Decontented - Kitchenaid French Door No Ice/Water in Door

11 years ago

We are shopping for a standard-depth french door fridge with no ice/water in the door, but the little water dispenser inside the fridge. We are considering the Samsung RF261BEAE or the KitchenAid Architect KBFS25EW. DH likes the American brands, and also we are very concerned with all the reports that if something goes wrong with the Samsung fridge, it is very difficult to source parts and that Samsung itself is completely uncooperative.

One store we went to did not have on the floor the KA FD without water/ice in the door, but did have several KA FDs with the water/ice in the door. We liked the interior of those, and the drawers and bins were better quality than the Whirlpool and Whirlpool Gold models on the floor. DH's pet peeve is when the drawers do not have rollers and the plastic is thin and seems easily breakable. The KA interior was nice, so our minds were made up, at least at that point.

Then we went to another store that did have the KA KBFS25EW on the floor. To our surprise, the interior was the same as the bottom-of-the-line Whirlpool. The freezer baskets were rickety too. It looks like KA completely de-contented for its standard-depth FD without ice/water in the door. What the hey?

We also like the Electrolux, but they do not offer a fridge that has an interior water dispenser. We will look at Kenmore - they appear to offer only one with interior water dispenser, the 72013 (looks to be a re-badged Whirlpool) to see if it has a nicer interior. Anyone know of a FD fridge without ice/water in the door, an interior water dispenser, and nice drawers/bins? (P.S. GE fridge is not in the running; been there, done that, never again)

Kitchenaid KBFS25EW FD Fridge

Kenmore 72013 FD Fridge

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (3)

mydreamhome
11 years ago
We have a Kenmore Elite badged Samsung fridge and love it. We needed a CD model, and at the time they didn't make the FD in CD so ours is a SxS. My grandparents have the FD full depth Samsung fridge with the dual freezer drawers. We have had 0 problems with our fridges and are very pleased with our purchase. Remember as you're reading reviews, that usually more people take the time to write negative reviews of products than people who are happy with their purchase. It's a way venting their frustration. Not to say that people who are happy with their purchase don't post reviews, just that unhappy people are more likely to post them. I would keep that in mind as you're reading reviews online.

I did a little research for you on the KA FD freezer drawers. It looks like they do offer the solid freezer drawers on the following model that includes your other specs. However, you lose some space as it's 19.6cuft vs the 24.8cuft you listed above (it's 30" wide vs. 36" wide).

KitchenAid Architect Series II KFFS20EY

These two models offer mats in the bottom of the wire freezer baskets-

KitchenAid Proline Series KFCP22EXMP

KitchenAid Architect Series II KFCS22EVMS

How important is the water dispenser to you? If you can live without it, you may want to consider this FD fridge from LG:

LG LFC25765

So it sounds like your choices are:
- Go with Samsung and get everything you want. On the off chance you need a repair you may have a delay.

-Go with a KA model with wire shelves in the freezer

-Go with the smaller KA fridge to get the solid shelves in the freezer, but sacrifice storage space

-Go with a KA model with in the door ice/water to get the solid freezer shelves without having to sacrifice space

-Go with a fridge like the LG to get the solid freezer shelves, but sacrifice the internal water dispenser

Hope this helps!
alwaysfixin
Original Author
11 years ago
Thank you Mydreamhome for all your information, and insight. Two things we must have are 36" width (there is a cabinet surround), and interior water dispenser. That leaves us with the KA, Samsung and Kenmore.

