Can we save this floor?

11 years ago

DH and I have been refinishing our kitchen, totally DIY, since last Fall. We were about 95% done, and DH was putting in the sink when disaster hit. I'll skip the details and just tell you that we learned the hard way that our kitchen was plumbed by bypassing the shut off valve at the house. The floors are (were) brand new red oak engineered floating click lock, with a plywood (not MDF) core. The underlayment is silent blue, which is foam with foil on the back--no paper or felt. We shop vac's and dried the floors immediately after the fire dept left (long story, but even they had trouble shutting off the water to our house), and the damage restoration people were there walling off the area with plastic sheeting and setting up fans and dehumidifiers within a few hours. They were pretty confident they could save the floor as most of the water was cleaned up quickly. Per their instruction, we stayed out of the area as much as possible. So no one noticed until this morning, when they came back to get new moisture readings, that the dehumidifiers were not plugged in. I don't see any cupping or buckling (yet), but it looks like the finish on the ends of sides of some planks is wrinkling or looks puckered. I only notice this when I look at the floor at an angle. The moisture reading they took today were not good. I am just sick about this whole situation. The restoration folks are coming back tomorrow to take new readings, and we have another company, recommended by our insurance broker, coming for a second opinion. I don't want to replace the floor unless we have to, because I am so tired of having our house torn apart from renovations. The flooring goes under the new cabinets, so they would have to be removed if the flooring is replaced. At the same time, I don't want to waste time and money trying to fix floor that is not salvagable or that will only cause us problems down the road. Any advice?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

glennsfc
11 years ago
I am surprised that your new cabinets sit atop the floating floor. Are you sure that is what the flooring manufacturer recommends?

As for this water event and your new floor...it is probably a total loss and will have to be pulled out and replaced.

Good luck.
stephsgarden
Original Author
11 years ago
Actually never thought about what the flooring manufacturer recommended. If furniture and appliances can sit on a floor, why not cabinets? We toyed with the idea of putting the cabinets on plywood and tiling or laying floor around them, but even if we had done that before our little flood, we would still have to remove the cabinets to remove the wet ply from underneath. If we take up the floor, what would you recommend putting under the cabinets?
Related Discussions
Can we save my bonsai tree?
Q
Comments (3)
In case you did not find an answer yet, there is a link below that I found regarding health conditions and proper care for your tree. "Unhappy serissa bonsai trees shed their leaves," so this technically means your tree isn't completely unhappy, if it hasn't let go of its leaves yet. Keep it out of DIRECT sunlight, and not too much water. Having it indoors by a window might also be a good idea, so that it can recover in a stabilized environment (despite it being a good outdoor tree). Hope this helps. Here is a link that might be useful: Serissa Bonsai Trees
...See More
Is it dead, or can we save it?
Q
Comments (2)
I'm a bit puzzled by your reference to flowering. Holly is generally brought into homes at christmas for its berries. The flowers are rather insignificant and are different on male and female plants. Is this an Ilex aquifolium we are talking about? If so then it is unlikely to be flowering in winter. Can you post a picture on the 'Name that plant' forum and then people can tell you exactly what plant you have and how to care for it.
...See More
Is there any way we can still save our Mango Tree?
Q
Comments (4)
Thank you all! (Thank you, viper114, for your fine compliment). I have taken these photos several days ago. The Mango Tree seems to have lost its last few green leaves by now...this is so sad. However, our helper says it's still alive. Perhaps it is? The problem is that there seems to be a large hole beneath the uprooted soil. A member from another forum says that I could try putting compost and then watering it. Would you advise this? I have tried scratching the bark off the middle of the trunk. The wood underneath is dry and brown. It does not seem to be greenish, as you say. However, do trees actually have a "Greenish" layer beneath the bark? From what I know, it is normally light brown in color. I hope this tree is still alive. I feel so sad for great, beautiful things that go. Here is the roots section (you can see the hole underneath): Thank you once more for your advice! I do hope this tree sill has hope.
...See More
What can we reasonably "save for later" in a new build?
Q
Comments (60)
Honestly, you can get more finishes than you think from the outset if you're willing to put in the time, creativity and legwork. Are you at all handy? We are far from DIY experts and did quite a bit in our first home including installing dentil crown in our living room, changing out lighting and ceiling fans, painting several rooms, painting the walls and floor of the garage and sealing the cracks, and installing beadboard and chair rails in two of the bedrooms. We also shortened some IKEA Billy bookcases so they fit perfectly on a wall in our sitting room. Everyone who saw them thought they were built-in. Just by doing those simple DIY projects ourselves we saved thousands of dollars. Become familiar with when different stores and websites have their major sales and buy things then in advance instead of waiting until you need them. A friend of mine has a master spreadsheet of everything she needs for her build along with dimensions, budget for each and photos of the look she's going for. She cleaned out her attic and garage to store her purchases. Each week she makes the rounds at the local ReStore, Sears Scratch and Dent and other places. She's gotten to know the salespeople so well that some of them will alert her when sales are about to occur or when something comes in that she might like. For example, when the annual Elfa sale occurred she ordered all of her pantry and master closet shelving because she had already designed them online. When IKEA had their kitchen sale she bought cabinets for her laundry room. She found the perfect sideboard to convert into a guest room vanity at a church rummage sale. She can barely still get her car in the garage but her builder is shocked by how much under her allowances she is so far even though she's thus far gotten everything she wanted.
...See More
glennsfc
11 years ago
Your flooring manufacturer may say that it is OK to place cabinets on their floating product; what do they recommend? Perhaps your insurance adjuster or restoration contractor may have a differing opinion about the necessity of removing the cabinets, but removal is probably your only option, due to the fact that it is floating over the silent blue foam.

If the manufacturer says that cabinets must not sit on the flooring, then any exterior plywood panel of the same thickness as your flooring...or any other material that won't disintegrate when exposed to water (a cementious panel, such as that made by the James Hardie) would be acceptable. If the manufacturer says that cabinets can sit on your flooring (which I doubt is true), then no filler material would be needed.
stephsgarden
Original Author
11 years ago
Thanks. This was a tough lesson to learn about hardwood floors and water. After three kitchens with wood floors, I think we will be switching to tile. We will see what the adjuster says.
brickeyee
11 years ago
"I think we will be switching to tile. "

Walking on tile is like walking on concrete.

There is NO 'give' in the floor any more.

"If furniture and appliances can sit on a floor, why not cabinets? "

Furniture and appliances are not normally rigidly fastened in place like cabinets (even lowers should be attached to the wall).
rdw829
11 years ago
Stephsgarden - I saw your post on the kitchens board. I really expect that your insurance company will pay to replace everything. Wait and see what they say.

Can we save this floor?

Comments (6)

glennsfc

stephsgarden
Original Author

Related Discussions

glennsfc

stephsgarden
Original Author

brickeyee

rdw829

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Can we save this floor?

Comments (6)

glennsfc

stephsgardenOriginal Author

Related Discussions

glennsfc

stephsgardenOriginal Author

brickeyee

rdw829

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

stephsgarden
Original Author

stephsgarden
Original Author