Casey, For our main color we have Cabot solid color Mountain Brush (nice green-gray) with Navajo White trim (creamy vanilla). Our shakes are oil stain cedar and soffit/roof trim is terratone (darker browny bronze). Our shingles look black in the picture but are architectural style in Weathered Wood, more dark/light grays and brown in real life. The color combination you are thinking of would complement your black roof and house style. Picking house colors can be tough, but you seem right on track (of course I am biased). Jill Here is a link that might be useful: Cabot Stains

Grrr. You folks are making great points. Thank you. I am at war with those columns anyway. Mtn, thanks so much for the photos. That first one is similar to my home in front with multiple materials -- especially the siding on the garage which I have painted dark charcoal -- leading me to like a the "blackish" door. The second photo I had used for inspiration when considering brick painting. What about the "blackish" door options below .... I don't want half-half w/mutin bars as I have that now with blinds and it is wayyy too country for me. I am moving toward craftsmanship style or traditional/artsy fartsy -- maybe 3rd one?

Sorry, I know this is old but we are trying to pick our exterior colors and considering Dorian with a blue door. The finished pic you posted is completely different than the color in the posted visualizer pic correct? I love they way yours turned out but I don't like the color that it looks like in the one visualizer comments.

I will head in a bit of a different direction. I think your house would look beautiful with a black paint (garage doors too ☺️). Like SW7069 Iron Ore. I think it would look very chic. Then I would put a couple of black patio chairs on the porch, maybe with tan cushions. Accented with a couple of nice size pots with greenery. 😍 Love your porch!!!!