On what I can see of your house, I dont see black on your house. Leave the trim white like it is. I am very sorry, but, I hate the garage door. It looks fake, and isnt attractive.. I would paint the garage door, the same color as the siding, so it all blends together, and the garage doesnt jump out as the first thing a person sees, when they look at the house.

I think Repose Gray might be too dark. Your stone is very light. If you use something on the rest of the house that is much darker you will accentuate the different surfaces. Unless that's what you want, I would first of all remove the shutters for good and then try something close to the mortar color. The roof trim could be done in the darker color. I agree with Ron that you should only be looking at DE instead of trying to color match. Get chips that are close to Repose Gray, but lighter, and paint a sample board (about ten square feet) with it. Then you can move the board around and look at it on all sides of your house. You can't get the same effect from a paint chip, and you don't want to waste your money having a contractor paint your house a color you don't like. If you end up wanting it to be redone, chances are he already has another job he has to get to, so a redo might not be as easy as you think.

The two large windows that jut out, and the roof material above them, are of a much more modern vein than the rest of the house. I think that is part of what you are reacting to in addition to the black looking harsh. Yes, paint them the same color as the body of the house. Then see how you feel. Adding black mullions to them that echo the mullions on the front door may help bridge their modern look with the more cottage vibe you want. Adding corbels, at this point is going to look like - well, last minute add ons that don't make much sense. Hire someone who can do a fast and good visualization of the black parts painted the body color, and include the addition of some landscaping along the lines of what you will actually use. It will save you money.

Hi there! For a fresh and stylish update that complements the existing blue and brick while also being good for resale, consider these options: Soft gray: This versatile color pairs well with blue and brick, offering a modern, neutral backdrop. It’s also a safe choice for resale, giving your home a contemporary look. Warm beige or taupe: These colors add warmth and blend nicely with brick. They provide a subtle contrast to blue without being too bold, making them a good choice for both personal style and resale value. Sage green: For a touch of color that’s still sophisticated, sage green can offer a fresh look. It complements both blue and brick and adds a bit of character while remaining appealing to future buyers. Charcoal: If you’re looking for something more dramatic, charcoal can create a sleek, modern appearance. It pairs well with brick and blue and tends to have broad appeal for resale. Classic white: A timeless choice that brightens up any exterior and creates a clean contrast with brick and blue. It’s always a safe option for resale and offers a fresh, crisp look. It might be helpful to test a few paint samples on a small section of your house to see how they interact with your existing colors and how they look in different lighting. Reach out to me on my Houzz profile if you need professional design help.