Yes, I was not loving the frame but it was available and thought it would go. I have an oil print Salvador Dali like, really funky in mylibrary(next room.) The paint escapes me now, but it is Ben moore, brown greenish. I will try to look online and find for you rose. What shape of a rug would you do? colors? Looked up those ceramic stools, colors don't work but I like the way you think teacats of that dimension outside of wood. Great idea!

A couple of possible situations come to mind: 1. A. The switch is on the common conductor, rather that the hot conductor. AND B. There is a partially conductive short to ground somewhere between the switch and the second light. 2. There is a partially conductive short from the hot side of another circuit to the hot side of the light circuit somewhere after the switch. I would use a volt-ohm meter to see what voltages I have, especially where I shouldn't have any.

"...Not everything needs to be matchy-matchy..." No, of course not. And if folks will read my comments, I didn't suggest "matching". What I suggested was to get light fixtures with "similar" characteristics--not matching. The OP's suggested foyer fixture has "bling" sides and an opaque base. The exterior form is hard edged. Of course, everyone is free to choose whatever light fixtures they please. But the OP asked if the two fixtures "coordinate". The answer is no. They contrast, not coordinate. Just my mileage since the OP asked. YMMV! :-)

True about the LED bulbs. And I agree about hating an off-center chandelier. That would drive me absolutely nuts! I was just on the Aladdin light lift website and they make lifts that are "remote mount." That might work in this situation. My contractor is looking into it.