good seafood batter/breading?

15 years ago

I developed a craving for fried shrimp a couple nights ago. I googled a recipe and was pretty disappointed with the results. It was too bready and thick. I'd like a thinner more "grainy" breading next time.

I can't find the exact recipe (that's NOT a bad thing though, recipes such as that SHOULD get lost), but it was something like this:

1 cup flour

1 egg

"some" ice cold water, forgot the amount

salt

pepper

dip shrimp in and fry

I was less than pleased with the results. I wonder if I should have used bread crumbs instead of a batter? What do the restuarants do? I forgot to take the tails off before frying so digging through all that bread to find the tail before eating the shrimp was a lot of work! I ended up throwing half of them away because I just couldn't stand the texture.

I guess that's what I get for not looking for a recipe here first!

What is your favorite seafood batter or breading recipe? Would you use the same one for say catfish as you would shrimp, or would you vary it?

Thanks :o)

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (13)

carrie2
15 years ago
I like panko crumbs for the third step of the three-step breading process. It's especially good for big shrimp.
arlinek
15 years ago
My favorite batter, hands down, is Tempura. Google it and there's lots of similar recipes. It's light and crispy - always served in Japanese restaurants. I'm almost positive (haven't made it in a while) that there's NO egg in it. Made with icy cold water, however, and the batter should be lumpy and NOT smooth when dipping the fish and veggies (if you're so inclined).

