Nothing beat JCP in my book. Maybe because I worked the largest men's department in the Midwest at the West Acres Mall in Fargo ND for sooo many years from high school all the way through college, but their selection and bang for your buck could not be beat. Their catalog was fabulous and their sizing was always dependable. The discount was good too!! Alas they like soooo many companies they are not what they were and I have yet to find as dependable or depth in any other newer hipper franchise.

I have some very nice quality long sleeve and 3/4 sleeve T shirts from LL Bean bought in the last couple of years. Not sure about the turtlenecks because I live in the south!

I really like J Crew Outlet, L’artiste long sleeve t’s. I have several, the length is generous.

Boden, j crew, ll bean maybe, weirdo names on Amazon, Talbot's, Garnet Hill maybe. Banana Republic made me mad with the latest sweater so they are firmly off the list.

Oh, Eddie Bauer for a lot of things, just nothing particularly stylish.

Like you, Funky, I shop online mostly. Not because I can’t get there, but because I live so far away from good choices. Here are my suggestions for you.

TALBOT’S:

I have discovered that Talbot’s Chatham style pants fit me well. I cannot wear their other styles. I have the Chatham in black, navy, white, beige, olive green and dress denim. I also bought a pair of bright blue on sale. What was I thinking???

I like Talbot’s Slim Ankle Jeans. I have myriad shades of blue, plus black, white, gray, and vanilla. Although they are called ”Slim,” they are really more of a straight leg. I also wear their Sculpt pull-on jeggings, but with styles changing I doubt I’ll buy any more jeggings. Unfortunately, you have to poke around the site to find all of the colors available for both the Chatham pants and the jeans.

I like Talbot’s pima cotton tees. I buy standard short-sleeve tees, bateau neck 3/4 sleeve tees, and crewneck long-sleeve tees. Search on ”pima” to see all that are available. Again, Talbots doesn’t put all of the available colors for one style together. I would guess that I have something in the nieghborhood of 2 dozen long or 3/4 sleeve tees in a variety of colors.

Shipping is a flat fee for however much you buy. From time to time, shipping is free if you buy $X amount. If there is a Talbots not too far from you, perhaps someone could make the returns at the store for you, so you can order a variety of styles and sizes to see what works for you.

LANDS’ END:

I like Lands’ End pima tee shirts. They are so soft! But they are also very long in the body.

LLBEAN:

I like LL Bean t-shirts, too, but I haven’t ordered any from them lately.

If you are going to wear your t-shirts un-tucked with jeans, consider a belt like this to keep from wearing a hole in your t-shirts. I actually shift the buckle slight off center too keep from having extra bulk front an center. https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00SXA4SW0/ref=ppx_yo_dt_b_search_asin_title?ie=UTF8&psc=1

Another person who's had good luck with Eddie Bauer clothing. Also look at their travel collection. I haven't bought anything recently as in the past few months. I usually do a good Black Friday haul from there, so that's something to keep in mind.

For basics like T's and leggings and jeggings, and some camisoles I rely on Uniqlo. My favorites to date are the light weight down anything, jean leggings, the camisoles with a built-in bra and the colorful array of mens' t-shirts. My husband likes to wear a t under his shirts or sweaters. Prices are great.

My new go to for upscale at a lower price is Otrium. I check it out everyday. I have wanted the European style long wax coat for the bad weather we have in winter here is Massachusetts. With an addditional 20% off the 60% off I scored a $695.00 coat for $114.00. Search the entire site, because it isn't the best designed one. Product comes in excellent packaging, free shipping, free returns.

6PM for shoes.

Amazon for jeans.

And for no-iron shirts, you can beat Chico's. It is the only thing I buy there, actually on line, and I start with the clearance. The white no iron long sleeve is a must staple. Wear it with a leather jacket, a blazer, alone, with a good pair of jeans.

I seldom wear cotton-y t’s or t-necks. Most of mine are tech fabrics I wear for athletic purposes and don’t fit your criteria. I do have a few I’ve bought for one reason or another and had good consistent size results from Eddie Bauer. Athleta is my go-to for pull-over shirts and their sizing is also consistent. I always look at the reviews for fit though and usually order tall sizes when available because of my long torso. And I love Athleta pants.

