What would you do in this situation?

9 years ago

I live in a house that was just built about 2 years ago.

Up until recently, I would notice a small amount of what I thought was condensation on the window sills of north and west facing windows after heavy or windy rain. (Basically the sills were just damp enough to glisten, if that makes sense.)

A week or so ago we had a very windy thunderstorm roll through. After that I found standing water on the sills of 4 windows. The largest puddle was 14 inches long.....so obviously this is more than condensation. Apparently my new windows leak.

I have contacted the person who built my house. This is the same person who spec'ed the windows used. Hindsight being 20/20, I now wish I'd paid as much attention to the window details as I did on some other areas of the build. He used Ply Gem windows. (Yes, I can hear you all groaning now. )

He is allegedly contacting MW/Ply Gem, although his initial response was to basically tell me the leaking was normal behavior for a heavy windy thunderstorm.

So - does this sound like something that is actually "fix-able", or am I paying a heavy stupid tax for not researching quality windows before now?

If you were in my shoes, would you bite the bullet and get quality replacement windows now, or would you try to work with MW/Ply Gem first?

In case it isn't obvious, I'm not knowledgeable about windows and have no clue how to fix this or even where to start.

Featured Answer

millworkman

9 years ago

You know the answer about the quality of your windows. However 2 year old window should not leak water and this is definitely not "normal behavior for a heavy windy thunderstorm". My gut reaction since I am assuming since he was the builder that he installed the windows as well, would lead me to believe and of course cannot tell from here but it sounds more like an installation error/lack of proper flashing detail to me than a manufacturing issue, which if the window rep shows up he will confirm for you. Did he by chance tell you what made him feel that it was the window that was leaking as opposed to installation?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (13)

User
Original Author
9 years ago
Since he hasn't visited the house to check this out, I'm not sure if there is anything I can say that would let him know if it is a window failure (if failure is the right word), or an installation problem.

I got the sense he wanted to hear back from the window rep before he did anything else.

On one hand, it's probably reasonable to give him (or the window company) time to respond to this, but on the other hand I'm not at all thrilled with knowing my windows leak when there is a heavy rain.

Given the fact that all of the west facing windows leaked during that heavy rain, does that seem to indicate an installation problem?

Stupid question - and if it is an installation problem, would replacement windows even fix the leaking? Or is this something that requires pulling the siding and essentially doing a new installation of the windows all over again?
Related Discussions
What would you do in this situation?
Q
Comments (17)
This happens SOOOO often. Truly, your interior designer should have been very aware of the possibility -- nay, probability that this would happen. In fact, it happens so frequently that he/she should have made specific provisions to prevent it, such as taking delivery of the slabs to a location under his/her control in the interim. My concern is that the wholesaler and fabricator have very little incentive to make this right. They've already got 50% of your money, and you have 0% of your product. So they're trying to convince you to pick another granite and 'go away'. Now I know you've fallen in love with a particular stone. That happens a lot. In fact, that seems to be the necessary precursor to the 'sold out from under you scenario.' But it's probably a good idea to see if there is something you like better. Why? Well, the ship, when it does come in, may not have any of this particular stone. Or if they do, there's NO guarantee it will be similar to the slabs you fell in love with. It might be -- but they're not offering any guarantees. My suggestion would be to look around again. You might find something very similar under a different name. Or, you might find something you like even better. (That also happens very often.) OR - and this is where things get interesting - you might find something at their yard that you like almost as much that is significantly more expensive. And this is what you agree to settle for, assuming they can't find what they agreed to provide for you. Then you'll see them start to hustle.
...See More
What would you do in this situation?
Q
Comments (27)
i'm back. been a long day of telephone calls and tears. she said she will not be taking them back. she's come to the realization that she can't help them because they really haven't helped themselves. one positive thing, someone from her church sent someone to talk to her - not sure if this was a lawyer or a from a child agency (i'm getting some mixed info). she actually said "i have to realize the little ones kids are not my responsibility". i thought that was a big step. (we know how she means that, so don't think by not making calls to social services or the like, is what she meant). both are in school, first and third grades. she has talked to teachers, one plays sports - so his coach, etc., and no one ever thought neglect for a minute. even though the parents might be smacked azzes, they have not neglected the boys in the true sense of neglect. and she would know neglect, if you knew her story as a child. so i thank you all for your thoughts. earlier when i spoke to her, she cried when i read many of the posts and said after a while "that's enough, that's enough, i know, i know", i've heard it from all of you, i heard it from XXXX visitor. when i said do you really believe in what you are saying and she promised she did. a relative is on his way to her, he has a business trip mid week and is making a little side trip to stay for a few days and see what he can do to aid them in finding housing. she made it clear that they will not be returning and he will be with her and whoever this person was that visited earlier, so that they hear it face to face and there's no confusion. this woman is wonderful, with a heart as pure as gold. it's not the first time she has extended that heart and probably won't be the last. it's her nature. this one was hard given the circumstances of her family and the promises made. i know her heart is breaking, but i can also hear a certain relaxed manner about her knowing she has made the right decision. thank you all again.
...See More
PBs please help - what would you do?
Q
Comments (7)
Thank you very much for the feedback. A liitle more info on the situation-I did not request any particular placement on the foam jets and did not request the Crystal ones at all. I'd seen numerous comments on this site about kids enjoying playing in jets on sun shelves so I asked the PB about putting something like that in for my grand daughter. PB sold me on the idea of the Crystal ones so she wouldn't have problems with hitting her toes on the normal type. It took some convincing me on his part since they were considerably more expensive. So, the placement and type were totally on the PB. I looked at the Crystal website the day before the dig began and saw the limitation on water death and contacted the PB to discuss it and was told he forgot about that limitation but would adjust the plans before they began. Apparently that did not happen since the final level of water on them was even more than shown on the first plan. I don't want to complain about PB though because they have done a fabulous job and seem very willing to fix this problem. I just want to make the best decision on how I want them to attempt to fix it. Tearing it out seems drastic but my understanding is they would have to do that even to change them to the normal type foam jets. Just one more request for advice please - if they do tear it out would you take the chance on using pebble tech and hoping it matches or would you use flagstone on the sun shelf so you don't have to worry about it matching?
...See More
What Would You Do in This Situation?
Q
Comments (7)
What would it take to be licensed again. My hubby's ex is a nurse and has "retired" several times. Currently she lives in Idaho and attended training for something she calls emergency comunity nurse. She will be called is there is a emergency that needs a nurse. Did not go into details but one of the things she might be called for is forest fire work to check the fighters. Last winter she gave flu shots. One of the other things she does for extra money is work as a private duty nurse. There are other things in that field that do not need the license such as providing information and training to others. Interesting that the other poster mentioned Walmart. Last week we were in one of the stores and the checker mentioned that she was 73 and going back to work was much better than staying at home. If you have already passed the regular SS retirement age any income you may would be gravy. I have not worked with a temporary agency for a long time so do not know how they treat there employees currently. If you did a good job no matter how trivial some assignments could last a long time. Much better than staying at home worrying about not having enough money to live on. Hubby goes to the Y with a group of mostly older women that are in better shape now than they were at 65. He received a reminder today that one of the mermaids will turn 90 next week and to bring a card or goodie to water arobics next week. So you see life does not end at 65 sometimes it only feels like it. Good luck and get out there.
...See More
PRO
Windows on Washington Ltd
9 years ago
Are all the windows leaking...?