arline
Related Discussions
Fish/seafood frying flour mixture?
Q
Comments (8)
When this cajun goes to the fishing camp you can bet something is going into a black cast iron pot. Here's a recipe for fried fish which includes a bit of technique. If you try these please, let me know how they turned out for you. Dan Perfect Cajun Fried Fish Recipe By : Serving Size : 0 Preparation Time :0:00 Categories : Amount Measure Ingredient -- Preparation Method -------- ------------ -------------------------------- 2 cups yellow cornmeal 1 cup corn flour (aka unseasoned fish fry) 1/2 cup cornstarch 2 teaspoons onion powder 1 teaspoon garlic powder 3 teaspoons salt 1 teaspoon cayenne pepper 1/2 teaspoon black pepper 1 pound catfish fillet (smaller size) Mix all of the ingredients together in a large bowl until they are thoroughly blended. Then taste the mixture and readjust the seasonings according to your taste. You should be able to taste a hint of each seasoning. Now take the fillets, just wet them with water, not dipped in egg wash, and roll them thoroughly in the coating mix. Do not fry them fry them right away. Let them rest for 3 to 4 minutes so that the coating adheres to the fish. If you fry too soon, the cornstarch won't have the necessary time to bind the mixture and the coating will fall off in the pan as you fry. Also, the cornstarch needs to pick up a bit of water so upon frying it adds a crispy texture to the coating. When ready to fry, pour 2 cups of high quality vegetable oil or peanut oil into a pre-heated skillet (cast iron is best). Then bring the oil temperature up to 350 degrees (for best results use a thermometer). Then drop in the fish, frying them 2 minutes on the flat side (back bone side) and 1 minute on the round side (skin side). Turn again back on the other side and fry another 1 minute. Your fish should be crunchy and crispy in 4 minutes when fried as I've directed above. - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
...See More
Recipes for Fish/Seafood and Their Sauces - Week 2 January 2013
Q
Comments (17)
I make tartar sauce similar to Country Sunshine's, but I put chopped stuffed green olives in mine. Here is my recipe for Shrimp Gumbo. I don't measure anything, but this is the basics. 2 ribs celery 1 bell pepper 1 onion Chop and set aside. In heavy skillet or stock pot, make roux of approximately equal parts flour and oil. Bacon grease is actually best...so if you have that...use that. I'd say about 1/3 cup each or a little more. Stir without stopping over medium heat until roux is very brown, but do not burn. Don't stop stirring either. Add chopped celery, onion and bell pepper. Stir it in and turn off the heat. Transfer if using a skillet to pot or if using a stock pot, add 3 to 4 cans chicken broth. Stir until the roux is dissolved, and on low heat, add a small can of tomato sauce. You can add more or chopped tomatoes. I don't like tomato pieces in mine....so I go with the sauce. I just want it to color the gumbo. The gumbo will not have a pretty color at this stage, but will as you finish it. Bring to a boil and when the celery, onion, bell peppers are cooked done, add a bag of frozen, chopped okra. When the okra is done, add shrimp. I use a lot of shrimp...and if I have crabmeat, I put that in too. You can put in any kind of seafood. Some people put in sausage, but I don't because it over powers the flavor of the gumbo. When I don't have seafood, I use chicken. Season to taste. I use Tony Chachere's creole seasoning and thyme. Tony's is flavored salt, and I use it like salt when cooking. Do not over cook the shrimp. As soon as it turns pink, or the liquid starts to boil, turn it off. Sprinkle a liberal amount of gumbo file and stir in well. That will also change the color a little bit. Stir it well so it doesn't kind of make strings in the liquid. A handful of minced green onions is good to add now too...or parsley. Serve over hot, cooked rice. (When you make the rice, put a big lump of butter in it to give it richer flavor.) My husband shrimped for 45 years...we still have couple of shrimp boats. I have cooked hundreds of pots of gumbo and this is recipe that I have worked on over the years. You could make stock from the shrimp shells, but I have found that chicken broth gives it more flavor. It doesn't taste like chicken...so no worry there. A lot of people don't like okra because they think it is slimy. Frozen okra has been blanched...so it isn't slimy. You can use fresh okra too, and it won't be slimy but I doubt any one who doesn't eat okra would believe me...so I say use frozen.
...See More
Batter bread & muffin problem...And fav recipes!!
Q
Comments (11)
Well, I made some corn bread last night. 24 gem muffins and one mini-loaf. Kept mixing to an absolute minimum, there were plenty of lumps (like Mom always told me to leave alone) and the results were very tasty. Like I said before, good flavor and crumb, no tunnels. But still, I got the Sombrero look. Not as much as I have gotten with straight muffin recipes but there. The loaf had more of it than the gem muffins. The flour info is interesting. I knew different flours had different gluten levels (never could make a decent wheat loaf until I heard about adding a wee bit of gluten flour) but as I use the same flour from batch to batch, that in and of itself doesn't explain why this only happens sometimes! A couple of weeks ago, I made a pan of cornbread that looked beautiful...modestly and evenly domed. Sigh. Okay, promised Lemon Bread Recipe: Lemon Bread 1 c oil 2 c sugar 4 eggs 3 c flour 1/2 t baking soda 1/2 t salt 1 c buttermilk 1 c chopped walnuts (see my notes) 2 T grated lemon peel Topping: 1 c sugar 1/2 c lemon juice Cream oil and sugar together; add eggs, slightly beaten. Mix together flour, baking soda and salt. Beat into mixture, alternately with buttermilk, until smooth. Stir in chopped nuts and lemon peel. Spoon into greased 9"x5" pans. Bake for 1 hour