Jeans - a whole nuther story. I did find some Hudson wide leg pants I wore a lot this summer that I loved for fit and style. I’ve tried to find Hudson jeans I liked but so far no luck in my size.

If I need a bunch of basics, I'll head to the Talbots outlet that's within reach of me. I find Talbots stuff to generally be better quality. I have a VF outlet not far from me where I can go to try on lots of jeans (wrangler, lee) if I need them. If I need to try on lots of stuff, then going to the store is the only way for me to go. I can try on so much more than I could ever accomplish by mail order. (Plus all the wasteful packaging that comes with on-line shopping rubs the "eco" in me the wrong way.) LLBean quality is decent for basics too. Kohl's will carry Land's End stuff which has a lot of basics as well. I've found a lot of poor quality fabrics at Ann Taylor Loft so I'm really careful what I buy there. GF's swear by JJill, but I find their styling not for me, same with Chicos for me.

@Funkyart I have that same sweater in three colors (black, gray, amethyst) . It is oversized and comfy. Just did a quick check of TN’s and they are from either Jjill or Talbot’s. JJ are 95%pima w/5% spandex made in Peru

Talbots 100% pima cotton -Indonesia

LL Bean has decent quality as well as LE but as others have stated the sizing is inconsistent lately in all of these brands.

Is it that Chico's has a look you don't want? I don't go in there because the salespeople pounce and won't leave me alone. I won't shop in a place that does that.

I pretty much live in jeans, always have, always will. But I'm having a hard time finding ones that 1) don't have to be shortened and thus lose the correct leg shape, 2) don't have such a high stretch content. I really long for close to 100% cotton Levi's that fade over time. No pre-torn either. I cannot understand how mature women think it's a good look.

I wear cotton turtleneck tees all winter, as a base layer. Check out Old Navy and Penney's.

I also like J crew outlet. I seem to have better luck with their clothes and selection than regular J Crew. I do find, though, that some things are more generously sized and other things true to size, but once you figure that out, you should be good. I also like some of Loft tops, but find they either tend to shrink over time or the quality is suspect. I like the Eddie Bauer every day long sleeve t-shirts for wearing under sweaters or sweatshirts in the winter; they have a little give yet hug the body so they're comfortably warm.

won't leave me alone. I won't shop in a place that does that.

The one time I shopped ar Coldwater Creek, there was so much chatter and requests for email addresses, do I want a credit card, how will I style it (a $7 clearance tee 😆), etc. I had to say I have cash, can’t someone just take my money?!

I’m sure all that was required by HQ but the clerks should be able to drop it when the customer is clearly not interested. There was another customer also trying to answer her clerk but not really engage. He asked “where are you going to wear this? with what? did you see whatever (additional thing he was trying to sell)?”

I think that store doesn't exisit any more. The policy of friendly inquisition probably killed it.

hhireno, yes, I experienced similar in Coldwater Creek (long gone from my town). You'd cross their threshold and they'd call out a greeting from the other side of the store. Then tell me about all the good sales. I requested to be left alone.

@hhireno I could have written your comment.

Coldwater Creek always had a nice window display to draw me in but would annoy me with the ”Welcome to CWC” and then follow along with me asking too many questions. I’m the shopper who knows what she’s looking for and does not require or wish to be helped. Please just be available when I need to complete a purchase. Must be my advanced age.

There’s a distinct difference between friendly sales people (welcome, let me know if you need help) and whatever CWC was doing.

There was a photo online of a store (for make up, maybe) that had different colored shopping baskets to indicate wants help/no help. Brilliant.

I bought a screen print T at a Life is Good store while on vacation and liked the fit so much that I purchased several of their solids online when I returned home.

Nice, heavy cotton that isn't slinky or clingy and they hold up very well in the wash.

I'm 5'10" and veer to plus size, but can wear their XL and XXL (with room to spare). They have long sleeves in lots of colors.

I have been looking for a regular fit turtleneck in some basic colors-not too thin or tight fitting, as I have those already for certain outfits. I just ordered from Land's End, and this time I ordered in Tall (I'm 5'4") as I like sleeves long and longer waist because they seem to always shrink in those areas. I just need some basic and comfy turtlenecks to throw on with a pair of jeans in the Fall and Winter under a coat or jacket for everyday. Hope the Tall works.