MW/Plygem window? What model? Pocket sill?

Do you have dirt and debris? Where is leak show (interior drywall return)?
User
Original Author
9 years ago
Is every window in the house leaking? No. I have 6 windows that face west, and every one of those has had at least a damp sill (if not a standing puddle). I've also had a damp sill on one north facing window. The rest of the north facing windows (7) have never leaked, nor have any on the east or south side of the house.

The windows are all Ply Gem. It's a vinyl window, I can look up the model number tonight. I don't know what you mean by pocket sill. (Sorry. I have many skills, but obviously windows aren't one of them. :) )

No dirt or debris inside. The leak shows up on the window sills only, although I noticed this weekend that the hardwood directly underneath 2 of the windows has what may be some raised grain and cupping starting. I'm praying that's been there all along and isn't indicating the windows are leaking behind the wall.
User
Original Author
9 years ago
Hopefully this picture will upload.

I know the water is hard to see against the white trim, so the rocks mark the outer edges of the puddle.
User
Original Author
9 years ago
And here is a closer picture of another window that also had a standing puddle on the sill

This post was edited by patriceny on Wed, Aug 13, 14 at 15:55
PRO
Windows on Washington Ltd
9 years ago
And it is coming from the window where the sash shuts in and not from the window head (top part)?

Post a picture of the sill of the window (the part where the sash shuts down on).
User
Original Author
9 years ago
I'll be happy to take a picture of that area for you tonight and can post that tomorrow.

Unfortunately I don't know where the water is coming in. All those puddles formed before I got home, and by the time I got home the heavy rain was over. None of the sides of the windows were wet though, no drips or wetness on any of the glass or trim anywhere but the sills. The prior times I thought I was feeling "condensation", it was in the corner of the sills - the same place that shows up as a puddle in the above picture. So I *think* it is coming in from somewhere along the sill, but haven't personally observed it to know for sure.

I'll take more pictures for you tonight. I really do appreciate any advise or wisdom anyone can offer. Short of going back in time and buying better windows anyway. ha-ha.

The windows are apparently called "MW classic double-hung", if that helps at all?
PRO
Windows on Washington Ltd
9 years ago
That is a bit much for condensation at this time of year.

Post up the pictures and it is time to water test these buggers.
User
Original Author
9 years ago
I'll post a few pictures of what I think you want to see.

Hopefully it means more to you than it does me. :)
User
Original Author
9 years ago
Another view
PRO
Windows on Washington Ltd
9 years ago
Is the screen sliding or take out?

Lift it up and see if the screen weep track is blocked.

It appears that you are getting enough trapped moisture on that sill that the will sill is filling up enough to overflow where the dam leg hits the main frame on the jamb.
User
Original Author
9 years ago
The screen doesn't slide. It's a bear to get it out of there. I have to struggle to when I want to remove it - it's a full length screen and it's in there tight.

I think I understand what you are saying, and I also think it makes sense. The screen fits so tightly that any water getting between it and the window might not be getting back out.

Thank you!!!

What would you do in this situation?

millworkman

Comments (13)

User
Original Author

Related Discussions

Windows on Washington Ltd

User
Original Author

User
Original Author

User
Original Author

Windows on Washington Ltd

User
Original Author

Windows on Washington Ltd

User
Original Author

User
Original Author

Windows on Washington Ltd

User
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

What would you do in this situation?

millworkman

Comments (13)

UserOriginal Author

Related Discussions

Windows on Washington Ltd

UserOriginal Author

UserOriginal Author

UserOriginal Author

Windows on Washington Ltd

UserOriginal Author

Windows on Washington Ltd

UserOriginal Author

UserOriginal Author

Windows on Washington Ltd

UserOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

User
Original Author

User
Original Author

User
Original Author

User
Original Author

User
Original Author

User
Original Author

User
Original Author

User
Original Author