I'm a SW Creamy fan. I sampled the usual suspects. BM Creamy White, Linen White, Mayonnaise, Mascarpone, etc.

What is your trim color, no soccer? In my room Creamy is very bright (LRV 87) and almost as white as the Extra White trim. I expected a little more contrast.

Not sure this is helpful but we have SW white dover trim and used SW Honied White walls in our family room and kitchen. I found Honied White in one of the Elle Decor pubs that had decorators share their "go-to paint colors" - the decorator described Honied White as "white with a bit of sunshine" - so it might help warm up the room a bit. I don't have any expertise but did want warmish white walls that would contrast with a brighter white trim and this combo definitely got me there so I was happy - hth!

Sorry, I've been gone all day.

Definitely go with a warm white if you want a white.

I do love BM Capitol White and think it looks great in both bright and low light.

Here is your SW Extra White next to 1) Capitol White; 2) SW Creamy

Thx for replying, Tib. I spent our dinner time on my IPad reading some Maria Killam blogs on white walls; almost decided to slit my throat instead of my pork roast. Don't ever try to paint a low light room white, it will look gray. If you use cream it will look apartment beige. If you still want to try, it must be pure white, blah, blah, blah.

Thanks for posting the pictures for me. As always the monitor is so incorrect. The SW Creamy looks peachy beige while the samples on my wall are almost as white as the Extra White trim. SW calls Creamy a cool color, btw. I don't understand the whole cool/warm thing. I'm going to try Capitol White for sure, respecting your opinion as I do. Plus I love all things Colonial Williamsburg including the CW colors, so feel I must. I'll let you know how it goes. Am I foolish to even be considering white or off-white?

That is why, if you want to do white walls in a low-light room, you have to go with a very warm white, i.e.: a yellow base white.

My kitchen is not only very low light, but it has a cathedral ceiling with no lights in it. Only lighting in the kitchen is the chandelier and the pendant light over the sink. The Capitol White is so perfect and looks great in all of the varying lighting in there. At it's brightest natural light, it looks creamy and luscious, but it has enough yellow in it to carry the low light and artificial light wonderfully. I'm pretty sold on this color because of its versatility that way. I've never tried SW Creamy but have read a lot of positive comments here about it. It does look peachy on the monitor, but whites are so deceiving and so hard to pick! Got to first look for the underlying tone. Is it blue (cool)? yellow (warm)? green, like white Dove (right between warm and cool)? Pink? It's maddening.

I have Creamy in a west/north facing room, though with lots of windows. It is creamy (yellow based), not cool or dingy or gray IMO. Nor does it look peachy in my room.

Now as far as trim, I think it's matched to BM White Dove.

I have to try SW Capitol White because I trust Tibbrix with colors.

The moral seems to be that you really need to try a paint color in your room.