Yep, paint colors really seem to lighten up in the outside so I would suggest looking at a black color that has a grey undertone to get what you want. If your dark greys are looking too light on your house then you should get the same effect picking a black with a grey undertone. Sorry I don't have any colors to suggest.

I really appreciate these suggestions and visuals - thank you! I will take pictures from some additional angles; the house is very boxy, and is currently one color of stucco all around, with one trim color (dark brown), with virtually no relief or break-up of that vast expanse of off-white stucco. I have been thinking about making the front porch body a shade or two lighter (or darker) than the body of the house to add a dimension/ depth; adding shutters to the 2nd floor windows is something I hadn't considered but helps add interest - thanks houssaon for that idea! Oh - there are no flower boxes on the 2nd floor - just on the outside of the enclosed front porch (which is basically the whole 1st floor you can see from this picture). OK, more to come soon - thank you for these suggestions!

I think a dark gray, or the darker charcoal would look nice. (then you can do the brick later) Maybe you could stain all of that pink brick w/a masonry stain and a sprayer. as you can see, the white is just too white Will you painting the brick at any time? perhaps go w/the gray and then the darker charcoal garage door would work. You already have the gray roof. Romabio masonry (not the Classico lime wash) paint for the brick. It's almost maintenance free, and has a 20 year guarantee. tint any color i did your brick w/this one. but maybe you like the white doors better w/the gray brick?

I'd go with sage green