'Doctor will not give you test results over the phone.'

12 years ago

I had an MRI on my shoulder last week to see if I'd torn a muscle. Before the MRI, the doctor (orthopedist) also ordered physical therapy. My PT appointment is today. When I called the orthopedics office to get the MRI results, I was told I had to wait until August 10 to get the results in the office. "Doctor will not give you test results over the phone."

I asked how the PT people are supposed to come up with an exercise plan if they don't know what's wrong with my shoulder. She said, "All I can tell you is that the doctor and his staff are in surgery and won't be available until Tuesday." (All of them are in surgery?)

So I called PT and asked them to obtain my MRI results before my appointment. I'll keep the appointment, but don't want to embark on an exercise program unless there's a diagnosis.

Whose shoulder is it, anyway? I must have spent 15 minutes at the orthopedics office last week, electronically signing privacy statements. I'm wondering whose privacy they're protecting.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (20)

monica_pa Grieves
12 years ago
Whenever I get a scan (MRI or CT), I ask up front for a copy to take home(Drs tell me to do this because many testing centers take days to send them). Have yet to be denied, and I copy them for my own records before giving the disc to Dr.
maire_cate
12 years ago
Excellent point! When I went for PT my physiatrist wrote on the prescription exactly what exercises she wanted done at the therapy center. Granted she was a rehabilitation specialist but still she specified what was to be done. Conceivably you could aggravate the problem if PT isn't aware of the diagnosis.
Related Discussions
Can you help me interpret the soil test results
Q
Comments (19)
That is a lot of stuff to be adding every month. But, why would the older roses be fine when the newer ones aren't? My guess is the newly growing roots on the newly planted roses are simply being burned, while the established roses have big enough root systems to handle it. Milorganite is pretty strong stuff. Cow manure can be too, it's often enough by itself. Why the bagged soil? Alfalfa is fairly high in nitrogen too. I fertilize my roses with either alfalfa or manure, but not both at once. I have very sandy soil too, although colder than yours, so everything moves slower. You're not adding all that to the planting holes, are you? you say you're applying as a top dressing. Because that would partly explain the difference between the older and newer roses. So, now, can you tell us what exactly 'fail to thrive' entails? Wilting? burning? just not growing? leaves turning yellow? older leaves, or newer, or all? leaves distorted? If you're in very sandy soil you won't drown the roses. And from what I've heard of Florida soils you could retest it later this spring to see if it's still too strong. I wonder if you have nematodes, or some other bug like FL has so many of, like chili thrips. There are a lot of Florida rosarians on the roses forum, you might want to post your symptoms there, with timeline, and with photos if you have any.
...See More
How normal are my 'normal' thyroid test results?
Q
Comments (9)
Tony, Metformin is a diabetes drug, used to control high blood sugar. But even if you found a drug for hypoglycemia (I'm sure they're out there!), most of the time the condition can be managed with diet. I've had hypoglycemia most of my life ("the" Dr. Atkins, who was my physician in NYC a long time ago, called my glucose tolerance test "a real clunker"). Two critical steps: First, give up sugar. Second, eat frequent small meals throughout the day, including protein whenever possible. Protein doesn't raise your blood sugar quickly, but it keeps it steady. Alisande, I haven't been following your story. Are you seeing an endocrinologist, or are you having the tests done by your regular doctor? I've been having trouble breathing for a year and a half, and none of the tests my doctor (an internist) ordered showed anything. I know low thyroid can do this, and in fact, it feels like the description of thyroid-related breathing problems that I've read: It feels like the muscles involved in breathing have become weak. I mentioned it to my doctor, along with the information that my mouth is sometimes dry, and he ordered the blood tests. My thyroid is at risk for problems because of the radiation I had when I was six years old (to remove my adenoids). I've been wondering how your joints are. Still painful? Forgive me if I've missed some posts! Coral, I feel like I'm falling apart! (However, I remind myself that I've said the same thing at other times in my life, beginning when I was 43--which was 23 years ago.) The knee pain came back on Tuesday, not nearly as bad, but bad enough to make me get out the ibuprofen again. It was preceded by the weird taste (like plastic) in my mouth that preceded the attack of joint pain just before Christmas. I don't know what to make of it, but I know my stomach isn't right, and hasn't been for some time. I saw a gastroenterologist (sp?) about a year ago. He was very nice and down to earth, but he kept telling me I looked good--so much better than most of his patients look. That's great, but it didn't help my symptoms. The stomach symptoms have gotten worse, as has the breathing problem. But as we all know, anxiety can produce breathing problems, or make an existing problem worse. So maybe that's a factor. I really don't know. Honestly, at this point feel like so many things are "off" that I'm reluctant to see any doctor because I know I'd sound like a hypochondriac for sure.
...See More
Food allergy test results - now what?
Q
Comments (28)
You can get Benedryl that is dye-free, but it is hard to find. You will be amazed at how many things have Red 40, like bar-b-que sauce, yogurt, many medicines. One brand of cake mix has it on the label for both yellow and chocolate cake. Then of course, all the red and pink things like jello, candy, some jelly, canned cherries, cherry pie filling, many toppings, ice cream, mixes with artificial berries. It's everywhere. A small percentage of people can taste red dye and it gives food a bitter taste to them. I am one of those people, so I have never been big on eating "red" things that other people think taste great. That is probably why I am not dead. I remember getting sick as a child on a desert that had red jello in it, and once ended up in the emergency room after taking a common (pink) med. In those days, I think I had to get a lot of it before I had a real problem. I always had problems after I would fly because I always took a pink motion sickness pill. I didn't know that everyone else didn't have gas, bloating, and diarrhea after flying. LOL Since I tend to get dizzy easily I had taken a lot of pink motion sickness meds before I discovered Meclizine. Also check any kind of vitamins you may take. Beware of anything red, pink or orange. I do really well most of the time, but occasionally when eating out I will get something without knowing it. If I get very much, I will have severe cramping within minutes. I practically live in the bathroom for the next two hours because my system will just try to "flush" it out. In addition, I have pains in my heart. During a very serious attack I will just be freezing and can't get warm. I sit in a hot tub of water, and keep running it hot until I finally warm up. I shake like I am having a siezure. Do you do any of these things? When it started to get so bad about 10 or 12 years ago, I thought I had some serious stomach or bowel disorder. Then I would get better and be fine for a few days, so I would think well, maybe not. If it does turn out that it is red dye, we are not alone. More and more people each year and learning that it bothers them. I am not a drinker, but I read an article about a lady being taken to the emergency after having a drink with grenadine. I hope this is not what is wrong, but at least if it is, you can control it. You will have to give up a few things, and maybe prepare more things from scratch, but you will soon learn what to avoid. Good luck. Carol
...See More
Which filtration system for this water test results?
Q
Comments (2)
Peke, was it trihalomethanes in the water? THM? That's a pretty common problem, which is the result of chlorinated water combining with organic matter, such as what you get after big storms when sediment washes into the streams. A basic carbon filter is all you need. Even one of the simple ones that attaches to the tap will be fine, very easy to solve. See? Isn't it nice to have an *easy* problem to solve, for a change? :) Karin
...See More
debo_2006
12 years ago
Hummm, I just has an MRI on my elbow last Wed. and have yet to get a follow up call from my ortho doctor (not sure how long is should take). I know he want me to meet with another sports doc at the same office, which means paying the co-pay AGAIN for the same issue.

