easier, because she didn't expect anyone to drop what they were doing and entertain her. We actually had the best visit we've ever had. I am ashamed of all the times I rolled my eyes or complained to my friends about her. You asked, "Am I being childish, or am I justified in the way I feel?" Do you think it has to be one or the other? You can certainly be justified in having whatever feelings you do. That is never childish. It is the actions we take based on our feelings that can be childish. A child thinks only of her own feelings and desires, and imagines that things can work out neatly, no loose ends. A grown woman knows that things aren't perfect, we can't control others, and sometimes there IS no resolution to be had -- so you just have to decide what you want life to look like, and do what you need to do to help make it that way, never mind what has happened before. We all understand that this is easier advice to give than to follow! Hang in there. You won't regret it....See MoreHusband looking for advice
Comments (28)"...or am I still chasing a dream?" Not trying to be a jerk or anything, honestly, I feel for you, having been thru this myself. But if I had to guess, I would say the chances of reconnecting with her are not great. I think I can offer some advice, since I really did go thru a lot of what you describe with my ex (only real difference is by the time I realized there were issues and started trying to reconnect with her, the affair had been going on for 6 months, you only have mild suspicions at this point). Don't look at this ordeal, as many guys do, as a "challenge", "something to conquer", "something to fix". Love does not work like that for women. It is fairly obvious she has fallen out of love with you, same as my ex did with me. I did love my ex...before I found out about the affair, she was not a perfect match for me in many many ways but I was happy and desperately wanted to "fix" the marriage. I went about it completely in the wrong way. I'm a "logical" person by nature (engineer, computer programmer, etc), who thinks rationally and not emotionally. I looked at the problems we were having as just things on a checklist that I could change and all the problems would go away. What I didn't realize is that she didn't want me to "fix" things, she wanted attention, romance, to be wooed, to feel special....all that stuff that seems silly to lots of guys (still does, sorry ladies) but women live for, whether they admit it or not. If you do make the decision to do whatever it takes to save this marriage (and don't do it JUST for the child, yes it plays a big part of it, but be honest with yourself and figure out whether this is really the person you love and want to spend your life with), the first thing you need to do is get home. You have ZERO chance if you are across the planet....none. You sound relatively young, money issues will usually take care of themselves in the long run if you are hard working and not stupid in your lifestyle, you have only ONE shot at winning her back, and more time apart from you is just more time for her to lose her feelings for you. Once home, you essentially will be starting from ground zero with her, you will essentially have to wooo her all over again, like you were just starting out. I didn't do this, I took the approach of "let's talk about what's wrong so I can fix it" and "what am I doing wrong?" This had no effect on her, I realize now. Sure, couples therapy should eventually be part of it I think, but the main focus should be in trying to reconnect with HER, not identifying and fixing problems. Take her on dates, go for walks, send her silly emails with pix of kittens, whatever makes her smile. Spend TIME with her...not just with your child there too. Again, not sure if it's possible at this point, but taking this approach might be your best shot. Again, take my advice with a grain of salt as it is from some stranger online...don't quit your job unless you convince yourself it is the right thing to do. But as someone who's been thru this, and didn't make the right choices, I wish I had the ability to go back in time and change the way I approached things....See MoreResent supporting my new husband
Comments (32)I was resent for supporting my husband at the beginning of the relationship..its almost destroyed my marriage...i went for a few sessions of counciling..which really didnt' help. In the end..i began to relaly keep separate finance with him. We always had separate but i would always fork more out... now i make sure we pay half and half on the bills...i took back all the cash i bailed him out before we married. And when it comes to any bills with his kids i leave it up to him...extras..he pays but he pays bit by bit to budget himself. Ex wife complains..but too bad. That is our budget..she's lucky she's evne getting any extra for the kids...becasue he is tight and i'm not a bank account. I felt so resentful for a while. To save myself and my marriage i spoke with him..and reminded him that before we got married that expenses...such as gas especially was his responsibility for his kids...