De-Leafing my Black Tulip Magnolia?

last year

I love my Black Tulip Magnolia! It has been in the ground 3 years now and has for the first time this summer really started expanding its branches. But ... I never saw a picture before I bought it showing how it looks AFTER it drops its blooms and leafs out. Although still very attractive, the dark green and super thick canopy of leaves looks very HEAVY to me.

So I'm wondering if I can remove some of the leaves in the middle of the tree to open it up a bit and show off its branches? I'd like to do it early summer after it leafs out and wouldn't remove any new buds which are forming.

What are your thoughts on this? Will doing this decrease the number of FLOWERS the following spring? I don't want to do that !!!

Also, wondering if I'll need to keep doing the leaf removal every year to maintain the same look or if in future years, the tree will automatically stop growing LEAVES where they have been removed.

Thank you!

The Greengoblin

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (8)

Toronado3800 Zone 6 St Louis
last year
Hello sir.

Is the Liriodendron tulipifera https://www.missouribotanicalgarden.org/PlantFinder/PlantFinderDetails.aspx?kempercode=a878 that we are talking about?

If so I say prune it shortly after it flowers for best flower production the next year though there may be other species specific health concerns I do not know about.

You'll be able to raise its canopy at will. Selective thinning will eventually require climbing. I like their natural look so maybe an every several year thing will do.

Far as it eliminating its shaded or lower branches, sort of. In a forest they absolutely do. In an opem yard they'll probably still thin themselves out but you'll have some branches that reach to the ground. They'll make mowing difficult but put them beautiful flowers at eye level. I'd try to go for a balance with mowing and flower visibility.
cecily 7A
last year
Magnolia soulangeana "Black Tulip" may be the OP's tree. It would be good to clarify that before we give pruning advice LOL.
Related Discussions
Black Tulip Magnolia has browning leaves - any ideas?
Q
Comments (7)
"This tree was planted about 2-3 months ago, with ammended soil in full sun." Generally, it's not good to amend the backfill soil when planting trees or shrubs. Amendments frequently cause drainage issues and root development problems. "I'm not sure what type of fertilizer it has been given, but nothing within the past week." Trees and shrubs don't often need to be fertilized. Improper fertilization can cause serious problems or death of the tree. Have you had a soil test that indicated a need for additional nutrients? When you say it hasn't had any fertilizer in at least a week, it sounds like it may have been receiving mega-doses of something prior to a week ago. Surely you aren't fertilizing the poor thing once a week! "It was watered for between 30 min to 1 hour every other day and looked fine until a few days ago." Wow, that sounds like a lot of water! Have you been checking soil moisture in between waterings? I don't know what kind of soil you have or how much water you have been supplying, but your description definitely raises a red flag for way way too much water. Are you sure you are not drowning the tree? Trees can die from too much water as easily as from too little. With the information given, it's impossible to say for sure what's happening with your tree, but it sounds like overwatering may be a likely suspect. Other planting issues may also have contributed to the problem. Details of how the tree was planted (planting depth, condition of roots at planting, how the roots were conditioned for planting, type of native soil, relative amount and type of backfill amendment, etc, etc) might lead to further insight. You may also want to carefully read the article linked below, for future reference and for possible help in further diagnosis. Here is a link that might be useful: Planting a Tree or Shrub
...See More
black tulip magnolia in So Cal
Q
Comments (6)
The USDA hardiness zones just address average low temperatures, not overall climate conditions - to find out if your area is suitable for this type of magnolia look at the information from Sunset. Sounds like your tree got dried out, or it came out of the shade and then burned due to a change in exposure. Otherwise it might have been burned by dry winds. Big box plant departments in my area are terrible about keeping stock trapped there watered, if you are seeing similar damage at the outlet to what you have it again may indicate your specimen got away from you one day. Leaving it in the pot is not the best way to fight with heat and drought, plants in pots are much more vulnerable to such conditions than are ones planted in the ground. Definitely be sure the sun does not beat on the pot and cook the roots. If you are not going to grow the tree in the ground then moving it up into a larger container should be undertaken before the summer drags on much longer. This post was edited by bboy on Fri, Jul 18, 14 at 14:44
...See More
Southern magnolia(Magnolia Grandiflora) tree leaf question
Q
Comments (20)
I've seen lots of DDB, it is a popular landscape tree in the SE. I've only seen one EB, my tree. EB's main claim to fame is it's supposed hardiness. Mine is in full sun and wide open, no large trees anywhere near it. It is about 20-25 years old from a one gallon. It is wider than high, branched to the ground, and fairly open with somewhat long willowy branches. It took a long time to bloom, and is even now a rather shy bloomer. Blooms are of average size. For me EB has been of average hardiness, it has never lost any wood or suffered any bark split, but it has had browned foliage, though never defoliated. On a scale of 1-5 I rate it 3. DDB is very popular and often seen in private landscapes and especially public ones. It is upright in youth and more spreading as it ages, but taller than wide. Foliage is deep glossy green above and copper/red beneath, especially when young. The tree presents a lush, rich appearance and is a vigorous grower. Floriferousness has been average, but blooms are well formed and slightly smaller than average, a good thing IMHO. Hardiness has been on a par with EB for me, the literature says less hardy than other hardy clones, zone 7. On a scale of 1-5 I rate it 5. All magnolias grown under conditions you describe will tend to be open, with slightly larger than average foliage and less than average bloom, all due to shade. If DDB and EB are the only clones under consideration, my choice would be DDB.
...See More
Help please! Magnolia tree, black plastic dilemma
Q
Comments (13)
the plastic is slowly killing the tree ... remove asap ... any root disturbance.. is irrelevant.. as to the long term increase of air.. water and nutrients .. and therein is the key.. roots need air as much as anything else ... and plastic does not allow air movement ... get a load of mulch and mulch properly after ... anything can be planted around the tree ... ken
...See More
sah67 (zone 5b - NY)
last year
last modified: last year
“Black Tulip” is a hybrid Magnolia, not a cultivar of M. soulangiana:

