Definitely, the top one.

Not only do I find it the most sophisticated- but can imagine that it would feel the most comfortable and be the easiest to clean.
But each one has a different finish besides being a unique style- is there a particular finish that you prefer?

#1, but I must admit I have the same pull, but in bronze!

Sorry, I'm thinking satin nickel...what do you think?

Bump...

I think #1 is OK, but it's kind of modern industrial to me. It kinda reminds me of plumbing. No offense to those who have it! (Ever see a hand railing made out of pipes?)

I prefer #s 3 and 4 for a more traditional kitchen...and not knowing what your style is, I guess I can't say. I like 1 if you're modern or transitional, but if it's a more classic style, 3 or 4. I guess 2 is just kinda in between and boring. :)

I like #2.

The last pull, number 4 is what I like. It has a slightly more formal feel than the others. Also, it shouldn't show finger smudges as much as others. Is this the top knobs or which brand/part number? I've considered same/similar pull. Second runner up is the first pull.

# 1 but that's because i like modern...

#1 or #3 gets my vote. I think they are simple enough not to look busy if you need a lot of them and I also don't think you would get tired of them.

sixmagnolialane,
The pulls are from an e-bay store called "My home hardware" Pull #4 is $2.80 for a 5 3/4 size pull. I think this is the best price I've seen for this size and style pull. Actually, all of the other ones are similar in price.
Pull #2 reminds me of the "felicity" pull from restoration hardware. Of course the price is 3X more in RH.
My house is pretty much traditional. So, I do want a classic, traditional pull but not fussy or boring. Life is full of choices!...but it gets easier here in GW. :)

My favorite is #1 - I love that it's simple but there's still a bit of interesting detail.

It depends on what look you're going for. My votes:

#1 if you have modern or transitional kitcen
#4 if you want to go traditional
#2 if you want to go a bit rustic/traditional

I like #1. #4 looks like it would be uncomfortable to grasp.

#1, but like others have said, depends on the style you're going for.

Bumping...to get more votes

I pick #4.

Do you have pics of cabs - It depends on the application - so a pic would help

I think #4 is the most interesting. That is also one of my finalists but in black or a darker finish so I am a little biased. #2 is my least favorite, just don't care for the look of the finish.

i love #4 :)

#1 for me but I do lean toward cleaner lines and more contemporary.

#1 and #3. The other two are too busy for me in their detailing. I like simple, clean lines.

#4, it was one of my choices for my own cabinets.

I have #4 on the drawers of my traditional kitchen, but I could easily choose #1 or #3 for a more transitional/contemporary-look kitchen.

#1 or #3 get my vote. #2 would be hard to clean and #4 is not my style. It is a bit formal for me and looks a tad dated. just my opinion and I certainly do not mean to offend anyone.

my vote is #4. i don't know which look you are going for, but i think it is the most elegant/traditional.

Hi,
Thanks to all for your votes and advise. Here is a "small" picture of the cabinets. Everything else is being changed but the cabinets. Right now I have brass on the cabinets. Now, I'm thinking should I go with Oil rubbed bronze instead of satin nickel? What do you think? I'm thinking this because the backsplash tile will have some bronze accent tiles and the light fixture over my kitchen table will be dark bronze. I think the ORB hardware will contrast better with the cabinets...ahyayay!!!

I was going to say #1 in satin nickel until your above post. I still like #1 but I agree with you that the ORB finish would be better given the backsplash accent tiles. I'd give #3 my second favorite vote. I don't think you could go wrong, you have good taste with those choices.

#1. I'm considering it as well.

#1 if you're going modern and #2 for a more traditional classic look. The other two are boring. My personal choice would be #4. It's timeless and classic.