Trying to replace insulation in old house
AdamM321
18 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (19)
chuckr30
18 years agochuckr30
18 years agoRelated Discussions
Insulating an old home bang for the buck
Comments (5)someone needs to get into your attic and look around. the best scenerio would be to hire someone who can advise you as to your best options for your specific home. there are many energy raters in florida, you could make some calls and hire an independent third party. I don't know how it works with BPI, but as a Resnet energy rater we do inspection & testing for air leakage into the house, and duct leakage. there are two seperate testing dates, prior to any upgrade, and once upgrades are completed. the first to establish a baseline for your house, and advise on upgrades. the last is to verify that house leakage, duct leakage and any issues that were addressed accomplished what they were bid to do. as your house has both cinderblock and stick frame construction, and age of house I would suggest that you have considerable leakage. blower door & duct testing would measure and pinpoint the leakage areas, so that they can be addressed. a couple of cases of caulk can do wonders to reducing air leakge into the house. as can mastic sealing of ductwork. trying to heat and cool a leaky house is expensive. if you make the house tighter and reduce the duct leakage it is a good investment. when replacing a unit as old as yours with a more efficient unit could cause problems for ductwork in a vented attic. your existing ductwork's r-value is somewhere between R-2 & R-4. with new variable speed equipment the low speed of the unit will be colder than high speed. ductwork in a vented attic in our hot humid climate condensates. installing open cell foam to fill the roof rafters to full depth, and to cover the faces of the rafters is a good investment. this would make mastic sealing of ductwork viable as compared to upgrading ductwork to R-8. it would also put ductwork in a conditioned space as the attic is now unvented. if you can get a foam company that has worked with hvac contractors..or visaversa..you will be dealing with like minded people. it makes a difference. most of our house leakage is from the living to the attic space. moving the thermal (insulation) barrier to the roofline with foam also moves the air barrier to the roofline. so the recessed lights don't suck air from the attic. cost of foam is higher, and you should keep in mind that you still need to meet code. this is not the 3-4" average fill bid. R-values for La. are R-30 for attics we meet the cathedral attic code with 6-7" get several bids and ask to visit an ongoing or previous install. understand that while the depth is increased that once they are on the job and set up its a matter of spraying more product. it doesn't double the price. as to where it leaks in the walls of the house, the blower door test will pinpoint these areas for you. location of the leaks depend on construction of house. each house is different. best of luck....See MoreInsulating a 107yr old house
Comments (18)Adding another layer, or two, over the plaster will have the same detail-deadening effect on the inside as extra layers of stucco will on the outside. You'd have to move all your trim, fir out all your opening jambs (window and door) etc., to fix this but then you also must extend or re-wire your outlets and wall switches .... well, it's a big job! Re insulating to the max in the attic. I was not suggesting insulating the undersides of the roof, unless you have heated/conditioned space just under the roof. In that case it should probably be done, but you can't just tack up insulation under the roof sheathing. You must arrange to have some channeled air -baffled barriers between the top-side of the insulating material and the underside of the roof. Look for info about insulating a cathedral ceiling to see what I mean. As for the walls, if they aren't plastered up there, then I would rip out sheet rock or paneling and insulate and, more importantly for rooms at the top of the building, install a vapor barrier before reclosing the wall. I wouldn't insulate between the floor joists on the enclosed space, but of course I would between the floor joists of any unenclosed, unheated space. And I would consider using an insulating product with the highest R-value per inch of depth. When insulating (assuming you're are not doing the whole house) put your money and effort into the upper areas/surfaces first, and then cut the infiltration pathways by caulking and sealing like a demon. I'm not familiar with a stucco-coated house, but in a frame house with wood siding, you could see evidence of moisture being trapped in the walls when paint peels off the outside, or mold grows on the inside walls or your walls get stinky and moldy internally. Not a pleasant thought! Good planned ventilation (kitchen and bath fans, primarily) goes along way to fixing this issue. But you can also but vapor retardant paint on all your walls and ceilings, which reportedly helps a lot. Now for the op-ed on this subject: Plaster by itself, especially old plaster on wooden lath, can be a huge moisture mediator, all by itself. And hollow walls allow a good deal of vapor and air to move harmlessly to the outside. (At least in wood-clad house, I'm not familiar with stucco.) All the steps we take in closing up a house in the name of energy efficiency may, paradoxically, be somewhat interfering with the time-tested engineering of these old building systems. And certainly, I believe the standards that are used for new houses which require intense efforts at moisture/vapor management are successful and necessary in builings built of more complex