General Remodel Question - Layout (Contractor/Architect)

xtremeski2001

10 years ago

Hi,

Received some great advice on the landscaping forum and thought I'd take our remodel questions here. We have a few changes we'd like to make to our house, but haven't a clue if these are $150k changes or $20k, $10k, etc.

Background: We live in a great location, large wooded 1 acre lot, great schools, good neighbors, and we're the cheapest house on the block (~$425k in a neighborhood of $550k homes). Our home is two stories with a unfinished basement and approx 2,700sqft.

We don't want to waste our time (or theirs) so should we have a contractor come by or an architect to give us a ballpark of the cost of a few of these changes? The #3 change below is likely unreasonable, but if the price is right we'd do it.

1 - Open living room into dinning room. Would require putting a hole in the wall, relocating HVAC return, some reinforcement of wall as we believe wall is load bearing.

2 - Raise sunken eat in kitchen to be level with rest of kitchen. Kitchen is over basement and eat in kitchen is on slab. Would require raising two doors (one to deck (french door) and other to garage) to be level with raised floor. Room is 13x12.

3 - Relocate mud room/laundry from center of house (sits between family room and kitchen). Would require adding on to the house near the slab mentioned above. Added room would be ~11x6 and have doors into the garage and out to the deck.

Thoughts?

Featured Answer

kirkhall

10 years ago

Start with a GC or 2 for a ball park. For some of this stuff, you may be able to do with just their designer and engineer and not have to pay for an architect.

You could also start with the city/municipality you live in to see what they require. If they require an architect's plans, then you might as well start with the architect. But, if not, I'd start (and did start) with a GC.

Now, do you have your houses blueprints/design documents, or are they maybe on file with the city/county? Those can be very helpful for a GC in determining if a wall is load-bearing or not. If you don't have them, your ball park will be less "tight" (and maybe quite low).

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

PRO
Joseph Corlett, LLC
10 years ago
BBdude:

Don't be offended when a potential contractor "qualifies" you. I would ask you your plans and your budget. If you are realistic, I would continue to invest time in possibly earning your business. Your contractor is as worried about wasting time as you are.
Related Discussions
Hire a general contractor or sub-contractors?
Q
Comments (11)
I’ve acted as GC on my last few renovation projects, one which involved three bathroom gut remodels and a brand new kitchen with all new appliances and cabinets, new hardwood floors, doors, and moving walls. Subs I had: (1) paint/general construction/drywall, (2) plumber, (3) tile, (4) floor guy. I did the bulk of this in about a month and a half, with just little aesthetic touch ups later. I saved both money and time. Time, because I found that GCs will schedule one thing after another, not wanting people to work around each other, but because I was on a really tight timeframe that my son and I wouldn’t have a place to live, I scheduled a lot of folks to work at the same time around each other. They grumbled a bit more, but I was there every day to smooth things over, help, and just be a charming friendly person who brought cookies and snacks :). That said, to echo a lot of what folks said, it’s important to (1) be there on site every day to catch things early that are not aesthetically what you’d like, before it becomes more difficult to fix later, (2) have great people skills to motivate folks and work through issues, (3) have great organizational and project management skills (4) make decisions quickly and easily (being willing to do your own research) (5) be efficient about ordering supplies and materials on your own, which really saves time and money. And maybe most importantly (6) have the energy to deal with this all — it takes a lot of energy. I was exhausted. The reason I undertook it is that some GCs I talked to gave me a 4 month estimate on the work, and I just didn’t have that kind of time. All the sub folks were referred by my broker, so they were really responsive and professional and above par. I’ve continued to use them on other renovation projects, and they’ve always been really responsive and great. I may be lucky, because I’ve heard of nightmare stories as well, but it’s just to say that if you get good referrals, I‘ve found it’s not always the case that you can’t get subs to show up or have leverage compared to a GC. In fact, on a current project I have, all my same subs agreed to take on the work for me, right away, when my GC couldn’t get his subs for weeks out. I respectfully don’t agree with the comment that if you can’t tell about running an electrical line you can’t be a GC. If you trust your subs to be good at what they do, they’ll guide you through everything and help you make the best decisions. That’s what they’re there for. I‘ve done several remodels now, and haven’t had any issues later on (I lived in that particular house for 5 years). Anyway, I know it’s been 6 years since this post, but since I always get value from older comments and advice, I thought I’d still share my own experiences for others with this same question.
...See More
General questions about tile layout with a busy vein-y marble
Q
Comments (29)
Its standard here for marble flooring, we go to the warehouse to pickup a slab usually around 8'x5' or more then discuss the final tile cut size to minimise wastage before the installer drylay the marble in the factory to arrange the veining (also to place less desirable tile under furnitures etc). I'm in the process of laying 27"x51" size marble tile for my flooring, still deciding whether to have the veins move vertically into my room or horizontally across it.
...See More
Hiring a general contractor for bath remodel?
Q
Comments (9)
The easiest way to save money on a remodel is to learn to DIY the job or portions of the job. Almost anyone can paint. Tiling something basic isn't that difficult either. If you have friends or family that have done their own remodels (and they look OK!), ask them about swapping labor for something you do well as a hobby or for a profession. Bartering services or goods works with contractors as well. Maybe he doesn't have such a great website, and you're a web guru. Maybe his parents have a 50th wedding anniversary coming up, and you're a great caterer or cake baker or florist It never hurts to ask to see if something like that could be worked out. Or, GC it yourself by hiring the subcontractors directly. You will need electrical work, plumbing work, tile work, and drywall work, and some general demolition/labor in this remodel. Break down the job into those components and approach electricians, plumbers, tilers, etc. about doing those jobs directly. Above all, do not settle for someone doing a substandard job with materials that you do not like. This will probably not get done again, unless it's done wrong now. You've got to be sure that doesn't happen, and not trust any contractor to actually know what he's doing. Make sure that you educate yourself enough about the non pretty guts of the job that YOU know how things are going to be waterproofed, for instance. And don't pick materials just because they are cheap and you can afford them. Materials are the lowest expenditure on most jobs, and even a month or two more of saving before the job is tackled can allow you to use materials that you really LOVE. You CAN do a pretty bath on a budget with inexpensive materials, but you have to be more creative in how you use those materials and you have to be willing to do the footwork of searching for them.
...See More
What to look for in a general contractor
Q
Comments (10)
>> The most important thing for me was that our contractor (Jeff) was in daily contact with me letting me know who would be in next, or where we were at with things. He returned my calls promptly. He had everything lined up so that someone was at our house everyday working. >> We too just had an unusually good contractor experience, and these were the hallmarks: - Good communication: frequent and consistent email contact. - Much work done by direct employees, all of whom had blackberries, bluetooth headsets and email. - Office support: regular billing, scheduling, take deliveries, answer questions, convey urgent messages, central source of information, and a really good Web site! We never had our GC's cell number and never needed it. - Feedback requested: we were asked to fill out a mid-project survey! - Regular meetings. Some GCs blanched at the suggestion of weekly meetings, ours practically insisted on it. LOTS of problems prevented that way. - We asked GCs if they could get their bids in by a certain date, they all said yes, only two actually did, including ours. - Scheduling: our GC blows out a complete schedule, with dates for every trade to start, in writing. Never a down day in 9.5 months. - Resources: Every GC has to deal with trucks breaking down, injured workers, flaky subs, delayed materials. We never saw it and never heard excuses. (a previous GC's main guy got injured, delaying an entire upstairs remodel by weeks, and we had a baby coming!) - Can manage agencies: Our instructed all his workers never to B.S. during inspections, admit the problem and don't argue with the inspector. As a result, trust was built and we sailed through final city inspection despite a few minor code issues. - Punchlist-avoidant: they're inevitable, but he encouraged us to bring up the sticking-out-nail here, missing trim piece there, immediately. Goal was for no punchlist to build up. Meantime, a friend had a very difficult experience with a carpenter-turned-GC. Good carpenter, bad manager. Didn't know how to read plans, didn't interact well with the architect, ran out of money and refinished floors himself and made a huge mess, forcing our friends into a hotel for a few weeks, hired a painter who messed up the sheen levels and had to repaint the entire house, then the painter went broke. Without my friend's engineer husband on the job every day it'd have been a nightmare. Our awesome G.C. really cared about his reputation and told us in the first interview that his goal is for us to move in to a complete house and be thrilled. I think that sort of philosophy is what made our project work so well.
...See More
weedyacres
10 years ago
Both #1 and #2 sound like pretty straightforward carpentry projects. I can't see them going over 4 figures.