I had a 50% off plus FS email from LE last week so I just HAD to order something. I opted for a new LS black pima cotton nightgown in Tall.I have one already and I like the length (5’7”)

I had a black turtleneck that was very stretchy-- a cotton blend but with lycra similar to legging material but not so compressive. It wasn't bodycon but it had shape and looked very sleek -- i think that is what I am looking for. I want some shape to some of my turtlenecks.

I do have some already -- mostly talbots but a few RL and other brands mixed in. They are great for everyday but some of them have way too much fabric (RL) and some are just glorified tshirts with a neck. I like them-- especially the white ones-- but it's a different look. More apres ski or wholesome girl next door than sophisticated chic out for the evening.

So I guess not so much basic as simple sophistication? For now, I am going to go with a black cashmere but still looking for the stretchy sleek one.

I haven't tried anything other than the turtlenecks from JCrew and that fail is on me because I missed the info on the "new shorter length" in the descripion.

I have high hopes for the one I ordered from Athleta. I am a big fan and have loved most of what I have ordered from them -- it should arrive later this week.

I did order this turtleneck sweater from Banana Republic and I like it alot-- but it is a sweater and also oversized. I am ordering another in a size down be closer to the fit on the model.

I can't even begin to talk about jeans! I still have a ways to go with my weight loss so I don't want to invest much in jeans now but I do want some smaller sizes to show off my losses to date. Thanks to RNmom, I found some wit and wisdom jeans that look great-- but they are out of stock. I ordered a similar pair a few days ago and then the order was cancelled as out of stock. I just ordered another pair from old navy because they were cheap lol. We'll see if they work out.

Thanks again for all the continued suggestions!

Odd, I posted to this thread last night but it's not on here. Anyway, Talbots has several turtlenecks in all different weights on line. Yesterday when I posted they were having a flash sale that let you stack 2 offers for roughly 50 % off.

Oh well, there will be other deals.

@Funkyart Now this gives you a chance to maybe make it to a store to try some styles on. Several run large so you may be able to wear an XL.

Oh I have tried (and own) all the Talbots turtlenecks -- my favorite isn't sold anymore though. The cotton turtlenecks are fine as very basic basics. I wear them under sweaters. I don't really like the ones with the button cuffs and the cashmere is fine but isn't as flattering as it could be. I am tempted by the sparkly metallics though ;)

@Funkyart I started to order one with the button cuffs. Why do you not like them? I did order a red longer one with a snowflake design. Red looks fab on me and I felt great in it. I will look like a snow bunny (an old snow bunny!) skiing over Christmas.

Another brand, which you might find on Zappos, is Mod O Doc (sp?). I have a few 3/4 sleeve cotton tops and they’ve help up well over the years.

Thanks, Sue.. I never heard of them but will check them out.

Gracefullyaged, my mother loves the Life is Good tees too-- I used to get her a pretty floral for each Bday/Mothers Day. They are a nice weight and love the colors!

RnMom .. the Talbots perfect turtlenecks get loose and roll down the neck-- not a good look for me. I prefer a high neck that stays put. Also, and I am prepared for the hate, I think the buttons on the cuff are matronly. The old design for their Perfect Turtlenecks had no buttons and the neck stayed put and had more elasticity. I still have one but it is on its last legs.

I agree with buttons. Cuffs, shoulders, pant legs. To me they look either matronly or military, neither of which is a look I’m after.

On sale at Lands’ End. Code HOWL for up to 50% off

Fitted: https://www.landsend.com/products/womens-lightweight-fitted-long-sleeve-turtleneck/id_302529?attributes=44967,47777

Shaped fit: https://www.landsend.com/products/womens-supima-cotton-long-sleeve-turtleneck/id_244120?attributes=2448,44967

I don’t know the difference between ”shaped” and ”fitted,” but I’ve always found LE to have excellent customer service.

Thanks, bbstx ... i am going to hold out and continue looking for the stretchy, lycra type turtleneck for now. In my mind and experience, it's a little more elevated.. a little more versatile.

