Underwriter asked for a letter and more comps. Nervous

15 years ago

My husband and I are trying to purchase a short sale property. The property is a two flat that is three blocks from our kids school. I am sick of driving all day so we tried. The whole thing started in Early September. On January 12 we were told by Countrywide that our offer was accepted. They then sent us the final final letter on Janurary 26th saying that we had to close by February 26. Before we had the final letter we told our mortgage broker that we wanted to go ahead and lock in and we paid $475 for the appraisal. We got the package signed back to the mortgage broker by the 26th of January. We waited for awhile for the appraisor and he appraised the house for 5 thousand above what we agreed to pay. This property is a two flat. I believe the mortgage broker gave the package to the underwriter on Friday Feb 6th. On Friday the 13th the underwritter told the mortgage broker we needed to write a more convincing letter that we were moving into the two flat (We are renting our home) and more comps from the appraisor. We were sceduled to close this Thursday the 19th but that is not happening. The appraisor has not gotten the comps. As of today the MB told our attorney that they will be in by end of the day today. Oh our letter was finished and emailed to the MB and he forwarded it Monday (a band holiday). I know this is a long story but was wondering how long it will take the underwritter. I guess she knows we are under a time contraint. Should I be mad that the appraisor has taken his time from the beginning? We did complain about the appraisor and were told we could get our own. Any thoughts would be great.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

dave_donhoff
15 years ago
My advice;
BREATHE!!!!

Countrywide wants your money... they'll extend their deadline for closing if that is required.

I don't know what the "explanation letter" is all about, unless you are "mving down" in size, neighborhood or quality, while keeping the old, better place. Is that the case?

All will likely workout fine if you can just relax a little & breathe. Nothing you can really do otherwise.

Luck
Dave Donhoff
Leverage Planner
sweet_tea
15 years ago
My guess is the explanation letter is needed in order to convince the lender that you are really going to live in the 2 flat and not buy as investment. My guess is the loan is not an investment loan (higher interest rate) and they want to be sure you will be living there since they are giving you the residential loan (lower interest rate).

They are probably having a hard time understanding this because they see you still own the SFH and think you will stay there and just rent the 2 flat out as an investor/landlord. My bet is some investors have lied in the past and received residential loans (lower rate) even when they never intended to live in the place.

