Help choosing roof shingle color!!!

7 years ago

last modified: 7 years ago

Here is a photo of our 70's ranch bungalow that is needing a new roof soon....please help in giving suggestions what color of roof shingles we need. We live in zone 5 in Iowa so most of the year its cool and cold here. Thanks!

Featured Answer

PRO

Brennan Enterprises

7 years ago

There are a million options to choose from, so how do you pick the right one?! Determine what is important to you when it comes to roofing. Do you want something that is long-lasting with an old charm feel, or are you looking for something a little more modern? There arepros and cons to all types of roofing, but with a little help, you'll definitely find the right solution for your home!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (14)

practigal
7 years ago
Do you like what you have currently? Or are you planning on another look?
User thanked practigal
User
Original Author
7 years ago
I do like the color that is on here now, but wonder would another color look better? Trying to find the best look for this house! Needing ideas! Thanks!
Related Discussions
Need help choosing a shingle color for our home.
Q
Comments (3)
It is pretty hard to tell without a closer pic of the brick, but I would stick with a medium grayish color. Trying to match some of the browns and tans is a bad idea, and going too dark will make the roof stick out too much. Personally, I like the weathered wood. I would stay away from the black walnut.
...See More
Help! Need help choosing new roof color!
Q
Comments (27)
I would also spray paint the star a rusty red so it will show more. It really doesn't stand out on the brick in it's current color which looks more copper in the picture. (the copper is pretty but you need red there) I would also consider opening the bed up in front of the stairs to add flowers as well. The house is beautiful, but the landscape is what's lacking. I would actually post a thread in the landscape forum to get some ideas of how you can build the landscape up a little. Put a plan together and just do a little bit every season..
...See More
Help Choosing Shingle Color & Ideas to Add Curb Appeal to Our House?
Q
Comments (4)
Hmmm...neither of those shingle colors look right to me. It could just be my screen, but the top one looks like it could have a little blue undertone, and the bottom one looks a bit red. Is the brick mortar more gray...or more gray than it looks on my screen? If so, I'd stick with gray for the roof as long as it has no blue. Gray roofs with brick are usually nice. Agree there's not much room for properly sized shutters. You could beef up the window trim instead. BTW, the roof color in your third photo looks good. Maybe stick with something close to that.
...See More
Hello! I need help choosing a roof color and siding color.
Q
Comments (1)
I'd confirm available colors in each brand before making a decision - we were going to go with Mission Brown, which per the website is available in our area, but due to Covid, they had reduced their colors down to a handful. This was 4-5 months ago so things have maybe changed. Good to know before you get your hopes up as we did. We ended up with Weathered Wood and we like it a lot as well. Before: After Good luck!
...See More
practigal
7 years ago
I like it to. I would go to one of the big paint companies' website and download their color program-you provide the photo and then pick the various colors. If you see one that you like better, you may want to change it. But with the color that you have here you can go with a lot of other colors if you get bored with the white-tan colors.
User thanked practigal
User
Original Author
7 years ago
I did that and there is so many choices! Made it even harder to decide! House being so neutral color about all of them worked!! wish there was an easier way!
User
Original Author
7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago
We are leaning toward this color...called Burnt Sienna......is this a good choice? This is downloaded from the site.....

Here are both tell us which you like best....be honest....Thanks!!!! Looks like the black might bring it out of the 70's look!?
Olychick
7 years ago
I like the dark because it seems to go with your shutter color, but I'd consider going maybe even one shade lighter. Will you always have your house painted white? The Burnt Sienna will really limit your paint color options, while the more neutral color opens them up. Since this is over 10 days since you posted, if you haven't yet picked, you could post your question on the home decorating forum and ask for advice there. Some good with color folks hang out there.

Home decorating forum
User thanked Olychick
Vith
7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago
Not a fan of the black, roof would get pretty hot with that also. What you have currently looks like the correct color, it is just worn a bit. The color will pop more with new.

FYI, steel roofs are the new thing. Last a lot longer (more durable against hail and wind damage), weigh a lot less (can be installed over existing shingles), absorb a lot less heat, dont shed gunk into your gutters and yard, and are recyclable. They make steel roofs that are installed in a shingle style, and they also have stone coated steel roofs that look just like normal shingles.
User thanked Vith
User
Original Author
7 years ago
Thanks Olychick! I posted on that site now! Thanks you!!!
User
Original Author
7 years ago
We finally picked the shingle color....Tru Definition Duration Owens Corning....called Brownwood.....now hope we made the right decision? will post picture when finished....Thanks everyone for the help!
User
Original Author
7 years ago
Here is
after the new shingles.....the colors aren't really showing up like in
real life.....and the photo doesnt show the architectural aspects of it
either? we do love how it turned out....photo doesnt do it justice at
all.....Now, what can we do to make it look even better? I have black
metal garage hardware to install yet, after I get the door painted
first.....any ideas what I need to tweak? Thanks!!
Linda Doherty
7 years ago
I'd put dark shutters on house and a dark garage door.
PRO
Novel Remodeling
7 years ago
Dees

Color and whats nice is just a perception of humans. I can find a single color more attractive for no apparent reason. Its not about the color of a roof, but functionality, stability and durability.

However, if I were to share my experience regarding your roof, I would recommend a darker color and to repaint the exterior of the house to match.

A darker color with a lighter shade to the exterior will add depth and design. Can simply make it stand out in your neighborhood of bland colors.

We like to make homeowners stand out and be different! No cookie cutters here!
millworkman
7 years ago
"Here is after the new shingles"

Think she already has a new roof judging by her quote..........................................