( the cost is ALOT to pick them up...its a 3 hour drive...soo...hefty onthe gas) i stopped paying the gas ..that is his responsibility.. The only thing i still pay is xmas gifts....which i've cut down onthose as well...but one thing hit me this year...he bought nothing for his daughter...and i mena nothing....i paid for all her gifts..which next year this will have to change.. There are times i just feel like a mother...and not a wife..nto a partner.. Especially when it comes to birthdays..or xmas... i know why he is holding back on that...i understand. He feels used. Unappreciated. He gives , he gives, extra...and then they drop him on his weekends...they say its boring..etc...they skip out on father day gifts on year.. Last year they made up for it. But youknow..after a while...the scars are left and you just cannot forget..so as much as he loves his kids. He also resents them.The key is to not let it control you. Tell you husband...he wants to give extra?? not your money...tell him to go work more and give if he wants to do that. I make sure the bills in our household, food, rent is taken out first...anything else he will have to manage what is left... Its sad but that is reality. You must talk with your husband. Spell it out onpaper..ihave a book where i write all the bills coming in and how we split it inour household. He must pay his share....your not a bank account.Sure you support your husband....but not his exwife! NO WAY!... I made sure my finances would be separate...so no money goes to his ex or actually his kids. Unless i want it to. By my own accord..not be forced. This is why you feel resentful. Because he is taking your portion to cover his butt from ex and his kids. No way...i would never allow that. Dont care if the kids hate me.....woldnt' want anyone around me who hated me anyways...so no loss there....lol I'm lucky that my sk dont hate me..but i do wish were closer..but thanks for mom..that will never happen....See Morestepdaughter resents me
Comments (10)Welcome to MY life.... "i have a 9 year old stepdaughter who is very disrespectful to me. over the past 4 months she has said horrible lies about me" My SD is also 9. Over the last year, she's told lies about me. The worse lie is that I hit her. Her mom gives her lots of attention to these lies. She continues to do it, because she gets attention. Her mom called CPS & since the CPS worker talked to her, she's had a completely different attitude. She even told me she isn't going to lie anymore because she's tired of getting in trouble. It's very frustrating to have someone saying horrible things about you and worse when they want you to be nice to them. My SD lives with me full time and tells her mom these lies on her weekend visits and comes back expecting me to kiss her boo boo's and do things for her. It's getting better right now, but it's an ongoing battle. "she has said mean things about me to my friends, and she will not listen to me when i tell her to do something. its seems that she gets worse everytime she comes over (which is every other weekend). i have done everything i can think of ranging from.... spending alone time with her shopping, taking her to the fair, letting her help me cook, letting her dress our 6 month old baby." If I were you, I would not do anything for her when she acts that way. When she is being nice, then do something nice for her. If she is being nasty, tell her to ask her dad. "i know that she is jealous and i understand that. i really feel that she resents me for marrying her father even though she says she doesnt. one minute she says she loves me and wishes that i was her real mother, and the next minute she is sarcastic and hateful to me on the drop of a dime! when i ask her why she does this she says she doesnt know. my husband and i have sat her down and told her that we love her and just because we have a baby wont change that." She probably is jealous. She's got a new stepmom, losing dad's attention. She's got a new baby to compete for dads attention now too. Baby is six months old, this has been going on for four months. Perhaps she was okay with the baby but now she's realizing the baby is taking dad's attention. Maybe her mom (or someone else) has said something about dad spending time on the baby. She probably does want to get along but has conflicting feelings. She may also be trying to manipulate and getting upset if it doesn't work. My SD will be lovey dovey with me and I tell her to do something or give her an answer she doesn't want, and boom, right back to not liking me. They might get upset with their parents but forgive & forget.. but a SM is not the parent and she tends to remember every incident where I do something she doesn't like. "she says sarcastic comments to me so that my husband wont hear and then when i tell him what she said it doesnt seem to bother him very much. he thinks that because she is only 9 it isnt a huge deal. he yells at her when she treats me like this but i dont feel that he has properly handled the situation. i love her and wish we had a good relashonship! i dont know what else to do, i treat her very good and am tired of her treating me like this! she is driving a wedge between my husband and i that my husband doesnt seem to even notice. my husband and i fight all of the time about this and it gets us no where. i feel that he isnt sticking up for me like he should be." This is the most worrisome part of you post. You and your husband should be a team. Not just for your baby