Daylight tends to wash out colors, so the whites you mentioned might be too white. I'm not sure what end result you're hoping for. Your windows are white, so it's possible that one or all of those whites won't look good with your windows. Close, but not quite the same white can be jarring. White on white doesn't work on every house. I don't think it's what I would choose for yours. I wouldn't outline the columns on the front porch this time around, or any of the corners. I would paint your roof trim the same color you choose for the rest of your trim. The faux rafter tails over the arched front window look odd. See if you can remove them before painting.

Use the brick as a guideline when deciding which colors to sample. Sampling is very important. Try one of the whites you mentioned to see if you're really going to like it. If not, move on to colors that might seem at first glance to be too dark as they might really be what you want. What you have now looks a little peachy. I assume that's what you want to move away from. I think a lot of BM's Historical colors are great for exteriors.

“If not, move on to colors that might seem at first glance to be too dark as they might really be what you want.”

Good advice. The whites you mentioned can often look very light/bright on the exterior. One we’ve used on the exterior is BM Swiss Coffee. It can transform into very white outside.

Thanks for the feedback!

I just picked up 6 paint samples, leaning towards some of the darker off-white / greiges, to test in different parts of the house to see how they also look at different times of day. This being my first time around painting a house exterior, I had no idea just how much paint colors get washed out in the sunlight vs how they look on interior walls.

I'm definitely leaning more towards keeping the colors the same on siding and window trim. Will play around a bit with the gutters as my wife is looking for some contrast / to blend the roof in. Maybe also worth noting that the windows are being replaced with new ones that do not have the grids.