”sometimes listed as a selection of Magnolia x soulangiana, but its background is more complex than that. It is the result of a cross, made by Mark Jury, of 'Vulcan' as the seed parent and possibly 'Iolanthe' as the pollen parent (Gardiner, 2000). The background of these parents includes a number of Magnolia species.”

https://landscapeplants.oregonstate.edu/plants/magnolia-black-tulip
forno_chris
Original Author
last year
Thanks Toronado! Here's the tree: https://www.monrovia.com/black-tulip-magnolia.html

And here's a pic of what I'm talking about after it loses it's flowers:

https://www.pinterest.com/pin/569423946619045411/

It's located against a fence in a garden so no mowing required. ;)

I'm not necessarily looking to raise the canopy but rather remove leaves so that it doesn't just look like a wall of green. Would like to see the branches which will make it more interesting. Just want to make sure that when I remove the leaves in summer, that I'm not limiting the blooms next year.

Thanks Again!!
gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)
last year
last modified: last year
The leaves serve a purpose. You do not want to remove them if you value the long term health of the tree. And being a pretty small sized tree to begin with, the loss of any leaves during the growing season could very well have an adverse impact.

You can see the branches in winter and when the tree is in flower before the leaves emerge. But do not remove just for aesthetics!!
forno_chris
Original Author
last year
Good to know- glad that I asked! Thanks for the info Gardengal!
laceyvail 6A, WV
last year
In addition, magnolias tend to resent pruning.
ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
last year
i think you ought to go buy more plants.. and screw around with those.. and leave this poor thing alone.. lol...

a shrub with large potential can take 2 to 4 years to settle in .. and get growing to specs.. we call that getting established ....depending on how well you planted it ..

so your plant is not fully established ... and your only thing is.. im going to start cutting off the food making machines [leaves].. because i know better that it.. how it should grow ..

no.. no..no.. leave it alone.. and as stated above.. go buy more plants

and i suspect in 5 years.. you will love this plant as it is.. shrubs should be some of the most carefree plants i in the garden.. presuming you sited them properly from the gitgo ... [meaning you didnt plant then 2 feet from the foundation...lol]

now.... all that said... after it does get fully established .. and you want to start pruning it for aesthetics.. then knock yourself out ... its your plant.. in your garden.. and i approve you doing whatever you want to your plants ...

ken

De-Leafing my Black Tulip Magnolia?

Comments (8)

Toronado3800 Zone 6 St Louis

cecily 7A

Related Discussions

sah67 (zone 5b - NY)

forno_chris
Original Author

gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)

forno_chris
Original Author

laceyvail 6A, WV

ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

De-Leafing my Black Tulip Magnolia?

Comments (8)

Toronado3800 Zone 6 St Louis

cecily 7A

Related Discussions

sah67 (zone 5b - NY)

forno_chrisOriginal Author

gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)

forno_chrisOriginal Author

laceyvail 6A, WV

ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

forno_chris
Original Author

forno_chris
Original Author