I know the Xrays found loose cartlidge around the elbow which could be the cause of it locking, and that's why they wanted an MRI....to see if there is more they can't see on the Xray.

I didn't know I could request an MRI copy for myself. I will certainly do that in the future along with a request for my own Xrays. After all, I'm paying for them...through insurance.
marie_ndcal
12 years ago
You might tell them you will be calling back Tue and expect to talk to the Dr or his nurse. I would not do any therapy until you talk to him. I get so annoyed when these so call specialist refuse to either return calls or make you wait until the next appointment. I just refuse and insist they give me the results. Yes, I do know they are busy BUT I have found out recently that many of them do not even look at the test results until 5 minutes before you see them.
quilly
12 years ago
Well he's not going to be in surgery all day. Call back and tell the receptionist that you need a return call today...tomorrow at the latest.

I honestly can't see why he can't give you the results for this test over the phone. The only excuse would be if he had bad news and wanted to tell you in person. I don't think I'd want to hear that I had a life threatening disease over the phone but an orthopedic problem isn't usually that dire.

When my DH is on call he gets ...and returns...phone calls even at night.
alisande
Original Author
12 years ago
This doctor looked about 17 years old....which has nothing to do with anything, I know, but he has to be just starting out. Either that, or he's had extensive plastic surgery. LOL

I have to leave now (in the middle of a t-storm) for my PT app't. I'm hoping the PT people will give me the MRI results. If not, I may proceed to my other errands, which include buying a certificate for a discount on the spay surgery our stray mama cat is getting on Wednesday. (The calico kitten went to her wonderful new home yesterday!)
susanjf_gw
12 years ago
don't forget it's july almost aug, and the doc's are on vacation, too...had my kidney dr cancel an appt, and know he forgot to tell the staff when he was leaving town...they do it all the time...the office staff get so frustrated...
Charlee_MO
12 years ago
I hope you find out the results soon. My friend just had an MRI on her knee. She has to go back for the results. I think it's for the $$. That's just MHO, though.