I do have a handful of others similar to LE on order and in my closet but I will circle back if they are all fails.

Thank you!

Funky, you have made me laugh. i have a tired Talbots ribbed fuschia turtle that i love and have tried to replace. i got an end of season black one this spring—- with the buttons—- and now i will feel old, stodgy, and will think of you with each wearing!

The other garment I’ve tried to replace is a fine gauge Ann Taylor silk cardigan. Never find anything like it..

Funky, you might want to check out Prana and Eileen Fisher for stretchy turtle necks. At least in my experience, sizes run fairly true.

Funky, I lost 30 lbs last year (went from L/verging on size 16 to M/10), and live in rural Canada with no local stores so do a lot of shopping online. I first bought some Old Navy t-shirts because the price is right and returns are easy, and I was desperate for something that fit. Once I knew what my weight would be, I bought better quality tops from Lands End, LL Bean, Madewell, Uniqlo. Some brands that I like, like Talbots, J. Crew, Ann Taylor/Loft and Eileen Fisher, are hard to find or crazily expensive at least in my part of Canada, so I was thankful to discover Poshmark after I had lost weight; another benefit is finding vintage items from LL Bean, Lands End, Orvis, J. Crew, Thomas Pink that are much better quality than what's being made now. I also like Madewell t-shirts, which The Bay carries (often on sale) as well as Karen Scott; I like KS tops, both the t-shirts which tend to be a bit heavier as well as the sweaters/jackets.

Also, I think Lands End and LL Bean still offer tall sizes -- I bought some women's tall turtlenecks when I was pregnant years ago to make it over the bump.

I meant to add too that one thing I like about Poshmark is that so many sellers note the clothing measurements, like pit to pit and shoulder and length (and if they don't, you can ask for them). I wish this was common for everyone selling clothing.

My fave tneck from Anthro has many buttons up the sleeve and I luv it as do my DDs, who steal ... err borrow it.

I did forget, I buy Chicos white no iron button downs, on line. I think I convinced someone else here to try them? They have a pinch of lycra and are fitted.

I like J McLaughlin, I see them as a more upscale and more interesting Talbot vibe.

I did try a chicos shirt based on your rec mtnrd, but I seldom wear it. I like the fabric though it does need ironing, but there's something about the collar that bugs me. If it's buttoned it sits fine but looks too formal for my events. Unbuttoned, it doesn't sit well on me, kind of wimpy looking and it doesn't look good with my cardis. But my lifestyle is such that a shirt like that isn't needed much anymore anyway.

I, too, bought the Chico’s white shirt. I wear the collar almost popped. I don’t iron it. It would be crisper if I did, but I find it totally acceptable if I tumble it in the dryer for about 10 minutes then hang it to finish drying.

What I really don’t like about it is that the backside of the cuffs has started to ripple, as if the interlining is failing. It doesn’t render it unwearable, but it does require me to wear it with the cuffs turned back to hide the ripples. Has anyone else who bought this shirt noticed that theirs is doing the same?

I must have lower standards for ironing. bbstx, I’d return it. i wear button downs casually all the time w jeans.

Mtn, I’ve thought of returning it. I just wear it with jeans and flip the cuffs back which then shows the CC.

The buttons on THAT long sleeve is sweeeeeeeeeeeeeeeet! I've never tried Anthro....just browsed.....maybe.....

OK, I like both the anthro turtleneck and really love the sundance top. Maybe because they have plackets vs just throwing on some buttons?

There are definitely things I could wear 20 yr ago that looked cute then that look matronly on my 58 yo body. Plus, I admit.. I am picky and opinionated. I may love something on you and hate it for myself.

I do not look great in most button down shirts -- i suspect it is my body type. I have a very wide rib cage, broad shoulders and a pretty average bust. I love the look but it just doesn't work for me with a very few exceptions.

I have a friend who LOVES those Sundance tops, especially the ones with the prints. I haven't tried them yet, mostly because we already often inadvertently dress like twins.

