I did an image search for "small craftsman white trim" and here are some options. It depends on what you like. Yours is a craftsman style and can handle a stronger color with white trim.

Thanks so much, I do like that sage color!

I agree that sage is very pretty!

Yep, sage is the one.

The color in the last (sage) pic is similar to my house, which is Ben Moore Tree Moss. This isn't my house, but it's Tree Moss.

I'll be the dissenter. I like all the other colors better than the sage, esp. in a setting with a lot of foliage, such as your cottage. The blue with orange door is adorable. I love all white, but think it might work better with strong detail.

The photos of the examples all show the gables & walls the same color, a very pretty arrangement.

It adds power or weight to the main color, & makes the trim more "trim".

Lily'smom's idea of Nantucket Gray with a cranberry door sounds exquisite!

I noticed the same thing Sylvia did; the house examples posted all have the total body painted one color. Your house currently seems to have more trim than it does house. I think the grays and greens posted would look great on your house if the V-shaped area under the roofline (not the facia board) is painted the same as the body. You could still keep the trim white. Please come back and show us the completed project.

I am painting our little house right now. I let my son and mom pick but they liked what I liked and I was lazy and just used a behr example but the silvery gray green looks like shade, something we like, the eaves are white and the wide trim around the doors and Windows are a deep green. I am thinking of a yellow tan for the door but not sure yet

I agree with the posters who suggest painting the gables the main house color instead of the trim color. I love all the examples Lisa posted and don't think you could go wrong with any of them.

Thank you all so much, I appreciate all the comments. The roof is a tan color and the sage colors would blend well. I'll post pics afterwards but it may be a little while, have some serious rehabbing to get done!

Thanks again!