#3 depends on lots of variables, as it's got plumbing, exterior finishing, and tie-in to existing building, which could entail complexities like roof connections. That's the one to get some ballparks before deciding to proceed. And then work with an architect first to design exactly what you want.

Not that you shouldn't get bids on the first 2. I just think you can pretty safely proceed with those without your budget inquiries first.
xtremeski2001
Original Author
10 years ago
Thanks, all.

We received a quote for #1 for about $1,200. We lucked out as no HVAC/plumbing is in the way. This only covers the hole/framing, we're responsible for bringing the carpet through the new opening and painting.

While the GC was over he gave us his $.02 about 2&3. There would be a lot of relocating HVAC so we'd have to do split system to control heating/cooling upstairs versus down stairs. He ball parked the total cost of the upgrade at about $100k for everything, $50k of which would be for a whole new kitchen w/out appliances.

Considering we just moved in and have little equity (though we put down 20%), looks like this will have to go on the back burner as I don't know how else we could secure a loan with reasonable rates.
lavender_lass
10 years ago
If you can (or family can) do a quality DIY, then your kitchen upgrade would not be too expensive. Can existing cabinets and appliances be easily removed and reused? Do you 'need' a whole new kitchen...or just the floor raised?

Also, if you want to remove laundry from area between kitchen and family room...can you redesign kitchen space (during remodel) to accomodate the laundry and mudroom? Do you need an addition or can you reconfigure the existing space?
pangionedevelopers
10 years ago
Hello
I believe her question was to see if they should get estimates from architects or contractors.
Of coarse an architect can provide you an estimate but most of the time it is completely off in left field.
I can't tell you how many times we speak with homeowners and they show us their plans. The architect designs a $500k alteration when the homeowners budget is in the $300k range.

Contact some reputable contractors. Get as many bids as you feel are necessary but 3-5 should be suffice. Contractors like myself have in house architects and will include the plans as part of the package. You can also contact an architect. More times than not, his plans will cost more than it would if you went with the contractor.

You can read more on our blogs if you like:

Here is a link that might be useful: Bergen County Contractors

General Remodel Question - Layout (Contractor/Architect)

kirkhall

Comments (6)

Joseph Corlett, LLC

Related Discussions

weedyacres

xtremeski2001
Original Author

lavender_lass

pangionedevelopers

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

General Remodel Question - Layout (Contractor/Architect)

kirkhall

Comments (6)

Joseph Corlett, LLC

Related Discussions

weedyacres

xtremeski2001Original Author

lavender_lass

pangionedevelopers

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

xtremeski2001
Original Author