I noticed that the Whirlpool Gold GX5FHTXVY is the only one that is 115V instead of 120V (noticed on ajmadison website). Wondering if it makes a difference in performance.
Related Discussions
French Door Fridge with ice in door question
Q
Comments (9)
We have the water/ice on the outside of our FD fridge. I have four kids who drink mostly water, so having water on the inside would have resulted in my fridge constantly being opened. I could do without having the ice dispenser but finding a fridge that had just water on the door but with other features we wanted was too hard to find. I was worried about the ice dispenser taking up a lot of room, but we went with a very big fridge (29 cu ft) due to our family size. The ice/water dispenser does not take up much room on the inside of the fridge - in fact, we have plenty of space inside our fridge. I was more worried about losing space on the inside of the door for condiments, but with the model we bought, we still have plenty of room on both doors for what we need. I looked at quite a few manufacturers, narrowed down to the LG and Samsung, but didn't like the drawers on the LG at all. We have had the Samsung now for three months and so far, so good. I love it. I was recently at an appliance store looking at ranges/DW and somehow got to talking to the rep about refrigerators. I happened to look at a GE Profile on the floor and it was EXACTLY like my Samsung, except the design of the door dispenser was different. THe interior was exactly the same. Turns out Samsung makes the GE Profile fridges, though the Profile is more expensive than my Samsung was. If you haven't already looked at the Samsung or GE Profile, check them out. Though the ice machine looks like it takes up a lot of room, it really doesn't and there is still plenty of room on the door for condiments - at the top the shelf is very small, but I put my smallest items there. Truthfully, I feel like I have more storage on the doors now than I did with my old side by side.
...See More
french door fridge with SEPARATE ice and water dispenser?
Q
Comments (1)
We just got a French door freezer-bottom Samsung..very large, regular depth, not counter. Water and ice dispenser aren't separate, but a nice feature is that it has a 2nd ice-maker in the freezer...we love it.
...See More
Maytag French Door Fridge w/o Ice/Water in door -Anybody own it?
Q
Comments (2)
We have a Maytag Performa single door that is now our basement fridge since we remodeled & put in a KA counter depth French Door in the kitchen. Obviously, I don't have the direct experience you are looking for a recent Maytag FD, but I might be able to comment on several of your questions since both are now made by the same American company. Our Maytag is probably 7 years old & may have been manufactured prior to Whirlpool purchasing, thus some of my experience may not apply. The price seems great for a French Door fridge so if you don't need the bells & whistles this might be just the one for you. My experience with French Door is that the closing & sealing is hard to get used to. I do not think it is elegant on any brand. I still check our KA periodically, but I think it is FD, not the Maytag. The next time you are in a showroom open & close several of the FD refrigerators. You may have the same experience with all of them. We did have ice fall to the bottom of the Maytag because of the baskets, but I don't remember it being a problem -- sometimes the ice evaporates or shrinks in size before you know it is there. We fill our freezers quite full & often have small items pop over the baskets/containers. I felt the Maytag was easier to retreive items from under the basket than the KA is. My memory of ice for the Maytag was that the ice container was HUGE giving us more ice than we required. I used some other smaller container & had plenty of ice & more freezer space. I cannot remember it being particularly noisy, but our floorplan is not an open one. One issue I did have is since it wasn't digital (but didn't understand until I got a digital one) is veggies would freeze when we traveled. I ultimately would turn the temp up a few degrees to accomodate for the door not being opened during our absence. In all my refrigerators I have to work with the shelf arrangement to assure air is flowing properly. It seems initially I invariably have air blocked & freeze a few items until I can rearrange the shelves to make sure I'm not concentrating air in any one place. I love it when I can save enough on one applicance to justify (or purchase) another one. I say "go for it!". It sounds like your expecations will be met. Good luck.
...See More
A Word to the Wise re: French Door Fridge In-Door Ice Dispensers
Q
Comments (16)
I would just like to comment even though this is an older thread. French door refrigerators with in-the-door ice dispensers are known to have problems. This is due to the ice maker being located in the refrigerator area rather than the freezer area. All brands have problems. We had to replace our Samsung french door refrigerator after two years because of recurrent problems with ice buildup around the ice maker making it unusable. Samsung repairmen came out several times, the last time even replacing the entire ice maker but to no avail. After much research I learned that these all have problems despite the brand and although not everyone who has a French door refrigerator with an in-the-door ice dispenser will have problems, these types of refrigerators have an inordinate amount of issues necessitating repair or replacement. We finally bought a French door refrigerator with the ice maker in the bottom and have no problems.
...See More
dadoes
11 years ago
115v rating is no consequence. U.S. current is 120v standard. The electric circuit feeds voltage to the refrigerator (or whatever device is connected) at whatever voltage level is provided by the power company. There's no way for the device to "reject" the extra 5 volts and "take" only 115v on a 120v circuit.

Decontented - Kitchenaid French Door No Ice/Water in Door

Comments (3)

mydreamhome

alwaysfixin
Original Author

Related Discussions

dadoes

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Decontented - Kitchenaid French Door No Ice/Water in Door

Comments (3)

mydreamhome

alwaysfixinOriginal Author

Related Discussions

dadoes

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

alwaysfixin
Original Author