The Anthro TN i bought a few yrs ago… not avail this yr.; too bad it was nice and fitted but comfy

^^^

This! I can't be sure until I've worn and washed more than once if I am pleased with something. By the time it gets my seal of approval it's no longer sold. Even if it's the same item sku# and all,

it's most often different fabric content, cut, factory or whatever.

Like on the old Rosanne, they say it's the same but it's not the same.

I went back to JCrew and realized there are multiple styles of TN .. the one I ordered is the ruched style. I am wearing one now with high waisted jeans and I think they will be fine as long as I stick with wearing them only with high waisted bottoms. They are otherwise generously cut. I have more than enough room in the neck/arms/shoulders etc. They are just shorter than i like. I suspect the ruching pulls them up ... and I am long waisted.

I may try one of the other styles

Salvona,

Buy two, don't wear the 2nd until you've tested the first, then return the second if necessary. Easy said than done. Often I don’t realize until much too late that an item is perfect. For casual tees & workout stuff, I’ve been buying extras right away so I can keep some at each house.

Funky, this might be helpful in identifying some new-to-you resources. I've tried to be more mindful as I rebuild my wardrobe after losing weight last year (I did buy some t-shirts at Old Navy as stopgaps on my journey, and I do wear them often), both to save money and to buy just what I would wear frequently, and a few months ago I discovered a fashion stylist on Twitter, Lakyn Carlton, https://www.lakyn.style and on Twitter at https://twitter.com/OgLakyn who writes a lot about sustainable fashion, including thrifting and avoiding fast fashion, and inclusive sizes.

She has a great list of women's clothing sources, Where 2 Shop: Womenswear, which is available as a Google Doc, for $1.99 US. She updates it often, and there are a number of businesses that do ship to Canada, which was a concern for me (there are also some Canadian shops, others overseas).

https://www.lakyn.style/shop

She has the stores broken down into the following categories, which I find helpful: Alternative, Athleisure/Lounge/Undies/Swim, Boho/Vintage-Inspired, Classics/Basics, Eclectic/Colorful, Feminine/Sexy, Formal/Bridal, Minimalist/Androgynous, Multi-Brand Retailers, Secondhand/Vintage, Accessories, Bags/Purses.

Best $1.99 I've spent in a long time : ) .

@Funkyart since you mentioned about still in process of weight loss and not wanting to spend a lot yet on clothes...I follow a youtuber that buys lots of luxury items BUT she was raving about how great these jeans are from Walmart for $17.98! I thought, what the heck and bought the darkest pair and they really are pretty darn good IMO! I actually went back online and bought the light pair. Anyway, if you don't like, easy to return.

https://www.walmart.com/ip/Time-and-Tru-Women-s-Mid-Rise-Straight-Jean/584558416?athbdg=L1100

Funky, I just thought about another resource….Eileen Fisher Renew. I didnt even know about this until a few months ago. I know you are also an EF fan and if you need a couple of basic sweaters, tops or pants at reasonable prices, this might be a good place to look. They tell you the condition, and if there are thread pulls or snags it will be noted. Most things are in like new condition and have been thoroughly cleaned. You do need to check fairly often as new items are added all the time. New customers get 15% off.

https://www.eileenfisherrenew.com/?gclid=Cj0KCQjwteOaBhDuARIsADBqRejCZmloctQbNyyy--wfYVUc_d6bLf7A-K4fEbmOyFv9zClP13V65AkaAiBgEALw_wcB

Thank you, @OllieJane! I never think about walmart for clothes but years ago, I used to love their lycra tshirts. I don't love Old Navy jeans but I do keep trying them. I'll check out the options at Walmart.

And thanks for the reminder, @OutsidePlaying. I always forget about EF renew. It is a great option for "transitional sizes" as I lose weight.

I have a number of turtlenecks arriving over the next two days-- have already received ones from Old Navy. They are thin but fine for everyday, wearing with pj bottoms or jeans. Still looking for a quality and look that will work for a casual party or dining out.

I've been wearing St John's Bay (JCPenney) basic 100% cotton short sleeve crew neck tees for a long time. Every two years, I order at least a dozen more -- half white and the rest in a variety of colors. Just like the colors change from year to year, there are sometimes minor changes in the cut/fit, sleeve length, and body length, but for me they're the perfect basic tee shirt. :)