in a 350 F preheated oven. Cool Slightly. Remove from pans. Heat topping ingredients until sugar is melted. Place loaves on pieces of foil. Pour topping over bread. Cool, wrap and store in refrigerator or freezer. Makes 2 loaves. The above is the recipe as it appears in, "The Tastes Of California Wine Country Napa/Sonoma, written and compiled by Sonnie Imes. It is a cookbook I've had for years, featuring recipes from various Bed & Breakfasts in that area. The Lemon Bread recipe comes from a place called, "Healdsburg Inn on the Plaza" which, to my knowledge still exists, though whether they still serve this bread is anyone's guess. My Notes: This bread is fine made with your basic lemon. But I far prefer Meyer Lemons for their rich flavor. I do not add walnuts for two reasons,for one thing, I've never cared for nuts in quick breads. They lose any crispness, becoming mere chewy lumps as far as I'm concerned. For the second thing, walnuts give me mini blisters on my tongue. I sometimes do add dried cranberries, plumped slightly in some sort of fruit liqueur. Most often, I just let the lemon flavor stand alone. One can always serve the bread with a fruit puree on the side or a good, home made jam. The recipe calls for you to "pour topping over bread." I have found that direction to be inadequate. Place the loaf in a large baking dish or serving dish, something that has sides to catch the liquid topping and large enough for room to spoon it up as it pools so you can drizzle it back onto the loaf. The loaves should absorb every bit of the topping. Turn the loaves on their sides to soak up pooled topping as well. The top and sides of the loaf should be well inundated. Just before serving, I sprinkle the loaves with lemon flavored powdered sugar. I make this by whirring sugar, more lemon peel (I grate extra when I make the loaves and leave it out to dry a bit while they bake) and a few drops of lemon extract in a spice grinder. Plain powdered sugar would do, of course. This must be done just before serving because the sticky topping will soak into the sugar if given time to do so, leaving it icky looking. This is wonderful served as a "strawberry shortcake" in lieu of the shortcake.
...See More
Need a good date nut quick bread
Q
Comments (26)
Here's the recipe I made. I would definitely make it again, perhaps with some adjustments to the baking time and not using so much baking soda. I might experiment with using a ban marie too. It came out of "An Apple A Day: Vegetarian Cooking by Doctor's Wives." which was published by the Woman's Auxiliary to the Alumni Association of Loma Linda University School of Medicine. Date Nut Bred from Mrs. Ezra Richards 1/2 cup softened butter 1 cup sugar (I used all dark brown sugar) 1 tsp. vanilla 1/4 tsp. lemon extract (I used 1/4 cup candied citron peels as I have some and am trying to use them up) 1 egg 2 cups sifted flour 1/2 tsp. salt (I used 1/4 tsp.) 1/2 cup chopped walnuts 1 cup chopped dates 1 cup hot water 1 tsp. soda (I used 1.5 tsp. but I think that was a mistake) (I added 1 tsp. pumpkin pie spice) Combine shortening, sugar, vanilla, lemon extract, and egg, then flour and salt. Mix well. (I creamed the sugar, eggs and butter and then combined the flour with the salt and chopped walnuts in a separate bowl). Cook and cool the dates and walnuts with the water (I just did the dates and the candied citron peel). Add the soda to the cooled dates and then combine them with the creamed shortening and flour mixture. Put into an oiled and floured loaf pan. (I used 9x5 one). Bake in a 400 degree oven for 15 min. and then reduce heat to 350 and bake for 45 min. longer. (I don't think this is necessary. I would bake the whole time at 350 which is what most quick breads call for.) This was my "go to" date recipe, but not what my husband asked for. Harvest Date Cake Makes 12 servings. Bake at 350 degrees for 30 min. in a 9" square greased and floured pan. 1 cup flour 1/2 cup whole wheat pastry flour 1 tsp. baking soda 1/2 tsp. salt (Combine dry ingredients.) 1/2 cup softened butter or margarine 1 cup packed brown sugar 1 egg 1 tsp. vanilla (Cream/mix together wet ingredients) 1 cup milk 1 cup cut up date pieces Add wet ingredients to flour mixture alternately with milk. Stir in dates. Add batter to pan. Top with topping. Bake as directed at top of recipe. Topping (Mix together) 1/2 cup semisweet chocolate pieces 1/4 cup chopped nuts 1 TBLSP brown sugar Here's the one I'm going to try next. I know it is not traditional. I'm not going to use the cans since I don't think they are necessary if you're not steaming, which this recipe does not call for. It makes a lot so I'm going to halve the recipe Boston Brown Bread from Americanprofile.com 6 (14-15 oz.) empty clean tin cans, coated with cooking spray 1 lb. chopped dates 2 tsp. baking soda 2 cups boiling water 2 cups sugar 1/2 cup shortening 2 eggs 4 cups sifted all purpose flour 1 cup chopped walnuts 1 cup raisins Preheat oven to 325 degrees. Coat the insides of the cans with cooking spray. Combine dates and baking soda in a bowl. Pour boiling water over the dates and let stand to cool at least 5 min. Combine sugar, shortening and eggs in a large bowl. Using a mixer, beat at med. high speed until creamy. Add date mixture and flour and stir until well blended. Add nuts and raisins, mix well. Fill cans about 2/3 full with batter. Bake 1 - 1.25 hours, until wooden toothpick inserted in the center comes out clean. Cool in cans on a rack for 15 min. Remove bread from pans to cool completely. Makes six loaves with six servings each. 170 calories per serving. 5g. fat, 3 g. protein, 32g carbohydrates, 2 g fiber, 75 mg. sodium.
...See More
Lars
15 years ago
Try using beer instead of water. I always put egg in mine, but I use one egg for 2/3 cup of flour. If I want it crispy, I use rice flour. You have to experiment to see how thin you want your batter - if it is too thick, add more beer.

