new job offer, less salary?

20 years ago

I have received a job offer for a technical professional position. Problem is, it's about 4% less than my current salary.

I think its a great co. and opportunity. The position is very similar to my current job and even some extra responsibilites.

I would like to accept the position, but not for a pay cut. The base salary could be offset a little by a bonus program, but thats based on co. performance (and no guarantee). Also, the benefits are comparable to what I currently have.

FYI. They know my current salary because its on the job application. Also, commute time, distance, traffic and other stuff like that is the same.

Anyone delt with this type of situation? Had any success? I'm thinking this is an initial offer and theres room for negotiation. I just never receive an offer before less than my current salary. Maybe its just a sign of the times.

Anyway, looking for some successful tips and advice in salary negotiation. thanks,

-jasper

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

steve_o
20 years ago
My experience is that there's always room to negotiate. You are in the catbird seat right now: they've gone through whatever hoops they must to make you the offer; you're the candidate they want; if you say no, they have some work to do to make an offer to someone else.

So you can negotiate. You can mention that you think this job is a great opportunity, but that you're surprised that a job that takes advantage of your experience and even requires some extra responsibility on your part pays less than the job you now hold, and ask if there any room to improve the offer?

Remember that they don't have to pay you just in dollars. Maybe they can't play with the salary, but they should be able to offer you other things, like additional vacation time, or maybe to pay some insurance premiums for you, or to give you an amount of money for additional education (if you think you'll use it), or (depending on the level of this job) give you a company car or something. If all else fails, you can ask for a review in three or six months or such, with an adjustment to your salary at that time.

Whatever you do, make sure you get it in writing. Make sure it is part of your offer letter, even if they have to reissue it. Without that, you really don't have anything you can count on.

I have used this strategy successfully in the past, at my present employer (at which it seems everyone comes in at the same grade level, regardless of applicable experience) and with one of my ex-wife's employers (who offered her what she was making at her then-present job, but which would have been a pay cut after paying for parking downtown; we asked them to gross up her salary to pay for parking, and they agreed).
jasper_60103
Original Author
20 years ago
Hi Steve.
You make some good points. It really was a tough interview too. I had to grow through 3 sets of panel interviews. I feel I'm a pretty strong candidate for this position. I'll follow up Monday and see if they'll sweeten the deal. Thanks for the tips.
-jasper
Related Discussions
Job offer...
Q
Comments (17)
Well it is a sales position and what the guy talked about was eventually working to to a VP Denny said "what made him offer you a job?" ...Jeff kind of laughed and said..."he had lunch with me.." As if he is so unresitable...LOL I could tell you what the name of the company is but probably shouldn't...it orignated in Canada But each are individually owned and operated.
...See More
Don't like my new job... advice
Q
Comments (9)
oooh boy, you sound just like me a few months ago; and sometimes even now. I went from companies with at least 200 employees, to over 5,000. Now I'm working for a very small company with less than 50 people. It is really tough. I've tried everything. It's been difficult to balance having absolutely nothing to do for weeks on end, against my mortgage payment - LOL. Not sure if you have been able to talk to you manager or not but I know first hand that's not always the best thing to do, politically. But it might be worth a try. Maybe you could start looking for another position while you don't have much going on. Most hiring managers will understand your situation. The other thing - you may not even have to include them on your resume, if you change jobs soon. Best wishes to you - I really, really, really, know your pain. It's OK to feel that way, and to want to change. Just don't do it until you have another job - a SIGNED offer letter in your hand.
...See More
Salaries back then....,
Q
Comments (34)
I remember back in school when one of the teachers was telling us that they have their annual salary divided up over 12 months. I still remember the shock that went through me, even at that young age thinking "Just how ridiculous is that!" LOL It absolutely flabbergasted me that someone would defer payment of what they were owed, and for no real reason. I later figured out the reason was simply that they didn't know how to handle money. Same with the ideas of paying more into income tax to get a bigger refund at tax time or saving $1 bills (or quarters or change) and then cashing that in. It truly amazes me what some people do. I understand today that most kids are so spoiled by parents who think nothing of going into near-insurmountable debt so they have the toys they want but I would have thought that people in those days would have had the benefit I had of parents/grandparents/relatives who lived through the drought and depression days and that they would have been taught simple basic money handling skills. Looking back I guess it's true that some are born to ignorance and others have ignorance thrust upon them. When I worked for the school district I recall some people talking about paychecks. We were paid twice a month, which caused some people enough trouble since some months had 5 weeks and they didn't know what to do about bills. One secretary nearly floored me when she started ranting that her husband was paid every 2 weeks and we were only paid twice a month. "We're getting cheated out of TWO PAYCHECKS!" And she was serious. And she complained how they can only get by because her husband got the extra two paychecks she didn't. She honestly thought she was getting paid a lower salary because of the pay period. I attributed it to another humiliation of the public school system but genetics had to play a part in it too. Comparing costs and such to "then dollars vs today dollars" is pretty iffy at best. Different things inflated at different prices. Plus there was interest paid on savings and even checking accounts back when. Now that's effectively eliminated. So you need to exercise caution when you do such comparisons.
...See More
Remembering salaries
Q
Comments (36)
My first job circa 1948 was driving a tractor for a farmer during the busy seasons. I got $4 per day plus transportation to and from work and a noon meal. While in high school, my next job was a grease monkey at a service station. I worked 3 hr after school and closed the station. On Saturday, I had an 8hr day. I'm not sure what the pay was. It might have been $1 per hr. My senior year, I upgraded to a grocer carry-out and stock boy for about $1.25 per hr and no tips. That was a 6 day per week job during the summer. Obviously, there was no future in any of these jobs, but it was the best available in my area at the time. Along the way, I picked up a 1929 Model A Ford for basic transportation. I spent $5 to replace a burnt exhaust valve after which, that car provided 5 more years of service; 3 yr while I owned it and 2 more by my parents after I left home. After high school. I won a berth in an engineering training program at Rock Island Arsenal. There, I made barely enough to pay for college and living expenses. Folks back home thought that I had stepped up considerably financially, and I suppose that I did considering what was available back home in an economically depressed area.
...See More
aikidokap
20 years ago
Well...and this is the tough one for people to answer...ummm..err...

Are you sure you're working for what you're worth NOW?

I've often dealt with this where I get a great candidate that was doing a great job at his last place, but somehow had been hired at a very inflated rate there.

Now, I have a range to work with, but if it's way out of whack, I just can't stretch that far.

But, one thing I believe is that even if you get people at cut rates, they won't be loyal. I'm not saying that you should pay them a premium over competitors, but honestly...if they get you to accept that offer, do they really think you won't jump shift for any offer that comes along?

You'll see that a lot when the market is flooded, but not right now.

FYI, I'm a technology director for a large law firm and I interviewed a guy just this afternoon!

aiki
jasper_60103
Original Author
20 years ago
aiki,
actually I'm not sure how my salary compares in todays market. In the past, my salary was always at the very low end of the pay scale. But the last 5 years, the economy has not been kind to technology companies.

Anyway, just to update. They weren't willing to negotiate, so I had to decline the offer. Not just because of the salary, but when I compared the entire pkg (salary + cost of benefits + other) with what I currently have. It just falls too short.

Thanks for your comments.
jasper

new job offer, less salary?

Comments (4)

steve_o

jasper_60103
Original Author

Related Discussions

aikidokap

jasper_60103
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

new job offer, less salary?

Comments (4)

steve_o

jasper_60103Original Author

Related Discussions

aikidokap

jasper_60103Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

jasper_60103
Original Author

jasper_60103
Original Author