Souvenir de la Malmaison sport?
Anne Zone 7a Northern CA
7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (9)
Related Discussions
Souvenir de la Malmaison
Comments (9)I lived in Seattle for decades, then moved to California near San Francisco where the climate is also too cool for the blooms of 'S.D.L.M.' to open. I gave it to someone who lives in a warmer climate. If you would like a Bourbon rose that does perform well in Seattle I suggest that you post a question on the Antique rose forum for Seattlesuze and ask her if she knows of any Bourbons do well where you live. A fragrant pink Old Rose that did perform well in our Seattle garden, is 'Mlle. Cecille Brunner' It is sometimes nicknamed Cecil Brunner, but was named for a 12 year old French girl. Its' dainty pink Tea-rose shaped blossoms have a sweet Old Rose scent with a hint of spice, and the handsome bush has pretty dark green foliage. You can see photos of it on helpmefind.com. The original form is a small bush at c. 4 and 1/2 feet tall to 5' tall, and has few prickles making it a good rosebush to plant near a pathway. The Spray and climbing forms of 'Cecille Brunner' grow to be much larger plants. vintagegardens.com often sells it, as does hortico.com under "Polyantha". Luxrosa...See MoreDo I need Souvenir de la Malmaison?
Comments (74)Nova, If I had to choose between the two then Souvenir de la Malmaison wins hands down. Marchesa Boccella is a very pretty and worthwhile rose but it lacks of the WOW factor that SdlM has in spades. Flower: MB's blooms are a about 2.5-3 inches wide with a knotted button eye in the center. The outer petals form a scalloped edge. Bud color is deep rich pink that progressively lightens to an uniform light cool pink. SdlM flowers are bigger and the quartering is more "tight". The form is absolutely perfect on each and every flower. The outer petals form a circular disc with the inner petals pulled into segments, culminating into a pinpoint center. Only a few OGRs can match SdlM for consistency and perfection of form. Color is a pale icy pink that verges on white. The image included in my last post is very accurate in terms of form, color and petal texture. Fragrance: very different. MB has a strong Damask scent; i.e. "classic" rose fragrance. Unfortunately, it is very much a one note fragrance. SdlM, on the other hand, has ravishing blooms blessed with a gloriously complex fragrance. Now to be honest, some folks can't smell it. I can and to me it is pure whiff of heaven. Growth Habit: Both are short to medium in height but MB is more rigidly upright. I prefer the slightly wider habit of SdlM. Disease Resistance: Good for both. I found SdlM to be slightly more resistant but to be honest I didn't keep MB around long enough to do a fair comparison. Repeat: Good for both. SdlM is slightly faster to repeat. Vigor: MB is better. An own root specimen is likely to mature the second year. SdlM makes you wait a year or two longer because she blooms at the detriment of putting on shrub growth....See MoreCL. Souvenir de la Malmaison
Comments (7)Jaxondel, thanks. I will be ready to cover those lower leaves. Labrea, do you grow it as a bush rose? Robert, do you have gophers and voles? I guess you are almost a pro, you would notice if the roots were gone. That is really odd for a rose to do. I purchased 3 SDLM at a nursery this year for an idea I have for the back. All of a sudden this one rose has a set of canes that are really really long. I called the nursery thinking that someone made a mistake, and of course he said he would replace it. He said that it was not likely that the climber would be mixed with it because it is grown in a different greenhouse. He said I may have a sport, or just a long rose. Regardless of what it is, he wants to replace it. I will not ask that of him since it is healthy. He said that they put 2-3 little plants together, so that when they grow and bloom they will look large sooner. (I have noticed that.)Either one of the three is a climber, or it is a sport. The rose has some normal length canes, and I cannot tell yet if it is a separte rose or not. I could just let it grow as a large rose, change the shape of the bed, and put another SDLM in the bed. I wonder what it would look like as a bush. Sammy...See MoreSouvenir de la Malmaison, this is true love
Comments (21)Ratdogheads -- If 'Kronprinzessin Viktoria' survives the winter in your garden, then yes, you must add other members of the SdlM clan. There are many gardeners who will forever be grateful that Mike Lowe was the audacious, daring, committed and driven character that he was. Who but Mike Lowe would -- even momentarily -- have entertained the notion of attempting to do what he did with roses in NEW HAMPSHIRE? In Thomas Christopher's "In Search of Lost Roses" there's a chapter on Mike and his NH garden. In the final paragraphs, Mike comments that, due to the severity of the previous winter, he had lost his entire crop of young Hybrid Perpetual plants. He goes on to say: "Want Bourbons? I got extras. Boy, have I got Bourbons this year." So, take heart from Mike's experience and try more Bourbons in your garden. You just never know . . . There are two Bourbons in my garden that always evoke memories of Mike Lowe -- CDdG and 'Marquise de Balbiano'. Both are now in this country due to his efforts. He once remarked that 'Marquise de Balbiano' would be the finest of pillar roses if only it were hardy. I'm thankful that it IS hardy in my zone, and I have Mike to thank for the fact it's in my garden. Here is a link that might be useful: The Lowe's Archive @ HMF...See MoreAnne Zone 7a Northern CA
7 years agoAnne Zone 7a Northern CA
7 years agoAnne Zone 7a Northern CA
7 years ago
Related Stories
GARDENING GUIDESWhat Kind of Roses Should You Grow?
Want to add the beauty of roses to your garden? Find out which ones, from old-fashioned to modern, are right for you
Full StoryLIFEStop the Toy Takeover by Changing the Way You Think
Make over your approach and get gift givers onboard with your decluttering efforts by providing meaningful toy alternatives
Full StoryHOMES AROUND THE WORLDWorld of Design: 11 Book Lovers and Where They Like to Read
Bibliophiles across the globe reveal their top books and favorite reading spots, from a 2-story library to an artfully curated book nook
Full StorySponsored
Lisa Adams