But as long as you explain what you did here, that the entire reason you are buying is because of the proximity to the kid's school, it all makes sense.
Related Discussions
I'm very nervous
Q
Comments (20)
Sitting on the edge of the nest, no doubt the young bird's heart goes pitter-patter ... ... but then comes the exhileration of flying! Of coasting on the buoyancy of the air! Think of the expanding horizons. Being a kid has its wonderful times - as does being a teen (at times). I said here a while ago that I thought that one of my major responsibilities as a parent was to help my child plan, prepare for and build independence. Someone agreed that she felt that to be one of our major responsilities, as well. It is hard to be the parent, seeing your young one take off - and I recall my daughter, prior to her final year of High School, going on exchange scholarship to Germany for a year. It was a wonderful experience for her - she still keeps in touch with her distant "family". That was less disrupting for me, as I'd been her non-resident parent for ten years or so, and had moved to the Prairies (a couple of thousand miles from her) a year or so earlier. Good wishes as you look forward to the future - and it is disconcerting, not knowing whither you're bound. Trust me - it'll work out well in the end ... for your Mom, as well. ole joyful
...See More
Determining price when there are no comps?
Q
Comments (101)
Yes, Try_Hard...there is more news & none of it good. It's gotten to be such a convoluted mess & taking so much time that we've engaged a REA to help play Sherlock Holmes. If we end up with a contract, we'll pay him 3%. Our counsel has told us on Monday that the builder filed a 'death bed' BK just before the foreclosure auction. I searched the online info & couldn't find it. I phoned the state's attorney at 4:30 p.m. on Friday before the auction to check for a BK filing & he told me nothing was filed. That's one of the things the REA will be doing...hunting down all of these docs & getting us hard copies. So, if the builder still owns the property adverse possession may not make any sense. We actually know where the builder is & how to contact him. We've not done it because we thought the property was foreclosed. There is a foreclosure deed at Town Hall. In the meantime, there's been some minor vandalism at the property. Somebody has shot what looks like a BB at the kitchen & broken a window. The glass isn't shattered but will need replacing. I go through periods where I'm excited & feel like we can make this happen & other days feel it's a lost cause. Hopefully, the REA can devote some time to sniffing out the trail. But, for now...the house is lost in a sea of AHM bankruptcy filings. I went to look another house yesterday. It's a colonial also. Built in 1799 & sitting on 6.5 beautiful acres. It does not have the view of Mystic Harbor but it's a lovely property. As nice as it is...I just didn't get that same feeling as when I first saw 'our' 1825 colonial. But, I'll drag DH over to look at this other one Sunday anyway. /tricia
...See More
How to find prices of comps?
Q
Comments (5)
Your username appears to indicate that you are in NY? If so, you can get sold property price info at your county clerk's office. (Presumably City Clerk, or whatever equivalent in NYC.) You need to know address, or owners' -previous or new - to access the data. A few counties are on-line with a private service that you have to pay for. But there you also need the owners' names. You could also ask at your local real property assessor's office. They may tell you if you catch them at a slack time. It's public info, but they are not set up to search for or dispense that data in bulk. Though come to think of it, you can buy computerized lists of assessment data by towns/cities and that shows recent sales, too. BTW, if you look at county clerk's office, the prices may or may not be on the actual deeds. But there is a way to convert the tax paid data into the purchase price. Where I am it's $4 tax levied per thousand of sale price, so, for instance a tax of $40 is equal to each 10K of sale price. And remember the recorded price may not accurately reflect concessions made by sellers, like paying buyers' closing costs or contributing to the downpayment. HTH, Molly~
...See More
Nervous about looking at FSBO--advice?
Q
Comments (18)
C J - I don't want this to sound rude and it is a bit presumptive, but it sounds like you are making a very common financial "mistake" when you are considering the loss you are going to take on your current home. I am not trying to be critical of you, and it is something that I have done many times myself. But the amount of money you paid for your current home shouldn't be a factor in whether or not you buy a new home. While it does certainly factor into whether or not you can afford the new home, it is a sunk cost (you can Google it, if you don't remember the term). All that matters, for the financial side of the decision, are the avoidable costs. The only thing you should consider is, will you be better off in the future if you buy the new house. I know people hate it when I go all math - but here I go. Suppose you paid $200,000 for your house, that is now only worth $150,000. You know if you wait 5 years the price will rise to break even and you can sell then, but you are considering purchasing a different house for $165,000. So all that really matters is what do you think the $165,000 will be worth in 5 years. If the $165,000 house will be worth more than $215,000, then financially you should buy it. Because the house will appreciate more than yours. This may not be what you are doing, you may be referring to affordability, and if so, I am just putting this in here for future readers.
...See More
both
Original Author
15 years ago
I understand the letter and we did a good job writting it and even said we would be willing to sign a occupancy form or anything that they could take the house away or increase the interest rate if we do not live in the whole thing. The letter we wrote included pics of the huge pile of boxes we have packed and lots more stuff.
But why does she need more comps? It appraised for 5,000.00 more that what we are paying. (The appraisor was not from Chicago and I think he under appraised it.)
And why is the appraisor dragging his feet and the Mortgage Broker does not care that we are upset!! My husband and I have credit scores above 800 and a great paying job. If they were ever going to try and get paid for a home sale you could not get better looking clients in this day when getting a loan is so hard. Thanks for listening. Amy
pamghatten
15 years ago
The letter of explanation is needed because you are moving from a Single Family dwelling to a 2-unit dwelling, and keeping the Single Family dwelling. Unfortunately for you, this was a scam used by many borrowers to acquire investment properties at owner-occupied financing terms. Since Lenders have been burned by these types of transactions, they are now heavily scrutinized. And everyone signs occupancy affidavits, and they are worth less than the paper they are written on. In bad times, those 2-unit "owner-occupied" really investment properties are the first to default. Since they really weren't owner-occupied.

As for the appraisal, the fact that the appraiser appraised it for $5,000 more than you bought it for really means nothing if he used comparable properties that really don't support that value. Lenders are having all kinds of problems with appriasals, and the comparable used to support property values, especially in declining markets.

Is this area a declining market?

The appraiser is probably taking so long because he used the best comparables he could find, and now can not find others to suipport the value he stated. This is also happening all the time.

I used to underwrite loans, years before all this mess happened. These days, I would probably counter-offer and offer you investment property terms, to protect my banks interest. (Sorry, this is not about you in particular, this is to protect my employer.) The bank really doesn't want this house back, nor to change terms in the future.

And if your mortgage broker doesn't seem concerned, then I would say they are not very customer-service oriented.

Underwriter asked for a letter and more comps. Nervous

Comments (4)

dave_donhoff

sweet_tea

Related Discussions

both
Original Author

pamghatten

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Underwriter asked for a letter and more comps. Nervous

Comments (4)

dave_donhoff

sweet_tea

Related Discussions

bothOriginal Author

pamghatten

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

both
Original Author