Good luck!
Vickey__MN
12 years ago
I wish this had been the case when I found out I had cancer. Imagine being at work and your doctor telling you that you had cancer...over the phone. Yes, I'd rather it'd been that way!

Vickey
schoolhouse_gw
12 years ago
My aunt goes online to the clinic's website to read her test results. I'm not sure how long it takes them to be posted.
jannie
12 years ago
Sometimes doctors send their testing out to be read by radiologists. Maybe the radiologist hasn't reported back yet and your doctor's staff is just following orders. I would cancel PT until after getting the results. Just a suggestion.
matti5
12 years ago
I have yearly MRI's (brain) and each time mine are first read by the radiologist who then sends his findings to the doctor. This can sometimes take up to a week depending on the back log.

I can't imagine PT allowing a new patient without a diagnosis. Not sure the insurance company would allow that either. Mine won't.

Let us know what happens!
joann23456
12 years ago
We're lucky here in that virtually all the doctors' offices are part of an online network that patients can access. You can get medical reports, request appointments or referrals, get prescription refills, or just email your doctor. It's great.

Before that, though, I always asked for a copy of the results to be mailed to me, though my primary care doctor does that routinely.
susan_on
12 years ago
We can go to any hospital that is part of our health system group to get a copy of any xray, scan, MRI etc. When I have my MRI's though, my neurosurgeon calls me at home with the results, and to discuss the case plan. I love that, because it saves me from taking a half day off work to drive there (over an hour away) to get the results. He usually calls at 9:00 at night.
lydia1959
12 years ago
My doctor won't normally give the results over the phone, but she has made an exception for me (and probably others) since I live an hour and fifteen minutes from her office.
3katz4me
12 years ago
Food for thought - doctors cannot bill you (or Medicare or your insurance company) for a phone call but they can bill for an office visit. I get all my test results either by phone or via online access to the EMR.
patti43
12 years ago
Good for you, Alisande. I'm anxiously waiting to hear what happened at therapy. Nice to see someone take control of their own health care/rights. I'm such a wimp!

Vickey, in your case that was just plain cruel. It was probably much easier than having a face-to-face with a patient who will naturally be more than upset.

But in cases where it isn't life threatening, they should let you know the quickest way possible--especially before you start a treatment when you don't know what you have. Geesh!
kathleenca
12 years ago
I wonder if it is because doctors do not get paid by insurance for a telephone call - only face-to-face office visits.
alisande
Original Author
12 years ago
Went to PT, filled out seven pages of stuff (boy, medical offices must be drowning in paperwork these days!), and saw a very nice young woman who evaluated my range of motion, etc.

She told me the results of my MRI: two inflamed tendons, swollen joint, inflamed muscle, some arthritis, and the possibility of muscle tearing (the MRI didn't rule it out). She said the treatment for this sort of injury is basically the same with or without an MRI. For that reason, most physicians take a wait-and-see attitude about the MRI, and hold off until it can be determined whether or not treatment is helping.

So it seems that my teenage doctor jumped the gun with the MRI. Isn't that nice? I know it doesn't carry the sort of risk that a CT scan would (at least I hope it doesn't), but I hate to have anything done unnecessarily. The cost to the insurance company, the waste of my time and gas, etc. Not to mention that lying still in an MRI tube listening to hammering is not my favorite way to spend any amount of time.

Twice-weekly treatment is underway. More time, more gas.....but at least this has the potential to do some good.

Thanks, everyone!
Charlee_MO
12 years ago
Glad you got your results. Here's hoping the PT will be all that is needed!

'Doctor will not give you test results over the phone.'

Comments (20)

monica_pa Grieves

maire_cate

Related Discussions

debo_2006

marie_ndcal

quilly

alisande
Original Author

susanjf_gw

Charlee_MO

Vickey__MN

schoolhouse_gw

jannie

matti5

joann23456

susan_on

lydia1959

3katz4me

patti43

kathleenca

alisande
Original Author

Charlee_MO

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

'Doctor will not give you test results over the phone.'

Comments (20)

Related Discussions

alisandeOriginal Author

alisandeOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

alisande
Original Author

alisande
Original Author