Lars
User
15 years ago
Try just flour , salt, pepper and soda water. This works great too for a very light and crispy batter. You can also add garlic powder and other seasoning for whatever suits your taste.

Ann
khandi
15 years ago
The fish batter we really like is 1 cup dry pancake mix and 1 cup beer. Make sure your fish pieces are dry so batter adheres properly. Deep fry until golden.
lindasc
15 years ago
I salt mine and then just roll them in flour, the only way we like them. Egg makes them burn so we go the simplest way.
jimster
15 years ago
The restaurants here on Cape Cod invariably use "dry batter" as opposed to "wet". The batter is a 50/50 mix of cornmeal and flour with a little salt. Seafoods (fish, shrimp, scallops, clams, oysters) are dipped in milk or water, dredged in the batter, dipped in liquid again, dredged again, then deep fried. The crust is thin, crunchy and slightly crumbly. I think this is what you are looking for. The fish and chips around here is exceptionally good.

I also like panko crumbs, especially for shrimp. Dredge the shrimp in flour, dip in egg wash, coat with panko crumbs and fry. The seafood needs to be in small enough pieces to cook quickly, otherwise the coating will get too dark.

Tempura is good too. Arline gave you the essential pointers on that.

BTW, when I do these at home I shallow fry, except for tempura which I think must be deep fried.

Jim
teresa_nc7
15 years ago
Recently my sister fixed fried shrimp and I was invited to dinner! She soaked the shrimp in some beer, lifted them out with a strainer, and tossed them into some cornbread mix (Three Rivers brand) to lightly -very lightly - coat them, then fried in small batches in about 1-2 cups of hot peanut oil. Best I've had in a long time - and - we had homemade cocktail sauce and remoulade sauce served with the shrimp.
jimtex
15 years ago
This is the way I do it.
1 can Carnation milk
2 eggs
1 tbsp baking powder
2 tbsp vinegar
1 cup flour
Mix first four ingredients and add shrimp. Let marinate for 15 minutes or so. Dredge in flour seasoned how you like it and deep fry. This is from Tony Chachere's Cajun Country Cookbook and it's really good.
vacuumfreak
Original Author
15 years ago
Jimster... I did as you suggested and used half flour and half corn meal and seasoned it. I double dipped, using water before each dipping. Fried in vegetable oil (which I promptly spilled on my work khakis when I was cleaning the kitchen before work, that was fun). It was very crispy and very good... much better and easier than the terrible recipe that inspired me to create this thread several months ago. Next time, I think I'll use more flour and less corn meal, half and half is a little too much corn meal for me, but it was still delicious. I pulled the tails off beforehand and they were easier to cook and eat.

I know I'm reviving an old thread, but I just wanted to give feedback... I'm not experienced enough to give advice, but I think if I ever did, I'd like to know if it helped!
dixiedog_2007
15 years ago
vacuum I'm glad Jimster's recipe worked for you as it sounds good. I'm more like Ann though in only using flour. I like cornmeal but it is too much for me also at times. I use it for fish and shrimp.

Now I have a craving. I'm planning on shrimp cooked somehow tonight for dinner - possibly like this?
User
15 years ago
I've used this one of Joe's on shrimp. Very good and light.

Tempura Batter

2 1/4 Cup cake flour (I used regular AP)
1/2 Tsp baking soda
1 Tsp salt
2 Cup cold water
jimster
15 years ago
It was a pleasant surprise to see the new posts to this thread today. I'm glad you got a good result from that "recipe" and I'm glad you reported back on it.

Jim

good seafood batter/breading?

Comments (13)

carrie2

arlinek

Related Discussions

Lars

User

khandi

lindasc

jimster

teresa_nc7

jimtex

vacuumfreak
Original Author

dixiedog_2007

User

jimster

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

good seafood batter/breading?

Comments (13)

Related Discussions

vacuumfreakOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

vacuumfreak
Original Author