but both kids. He is not doing his daughter any favors by siding with her. He is also not being consistent by yelling at her and then being upset with you. I'm sure he feels stuck in the middle and the guilt makes him want to please his daughter and he yells at the daughter because her behavior upsets you and he wants all his girls to be happy. I really think it's wrong to say the daughter is driving a wedge between you and him. HE is responsible for the wedge if there's one. The daughter is a child that has been through a divorce, dad's remarriage, and now a new baby... none of which she asked for most likely. Dad needs to do more than tell her nothing is going to change how he feels about her. He needs to show her how important she is to him. My SD asked my DH to give her a nickname... like 'princess' or 'pumpkin', or some other endearment that is special to her. Your DH needs to take some time on his weekends to spend one on one time with her, even if it's washing the car or raking leaves. But, he does need to be a team with you and be the parent, not a referee. "i dont want our daughter growing up around that kind of influance. she has destroyed every relashonship that her mother has been in and i sometimes think she wants me out of the picture thinking that her parents will get back together. (even though my husband told her that will never happen)she acts like a helpless little baby to her "daddy" and acts like a resentful, selfish 9 yr old brat to me. short of telling my husband i dont want her around me for a while i am at a loss." Your hostility is understandable. You have a new baby and she's acting out. But, that's even more reason to back off and let her be alone more with her dad. Of course she may not want you there, she just might think she can get her parents back together. You are the obstacle to that ever happening and now, so is your baby. Again, she's a kid and if she has successfully ended her mom's relationships, she may think she's capable of controlling what the grown ups do because it's worked in the past. She gets daddy mad at you. She gets mommy's BF's to leave. The best thing you can do for your own sanity is to disengage and ignore her behavior. Personally, if she's only there every other weekend, I'd spend as much time away from her... go shopping or take the baby for a walk. Leave her to her dad for the next few weekends and give yourself a break from her. Maybe if she sees you aren't reacting or you don't care what she's doing, she will calm down. (she may also try different strategies.. my SD does that) But, it's only every other weekend. In the meantime, I'd also suggest parenting classes and talking to a therapist/counselor. I wouldn't drag her to the counselor just yet, maybe you and your husband could go and learn how to work as a team first. You could also discuss the issues with SD and get suggestions from the counselor on how to deal. Then, if it continues, you might take her and see if it helps....See MoreUser
7 years agoUser
7 years agoUser
7 years agolast modified: 7 years agoUser
7 years agolast modified: 7 years agoUser
7 years agoEmbothrium
7 years agolast modified: 7 years agoUser
7 years agoamylou321
7 years agolast modified: 7 years agoUser
7 years agoSuzieque
7 years agoUser
7 years agoUser
7 years agolast modified: 7 years agoUser
7 years agoDaisyinGA
7 years agoUser
7 years agoUser
7 years agoingeorgia
7 years agolast modified: 7 years agoUser
7 years agosushipup1
7 years agosylviatexas1
7 years agoBeverly Hills
7 years ago
Related Stories
LIFEA Therapist’s Guide to Dealing With Conflict at Home
Piles of laundry and dirty dishes are a part of cohabitating. Here’s how to accept it and move forward
Full StoryREMODELING GUIDES5 Ways DIY Remodels Get Derailed — and How to Deal
Keep your remodel on track by knowing the potential pitfalls ahead of time
Full StoryLIFEGet the Family to Pitch In: A Mom’s Advice on Chores
Foster teamwork and a sense of ownership about housekeeping to lighten your load and even boost togetherness
Full StoryREMODELING GUIDESContractor Tips: Advice for Laundry Room Design
Thinking ahead when installing or moving a washer and dryer can prevent frustration and damage down the road
Full StoryDECORATING GUIDES10 Design Tips Learned From the Worst Advice Ever
If these Houzzers’ tales don’t bolster the courage of your design convictions, nothing will
Full StoryHEALTHY HOMEHow to Childproof Your Home: Expert Advice
Safety strategies, Part 1: Get the lowdown from the pros on which areas of the home need locks, lids, gates and more
Full StoryDISASTER PREP & RECOVERY7 Initial Steps for Dealing With Floodwater Damage
How you handle your flooded home and its contents can affect not only the damage level but also your personal safety
Full StoryLIFEThe Polite House: How to Deal With Noisy Neighbors
Before you fly off the handle, stop and think about the situation, and follow these steps to live in harmony
Full StoryMOST POPULAR12 Key Decorating Tips to Make Any Room Better
Get a great result even without an experienced touch by following these basic design guidelines
Full StoryLIFE10 Ways to Work Through Grief Triggers During the Holidays
A year after losing her sister, she was facing another holiday. Here’s how one woman learned to find joy again
Full StorySponsored
rlcollins043