man-made components. But I'm not so sure that one should blindly transfer the standards of one building system backwards to buildings of another construction system. The good news is that older buildings can be quite tolerant, and apparently unharmed, by tightening up and some insulating (especially of attics) without vapor barriers. Just be aware that you can, even in the laudable effort to improve energy costs and loss, create another problem. For myself, beyond the above steps, I try to achieve overall building energy efficiency in different ways, on other systems (heating, laundry, appliances, lighting) and "forgive" the energy inefficency I can't cure unless I tear down more of the still-intact wall covering materials. And naturally, whenever I have an occasion to open a wall for any reason, then that portion in insulated and vapor barriered before closing. I find one of the most satisfying things about living in and owning an old building is that it keeps me aware that there are many different solutions for things, and the latest and greatest modern notion may have nothing on what was common a hundred years ago. Have you looked into the useful series of Preservation Briefs from the National Park Service? I'll attach a link; many topics are available for free on-line and I've always found the info very helpful. They cover a wide range of topics including energy efficiency for old buildings, and most importantly in your case, care and repair of stucco (along with window repair, roof, plumbing, building assesment, etc.) HTH Molly Here is a link that might be useful: Series of Preservation Briefs, List of topics...See Moreinsulating our 100 year old house
Comments (15)The basic plan it to draw an imaginary line between the "inside" conditioned areas and the "outside" areas. Any place that those 2 meet, you want to seal up any air movement and then add a layer of insulation. (If you have plywood or similar on the floor, you might have to take that up temporarily to seal and add the insulation. ) For venting, you want vents at the lowest point and vents at the highest point and nothing obstructing air from flowing between the two. That way, cool air is pulled in from the bottom and hot air vents through the top. That keeps the attic cooler in summer and keeps heat from building up and melting snow in winter....See MoreTrying to heat our new old home
Comments (16)Pace, we seem to be twins! I also bought a 100 year old beat up 3200 sq ft house in Kentucky. My utility bill last January was $650, and that was after new windows, doors, etc. We had expected much better performance after spending tons on the renovation & so that bill motivated me to investigate our options. We have a gas furnace in the basement which is ducted to the first floor and a heat pump heat/ac unit in the attic which covers the upstairs. While the heat pump unit has been great for AC, it had been the driver of high winter bills. We’d had it serviced repeatedly, and they’d change the number of heat strips wired up, but still it didn’t heat that well and was costly. Eventually we learned there was a coolant leak in the outdoor unit & that unit was replaced. We had the utility company come out and do an energy audit and they gave us suggestions on where to insulate and air seal. With attic insulation, air sealing, and lots of HVAC service calls, things seem better, but this winter will be the test....See Moredadgardens
18 years agoAdamM321
18 years agoglassquilt
18 years agokennf
18 years agoerasmus_gw
18 years agosierraeast
18 years agokevinw1
18 years agoAdamM321
18 years agokevinw1
18 years agonfllifer
18 years agospambdamn_rich
18 years agoAdamM321
18 years agonfllifer
18 years agocissado
18 years agomrblandings
18 years agotrevis
18 years ago
Related Stories
GREEN BUILDINGEcofriendly Cool: Insulate With Wool, Cork, Old Denim and More
Learn about the pros and cons of healthier alternatives to fiberglass and foam, and when to consider an insulation switch
Full StoryMATERIALSInsulation Basics: What to Know About Spray Foam
Learn what exactly spray foam is, the pros and cons of using it and why you shouldn’t mess around with installation
Full StoryREMODELING GUIDESCool Your House (and Costs) With the Right Insulation
Insulation offers one of the best paybacks on your investment in your house. Here are some types to discuss with your contractor
Full StoryWINDOW TREATMENTSEasy Green: 9 Low-Cost Ways to Insulate Windows and Doors
Block drafts to boost both warmth and energy savings with these inexpensive but effective insulating strategies
Full StoryFURNITUREOld Furniture: Clean, Reupholster or Replace It?
A veteran upholstery cleaner weighs in on the options for found, inherited and thrift store furniture
Full StoryGREEN BUILDINGInsulation Basics: Designing for Temperature Extremes in Any Season
Stay comfy during unpredictable weather — and prevent unexpected bills — by efficiently insulating and shading your home
Full StoryGREEN BUILDINGInsulation Basics: Heat, R-Value and the Building Envelope
Learn how heat moves through a home and the materials that can stop it, to make sure your insulation is as effective as you think
Full StoryReplace Your Windows and Save Money — a How-to Guide
Reduce drafts to lower heating bills by swapping out old panes for new, in this DIY project for handy homeowners
Full StoryMOST POPULARKitchen Evolution: Work Zones Replace the Triangle
Want maximum efficiency in your kitchen? Consider forgoing the old-fashioned triangle in favor of task-specific zones
Full StoryHOUSEKEEPING10 Problems Your House May Be Trying to Show You
Ignore some of these signs and you may end up with major issues. We tell you which are normal and which are cause for concern
Full Story
willieP